Poor first impression. If we lived in town, I wouldn't be back. The person who seemed to running the shift was drinking Modelo in the food prep area that is visible to the public. $65 for two 10 inch pizzas, 2 sodas, large wings, and a salad. No way to get your own drink refills and no one bothered to check on us til I asked for a box.Wings were awesome, husband liked his salad, and the pizzas were just average.Just because I ordered from a QR code doesn't mean you can skimp on the rest of the customer service. .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Kathryn R.
Pizza Co used to be one of our favorite places to grab a quick pizza, not anymore. They have taken away the wait staff and now you have to order everything through a bar code on your phone, food quality has gone down and at that price point not worth it. People were nice but that doesn't make up for the changes.
Alan Gaum
Used to be toppings 'as much as you want' for $11. Now, they took this away and small pizza is $14 !!! Also they don't serve you because you must use 'square code' thing that my phone don't do.... so, I'll do Mellow Yellow in future !That's where I am now... ?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Kevin Manning
Great pizza place next to the Distillery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chrissy Fiorilli Ellington
Everyone here was nice, but the food was honestly terrible? The pizza was incredibly chewy—like eating a giant piece of gum with pizza toppings. Our apps were also under-seasoned and underwhelming. The pita chips with pimento cheese were just grocery pita chips with a carafe of mushed shredded cheddar, and the arancini were lukewarm and sitting in a pool of plain, unseasoned crushed tomato sauce—like, straight from the can sauce with zero flavor. All our sodas were flat too, which was yet another disappointment. None of it was good. What a waste of $120 for a family of 4.I rarely leave reviews, but this was so bad I wanted to save others from eating there, or maybe compel the owners to have food that matches the atmosphere. Such a nice space, and the adjacent distillery is awesome, but the food? Leaves much to be desired.
Matthew Perry
16" is way too much money, $18 should get you more than one meal. Definitely not a pizza you should expect to be your only meal. Most of the other pizza places around here give you twice if not quadruple the amount of food for that price.
Food: 2
jim w
The taste is good, the service is also very good, but the pizza is too thin, there are many people on weekends, you need to wait patiently
keyshauna Dobson
For the time that is says on the website does not match the time they close. If you were going to close your establishment at 8:30, change it on the website! it is a disservice to paying customers
Tyler rice
3rd time ive come here at 8:20 and they're closed early. Why it say 9 and you closed at 8
Always our "go to" for great pizza and honestly, they must have all the best kids in town working here!! The service is always exceptional, friendly and orders are accurate!! You cannot beat the value in both product and price, this pizza is truly a gem and the atmosphere is casual and friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CL Sparkman
Good pizza (not the best) served by friendly staff. Part of the Burnt Church Distillery complex. Really pleasant to eat outside during any of their events.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Natalia M (Natalie m)
As someone who works in customer service this is some of the worst service I have received. Very slow day, We were one of the only two tables there. We received our food (no silverware or drinks yet). I had to personally find our server and ask for our forgotten drinks and ask for silverware. Almost felt like our server was expecting no tip, hence the very minimal effort to serve us. Hope that you can commit to up holding your employees to providing better service experience to your future guests.
Doug Delaney, Realtor
Best pizza in Bluffton. Im a keta dude and the cauliflower crust margherita is the right size, crispy and just awesome. Pizza is back, oh yesh ???
Roger W.
Have tried just about all of the pizza places in Bluffton, and this is the one we constantly go back to. It is also where we take friends from out of town. Never had anyone say it wasn't one of the best pizzas they have ever had. Very thing crust, not crunchy unless you want it that way. The list of toppings is very extensive and you can add EVERYTHING you want for $2 over the base for a 10" pizza which is currently $9! Service is always excellent and the Whoppie Pies are a great way to finish. I rarely write reviews but they deserve this.
Poor first impression. If we lived in town, I wouldn't be back. The person who seemed to running the shift was drinking Modelo in the food prep area that is visible to the public. $65 for two 10 inch pizzas, 2 sodas, large wings, and a salad. No way to get your own drink refills and no one bothered to check on us til I asked for a box.Wings were awesome, husband liked his salad, and the pizzas were just average.Just because I ordered from a QR code doesn't mean you can skimp on the rest of the customer service. .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Pizza Co used to be one of our favorite places to grab a quick pizza, not anymore. They have taken away the wait staff and now you have to order everything through a bar code on your phone, food quality has gone down and at that price point not worth it. People were nice but that doesn't make up for the changes.
Used to be toppings 'as much as you want' for $11. Now, they took this away and small pizza is $14 !!! Also they don't serve you because you must use 'square code' thing that my phone don't do.... so, I'll do Mellow Yellow in future !That's where I am now... ?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great pizza place next to the Distillery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everyone here was nice, but the food was honestly terrible? The pizza was incredibly chewy—like eating a giant piece of gum with pizza toppings. Our apps were also under-seasoned and underwhelming. The pita chips with pimento cheese were just grocery pita chips with a carafe of mushed shredded cheddar, and the arancini were lukewarm and sitting in a pool of plain, unseasoned crushed tomato sauce—like, straight from the can sauce with zero flavor. All our sodas were flat too, which was yet another disappointment. None of it was good. What a waste of $120 for a family of 4.I rarely leave reviews, but this was so bad I wanted to save others from eating there, or maybe compel the owners to have food that matches the atmosphere. Such a nice space, and the adjacent distillery is awesome, but the food? Leaves much to be desired.
16" is way too much money, $18 should get you more than one meal. Definitely not a pizza you should expect to be your only meal. Most of the other pizza places around here give you twice if not quadruple the amount of food for that price.
Food: 2
The taste is good, the service is also very good, but the pizza is too thin, there are many people on weekends, you need to wait patiently
For the time that is says on the website does not match the time they close. If you were going to close your establishment at 8:30, change it on the website! it is a disservice to paying customers
3rd time ive come here at 8:20 and they're closed early. Why it say 9 and you closed at 8
The service and food was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Always our "go to" for great pizza and honestly, they must have all the best kids in town working here!! The service is always exceptional, friendly and orders are accurate!! You cannot beat the value in both product and price, this pizza is truly a gem and the atmosphere is casual and friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza (not the best) served by friendly staff. Part of the Burnt Church Distillery complex. Really pleasant to eat outside during any of their events.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
As someone who works in customer service this is some of the worst service I have received. Very slow day, We were one of the only two tables there. We received our food (no silverware or drinks yet). I had to personally find our server and ask for our forgotten drinks and ask for silverware. Almost felt like our server was expecting no tip, hence the very minimal effort to serve us. Hope that you can commit to up holding your employees to providing better service experience to your future guests.
Best pizza in Bluffton. Im a keta dude and the cauliflower crust margherita is the right size, crispy and just awesome. Pizza is back, oh yesh ???
Have tried just about all of the pizza places in Bluffton, and this is the one we constantly go back to. It is also where we take friends from out of town. Never had anyone say it wasn't one of the best pizzas they have ever had. Very thing crust, not crunchy unless you want it that way. The list of toppings is very extensive and you can add EVERYTHING you want for $2 over the base for a 10" pizza which is currently $9! Service is always excellent and the Whoppie Pies are a great way to finish. I rarely write reviews but they deserve this.