Tastes like the original but not quite the same quality. Had a more crisp crust. Yet super close.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Eduardo L.
Very quick service and good food. A lot of options to choose from to eat. Will be returning.
Alan Stevens
Honestly this was one of the worst pizzas I ever had. We are from VA Beach and were staying across the street for Spring Break, got in late and ordered delivery. Pizza was 25 min late, they forgot the garlic knots (they did return 25 minutes later with the missing knots). Either way both the pizza and the knots were very lack luster. Pizza was greasy and had no real flavor, knots were covered in raw fresh chopped garlic, and their dough that was used for both was one of the worst I ever had. I do not recommend this place at all.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Eric Fisher
Staying in Surfside Beach for a couple of months and stopped in to check out New York Pizza. Pizza in New York has always been a favorite of mine and this was as close as I've come outside of New York. The crust was soft and light and the toppings were perfect.The owner Bennie was friendly and cordial and it was a pleasure to chat with him while I waited for my order. Great food, great service. Recommend it highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roxan
I walked in the guy just stared at me. I sat down..he was waiting on someone else but he said loudly MAY I HELP YOU??? I said I've never been here before can I sit down and order or do I order up there..no u can sit down! Ok I already know what I want..no menu given to me..he says ok what...I started to tell him he says we don't have that! I said I just looked at the menu online..he says NO!! That was the other place..this is a new place new menu..ok so what do you have..he says menu up here! I said yes that's why I asked do I order up there or can I sit and order..no menu up here!! He's clearly from New York and probably Russian or something with an accent and not very nice..Rude I would say..I ordered..I was going to eat there but I didn't feel comfortable so I took it home..$25 for 10 wings and a pizza roll...was horrible! Greasy horrible tasting..2 bites I threw the entire order into the trash...I was still very hungry so I baked a potato..I was looking forward to this new york Italian food...never ever go again!!!
Waxer
This pizza is bomb. Great customer service as well, will definitely be returning!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Kim Wilson
Spinach wàs over the top . Every square inch topped with canned spinach.
Food: 2
Tommy Prevatt
They don’t want you to eat here. They had a bad attitude from the second we walked in. We went down the road to Ultimate California Pizza instead and immediately had a better experience.
Marybeth Helenek
The restaurant was a stop on the way home, to NC. Being from NY, I drawn by the name of the place. Stepping inside I saw the typical pizza place. And then it hit us, the young Lady was obviously from NY because the attitude was awful. It was Sunday, about 3pm and already she was tense. We Ordered a spinach roll and a chicken roll. Since the bathroom was not operational, we went next door to the grocery store. The total for $9.00 spinach roll and a $9.50 Chicken roll came to $22.50. My hubby was upset by our wait for our food, and was going to explain the math was off...but we paid it and left. No sauce on the side, just dry rolls. My spinach was good but not his Chicken he said.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
James I.
Fantastic! Get it Ohio Valley Style. The crust is cooked first with the sauce, then the cheese is added cold once it comes out of the oven. The sauce is a sweet sauce and a special blend of cheese makes it fantastic. This place isn't fancy, its just good. A big shout out to Sara, she is the hostess with the mostess and made the experience even better! KUDOs!
The dough is light. I love their pizza. Glad I found it. Wasn't very good I preferred DiCarlo
Debra G.
The pizza was the best. I'm not a pizza eater normally but I'd drive back to Myrtle beach for that pizza. You need to be patient cause it's worth the wait. If you're looking for ambiance it's not that kind of place. Plain tables no ambiance but the pizza is wonderful. Personally next time I'd probably have it delivered with candlelight and drink of choice on a balcony overlooking the beach on my balcony. Making my own ambiance.
c roy
The company is known for its thin-crust pizza, which is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Tastes like the original but not quite the same quality. Had a more crisp crust. Yet super close.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very quick service and good food. A lot of options to choose from to eat. Will be returning.
Honestly this was one of the worst pizzas I ever had. We are from VA Beach and were staying across the street for Spring Break, got in late and ordered delivery. Pizza was 25 min late, they forgot the garlic knots (they did return 25 minutes later with the missing knots). Either way both the pizza and the knots were very lack luster. Pizza was greasy and had no real flavor, knots were covered in raw fresh chopped garlic, and their dough that was used for both was one of the worst I ever had. I do not recommend this place at all.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Staying in Surfside Beach for a couple of months and stopped in to check out New York Pizza. Pizza in New York has always been a favorite of mine and this was as close as I've come outside of New York. The crust was soft and light and the toppings were perfect.The owner Bennie was friendly and cordial and it was a pleasure to chat with him while I waited for my order. Great food, great service. Recommend it highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I walked in the guy just stared at me. I sat down..he was waiting on someone else but he said loudly MAY I HELP YOU??? I said I've never been here before can I sit down and order or do I order up there..no u can sit down! Ok I already know what I want..no menu given to me..he says ok what...I started to tell him he says we don't have that! I said I just looked at the menu online..he says NO!! That was the other place..this is a new place new menu..ok so what do you have..he says menu up here! I said yes that's why I asked do I order up there or can I sit and order..no menu up here!! He's clearly from New York and probably Russian or something with an accent and not very nice..Rude I would say..I ordered..I was going to eat there but I didn't feel comfortable so I took it home..$25 for 10 wings and a pizza roll...was horrible! Greasy horrible tasting..2 bites I threw the entire order into the trash...I was still very hungry so I baked a potato..I was looking forward to this new york Italian food...never ever go again!!!
This pizza is bomb. Great customer service as well, will definitely be returning!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Spinach wàs over the top . Every square inch topped with canned spinach.
Food: 2
They don’t want you to eat here. They had a bad attitude from the second we walked in. We went down the road to Ultimate California Pizza instead and immediately had a better experience.
The restaurant was a stop on the way home, to NC. Being from NY, I drawn by the name of the place. Stepping inside I saw the typical pizza place. And then it hit us, the young Lady was obviously from NY because the attitude was awful. It was Sunday, about 3pm and already she was tense. We Ordered a spinach roll and a chicken roll. Since the bathroom was not operational, we went next door to the grocery store. The total for $9.00 spinach roll and a $9.50 Chicken roll came to $22.50. My hubby was upset by our wait for our food, and was going to explain the math was off...but we paid it and left. No sauce on the side, just dry rolls. My spinach was good but not his Chicken he said.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Fantastic! Get it Ohio Valley Style. The crust is cooked first with the sauce, then the cheese is added cold once it comes out of the oven. The sauce is a sweet sauce and a special blend of cheese makes it fantastic. This place isn't fancy, its just good. A big shout out to Sara, she is the hostess with the mostess and made the experience even better! KUDOs!
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious pepperoni with mushroom calzone.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
The dough is light. I love their pizza. Glad I found it. Wasn't very good I preferred DiCarlo
The pizza was the best. I'm not a pizza eater normally but I'd drive back to Myrtle beach for that pizza. You need to be patient cause it's worth the wait. If you're looking for ambiance it's not that kind of place. Plain tables no ambiance but the pizza is wonderful. Personally next time I'd probably have it delivered with candlelight and drink of choice on a balcony overlooking the beach on my balcony. Making my own ambiance.
The company is known for its thin-crust pizza, which is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Calzone, Bread Sticks
Delicious! This pizza is originated from my hometown in the Ohio valley. Everyone up there luvs it- so I knew ppl down here would luv it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5