New York City Pizza
45 Pembroke Dr #105, Hilton Head Island
(843) 689-2229
Customers' Favorites
New York Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Caesar Salad
By the Slice
Menu
Photos
+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This is New York Pizza. It's flat Pizza that you fold over and eat. That's what New York Pizza is. That's the way Us New Yorkers like it. We were very happy with it. Our waitress was wonderful.
Definitely a solid pizza choice! Most of the bad reviews seem to come from the service people received when dining in, but as far as taste, this pizza holds its own. When I'm in town, NYC Pizza is a quick and tasty spot to pick up dinner. In fact, I look forward to it every time.
We went based on reviews and a love of NY style pizza. The restaurant was empty and there were half empty beer bottles in the windowsill. Our waiter was young and inexperienced. He didn’t know of a bar menu and then returned to say they were out of wine. No red wine. The first two pizzas arrived and were good. Greasy and undercooked, but good enough. Our third pizza came out 30 minutes later and was not good at all. We left it behind. Sadly, this location disappointed and I...
You May Also Like
Bullies BBQ - 3 Regency Pkwy
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, Vegetarian
DryDock Seafood & Spirits - 840 William Hilton Pkwy
![]()
Seafood, American
Red Stripes Caribbean Cuisine & Lounge Hilton Head - 840 William Hilton Pkwy Unit 2
![]()
Caribbean, Vegan, Vegetarian