The Rooftop Bar

The three entre's and the Mussels we got were great. I cannot say that for the Fried Green Tomatoes Caprese. Looked like fried green tomatoes that can be bought in the grocery store freezer. I would go back.

The food is great and worth the money. I have gone many times before and will go again. This time though they seated 6 of us in a booth that should really only be for 4. It was very uncomfortable and a very unpleasant situation. I will never let them do that again. I will leave if they do.

I had the mussels and fries from the early bird menu they were the smallest mussels I have ever experienced.

This is a great restaurant for everyone. They have an outside bar and tables. Inside when you want to get in from the sun or weather. The food is always on point and the servers are always courteous and helpful.

everything was extremely nice. Very happy we made our reservation here. Whole family enjoyed it.

I can't say enough about how fabulous this actually was! I have never been to Poseidon on a holiday and I will do it over and over again! The food was amazing and the service was also amazing! Diego was awesome!!! Backstory here .... My friend unfortunately got sick and canceled at the 11th hour. I did not want to cancel this late in the game, so I decided to go by myself! And, I am so happy I did! It was truly one of the best Thanksgivings I've ever had! Thank you all so much for making it so wonderful!!! 

Great service, Early dining menu had great value. Excellent meal. We also had crab cakes and fresh Key Lime pie. Both were also delicious.

We all had baked cod. The cod was very good. The roasted vegetables that one of our party had were barely room temperature. Service was good and friendly. The green beans were not properly cleaned.

Good atmosphere but my fried shrimp were way overcooked. I didn't bother to tell my server because she checked in with me and i hadn't tried the shrimp yet. Fried cod was ok.

Food was excellent. Usually always in. Our server, Melissa was very good. Table right next to us had a group of older, rowdy people.

Our server was excellent, food was great, a little loud even at 6:30 ... overall very good

All the staff was friendly and efficient. Our waitress was excellent! Menu had something for every picky eater and dietary restrictions in our group and everyone loved their food.

⭐☆☆☆☆ Terrible Service and Zero Accountability Our party of seven had one of the most frustrating dining experiences we’ve ever had. Two of our seven meals were wrong, and instead of taking responsibility, the waitress blamed us. She had clearly written the order down incorrectly, then tried to insist we were mistaken. When the food was replaced, it came out wrong again—and this time, she blamed the manager. To make matters worse, one person in our group is gluten-free, and instead of handling that with care, the waitress made it an issue, complaining that she had to go downstairs to check if the meal was gluten-free. Completely unprofessional and insensitive. When we tried to get one of the meals corrected the second time, the waitress told us the item wasn’t even on the menu. We had to show her that it actually was—and her response was, “They must have changed the menu.” Really? For a server who works there, that’s just unacceptable. By the time the rest of the food finally came out, the staff had already started clearing the table. The manager eventually came over and apologized, but offered no solution, no compensation, and no real effort to make things right. For a restaurant that’s supposed to care about its guests, this was an absolute failure from start to finish. Poor communication, lack of professionalism, and zero accountability. We will not be returning, and I would strongly recommend dining elsewhere. Absolutely awful experience!!!

I had the broiled shrimp and my husband had tuna with shrimp - all of it was very overcooked. There was fowl language being used by a patron close by. Our service was good, but otherwise it was a disappointing Friday night dinner.

Our party of seven had one of the most frustrating dining experiences we've ever had. Two of our seven meals were wrong, and instead of taking responsibility, the waitress blamed us. She had clearly written the order down incorrectly, then tried to insist we were mistaken. When the food was replaced, it came out wrong again—and this time, she blamed the manager. To make matters worse, one person in our group is gluten-free, and instead of handling that with care, the waitress made it an issue, complaining that she had to go downstairs to check if the meal was gluten-free. Completely unprofessional and insensitive. When we tried to get one of the meals corrected the second time, the waitress told us the item wasn't even on the menu. We had to show her that it actually was—and her response was, “They must have changed the menu.” Really? For a server who works there, that's just unacceptable. By the time the rest of the food finally came out, the staff had already started clearing the table. The manager eventually came over and apologized, but offered no solution, no compensation, and no real effort to make things right. For a restaurant that's supposed to care about its guests, this was an absolute failure from start to finish. Poor communication, lack of professionalism, and zero accountability. We will not be returning, and I would strongly recommend dining elsewhere.