Old Mill Brewpub

711 E Main St, Lexington
(803) 785-2337

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Marlowe

Great atmosphere, awesome area near by to walk, the hamburgers must be marinated and seasoned, and to my wife and I they weren't good. Place was clean, staff was friendly, only the second time ever going there, one experience was terrific, we will go back, just won't be eating the hamburgers lol.

Court G

We arrived mid afternoon in early January to sit outside on the patio. It took a bit longer than we would like for our server to make her way to us (which seemed like a mishap not a sign of bad service), but aside from that, it was a great experience! Lovely view of the pond, very friendly service, great selection of beers, attention for our puppy (a pup cup and a treat!), attentive manager (or maybe owner?), and our appetizer (the only thing we ordered to eat) was delicious. It was a great visit while we were in town visiting family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jared Jarvis Photography

Great lunch and dinner spot. Right on a beautiful pond with a walking trail. Good food and service and great environment. Plenty of beers on tap. A little tough to find parking sometimes due to sharing a lot with other businesses and the walking trail, but the lot is large at least.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Stephanie Muller Bell

This is the fourth time I have been here in the past couple of months. The food is always good. I've had the best service ever 2 of the 4 times with Jessica, one of their servers. She has customer service down pat. My kids & grandchildren enjoyed eating lunch here before leaving to go back home. I will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: She Crab Soup, Old Mill Fries, Hella Gouda Burger, Brisket Melt

Albert Esposito Jr

I am so disappointed, in myself, that we haven't discovered your wonderful place before now.
Kelly was terrific! We booked our Son's 50th Birthday in one of your banquet rooms. The room was spacious and inviting, I know our guests are going to have great time.
We were so impressed with your place we stayed for lunch.
So we met Jessica, she was warm and friendly and well informed about your several beer taps.
The Fish and chips was delicious, I tried the Paulaner Hefe draft, it was was light, smooth and not filling. (I said to my wife, lets go back in for another draft)! We brought the Pumpkin Blondie home to enjoy, it was great!
Thank you for a wonderful afternoon, the upcoming banquet room and the great hospitality.
We will return and bring friends.
Al

On this visit 12/26/2025, the whole family and co-workers enjoyed your atmosphere.
SABRINA was amazing! She hustled around our tables with the great of ease. Oh yeah there were 22 of us celebrating our son's 50th birthday.
The appetizers were delicious as well as every menu entre we asked for.
Thank you for another wonderful experience.
We will most definitely return.
Al

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ursula Redden-Lovejoy

Pretzel crab dip appetizers were great! My daughter’s burger was good. My mashed Potato’s were good. The string beans would have been good but they were very garlicky tasting. The country fried steak was ok. The water was good. Before yall say anything water has different tastes and I could tell it wasn’t from the tap. Our server was great though! Very nice and attentive and gave recommendations when asked and she was honest with her responses.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Crab Pretzel

Susan Watkins

Beautiful day in the sixties over looking the pond. Tried the local craft beers and food on the patio.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Old Mill Fries, Hella Gouda Burger

Nicole

Nice atmosphere but the food was terrible. We got wings & fish with fries. The frying oil was so dark & burnt I didn't eat it. The portion amount was for a small child.

***Attention management- check your kitchen, this ruined a planned date night. ***

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andy Potts

I had the fish and chips with a bowl of she crab soup. Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elle

The waitress was very rude. Terribly rude for no reason. We decided not to order and left and went somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Karen Brill

I ordered the smoked meat plate and got the beef brisket. I really wanted to like this meal but the meat was so full of fat, I was disappointed. Sides were good and so was the barbecue sauce that accompanied the brisket. Our server was fantastic and I liked the atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Larry Witteborg

This past weekend my grandson ordered the chicken finger basket. The breading was different then before as it tasted like a seafood breading very light and cripy and heavily seasoned. (had a seafood seasoning flavor)..not good and unedible.
. all of the other food we ordered was ery good. Though the service was slow on the back deck we were not in a hurry.
See you next time!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Brian Hough

It's a really great place. It's kinda a hole in the wall spot but very popular. Great service. Went there on my lunch break and even though they were short staffed they made sure we got service asap.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erica Houck

The server was great. The food and drinks left a lot to be desired. The cheese curds and fries were great. The rest was not good at all, unfortunately. The drinks were watered down. Salad had water in the bottom of the plate. Burger was ordered medium and came out almost black & DRY. So sad because I really want to love this place but I guess I’ll keep looking.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Pat Binkley

Last time for me. Came with my husband and sister. Since it was my choice I caught so much grief cause the food was gross. The server was very nice. The fries are good. Used to be better.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Loading...