New York City Pizza
81 Pope Ave A, Hilton Head Island
(843) 842-2227
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Parmigiana
Kids Buffalo Wings
Meat Lovers Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Margherita Pizza
New York Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Medium Pizza
Greek Salad
Menu
Photos
+65 photos
+64 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We got caeser salad, mozz sticks, and baked ziti with meat sauce. Everything was so delicious and huge portions, the prices seemed a little high at first, but after seeing the portions the prices felt more than fair 😅. We were there at a slow time, admittedly, but service was super quick and attentive!
Pizza was good but atmosphere not so much. Walked in Sunday night before 9 PM was told takeout only. No one in the place except for some young girl and some other dude. Whoever owns this place needs to reevaluate his help. Can’t be turning away people before 9 PM when you’re you’re open until 10.
Me and my family love New York City Pizza! It is so delicious- We visit from Texas and we always look forward to going to New York City Pizza! The staff is always friendly! My husband is on a special diet and they have the option of cauliflower crust which he loves as well!
You May Also Like
Plantation Cafe & Deli - 81 Pope Ave Unit C
![]()
Breakfast, Cafe, Vegan, Pet Friendly
Sage Room - 75 Pope Ave
![]()
Fine Dining, American, Seafood, Bar, Vegan