After walking the dog we stopped in for lunch. We ordered the Italian Sandwiches and ate at their tables outside with our dog. The staff were ultra friendly and the food was AMAZING!!! This little gem has everything you could want for a delicious Italian meal and they prepare everything for you! It’s perfect!We’ll definitely be stopping by again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
Lisa Hess
So disappointed that the "famous" bread was stale. Had the #13, small sliver of mozzarella, barely any balsamic or sun dried tomato. The prosciutto was ok.The atmosphere was a little sterile and didn't smell like anything was cooking. It was fine though being from Brooklyn I expected a little more. Owner was nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
George Hanstein
Ordered The Italian Sub. In my opinion, Subs are all about the roll. The roll was
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
William McIntyre
Awesome selection of food! It was hard to select what I wanted. I ordered the chicken parm hero for $11.95. Tasty chicken, great sauce and perfectly melted cheese. It's a big meal! The staff is super friendly. Definitely will come back for some more delicious meals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
Joyce P.
What a great place! Most items are made from scratch or shipped from NY. The taste, outstanding!
Lynsey C.
Really great food! The service is great and a lot of options. I can never decide what to get , it all looks so good. The sandwiches are really good too. But don't turn around, you will see the dessert case! Which is even more dangerous. The chocolate mousse! Oh how decadent. It is a smaller area but they have a few tables if you want to sit inside, there are a few more tables out front and some picnic tables out back. If looking for an authentic Italian deli, definitely hit this place! Definitely worth it
Tracie F.
Friendly people! Tried a hot ham and cheese on the freshest roll I've very had...all of the fixings on top were absolutely perfect. We also had a hot meatball hero and it was amazing as well. For dessert we tried the lemonchello cake and it was really delicious as well. All in all...how can we not come back? It was a ! Love supporting local businesses. Oh! And the macaroni salad and Cole slaw was delicious too!
tom romig
We like to patronize local places and bought subs there since it was opened. Just bought a spicy hoagie to go and the filling is about 1/4 inch thick. What a joke for $13!They lost a customer.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Frances Horne
Best place to have a great Italian meal great people and atmosphere and
Been wanting to visit this place for a while and finally got the chance to while visiting the Irish Italian festival yesterday and all I can say is WOW!!! Food was amazing - We had the perfectly sliced eggplant parm and also tried the Balboa - could not get enough. The Sarabella's are a wonderful family and while talking with them found out they are from my hometown of Astoria, New York! No wonder their food was soooooooo good!!!!! We came in as customers, but we left as family giving hugs and kisses as real Italian families do!!! Can't wait to visit again and stuff my face with all of the goodies this deli has to offer - OUTSTANDING!!
Stop by during the Irish/Italian festival 2023; Great atmosphere, beautiful decor and beautiful people. Everyone was friendly and wonderful to speak to especially Ashley, Jacklyn and Sherrie. They make you feel like you are back at home in NY with family and friends. Love it. Had some good old fashion Cappuccino (awesome - Jacklyn); then I had the Balboa (suggest by Ashley), it was totally wonderful with that brown gravy sauce (YUM :)) and my GF had the Eggplant Parmesan -(OMG) that tomato sauce was fresh and on Point!. We shared and could not decide which one was the best lol. The cheesecake is made from scratch by Mom (Sherrie) and is straight out of NY. I do not have to travel all the way back to get real cheesecake, when NY is right here at Sarabella's. I wish I had the time to take some pictures of the food we ate but did not get a chance to because it was just to good to wait lol. I can say we both left the premises feeling that our family is here with us too.Thank you Carolina Gold for mentioning Sarabella's, for it was not for you, we would have never found them.
Susan M.
My husband saw this place passing by and we decided to have sandwiches for lunch. They had beautiful bubble flying in the air, very colorful with the sunshine. The food was absolutely amazing! My mom and I shared walnut, cranberry chicken salad sandwich, which was delicious! It was homemade and wonderful! My dad and husband had supreme sandwiches, which had such wonderful flavor! The bread was awesome!! They sweetly suggested some chicken, which they cut and warmed for my daughter. She loved it and it tasted great! We decided to try some homemade Tiramisu and Italian Lemon Cake. They were both amazing!! We would definitely come again and recommend!!! Thanks
Julian Borrelli
The meatball is absolutely amazing, when taking my first bite my mouth was experiencing a explosion of flavors unlike anything I’ve ever had before. The meatball was seasoned and flavored to perfection. Complements to the chef, toasted to absolute perfection. I’ve had many meatball subs this this beats subway by far, would definitely recommend coming back to this establishment and trying there food. Don’t even get me started on the pastries they were beyond delicious.
nathian stjohn
This place is freaking awesome..anybody use to the New York style delis in Florida..their bread comes in twice a week from Brooklyn...It is the best sandwich place @ MYRTLE BEACH period!!!!!You are not going to find a place any better than this..I could eat there all day everyday...absolutely the best
Patricia Tobin
The New Yorker sandwich reminded me of the delicious sandwich I had at Carnegie's in New York City!! The desserts we brought home were ALL amazing - especially the Ricotta cheesecake!!
After walking the dog we stopped in for lunch. We ordered the Italian Sandwiches and ate at their tables outside with our dog. The staff were ultra friendly and the food was AMAZING!!! This little gem has everything you could want for a delicious Italian meal and they prepare everything for you! It’s perfect!We’ll definitely be stopping by again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
So disappointed that the "famous" bread was stale. Had the #13, small sliver of mozzarella, barely any balsamic or sun dried tomato. The prosciutto was ok.The atmosphere was a little sterile and didn't smell like anything was cooking. It was fine though being from Brooklyn I expected a little more. Owner was nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ordered The Italian Sub. In my opinion, Subs are all about the roll. The roll was
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Awesome selection of food! It was hard to select what I wanted. I ordered the chicken parm hero for $11.95. Tasty chicken, great sauce and perfectly melted cheese. It's a big meal! The staff is super friendly. Definitely will come back for some more delicious meals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches
What a great place! Most items are made from scratch or shipped from NY. The taste, outstanding!
Really great food! The service is great and a lot of options. I can never decide what to get , it all looks so good. The sandwiches are really good too. But don't turn around, you will see the dessert case! Which is even more dangerous. The chocolate mousse! Oh how decadent. It is a smaller area but they have a few tables if you want to sit inside, there are a few more tables out front and some picnic tables out back. If looking for an authentic Italian deli, definitely hit this place! Definitely worth it
Friendly people! Tried a hot ham and cheese on the freshest roll I've very had...all of the fixings on top were absolutely perfect. We also had a hot meatball hero and it was amazing as well. For dessert we tried the lemonchello cake and it was really delicious as well. All in all...how can we not come back? It was a ! Love supporting local businesses. Oh! And the macaroni salad and Cole slaw was delicious too!
We like to patronize local places and bought subs there since it was opened. Just bought a spicy hoagie to go and the filling is about 1/4 inch thick. What a joke for $13!They lost a customer.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best place to have a great Italian meal great people and atmosphere and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Chicken Delight, Italian Roast Beef, Tuna Melt, Meatball Parm, Chicken Salad Sandwich, Classic Prosciutto, Chicken Parm, Meatball Submarine Sandwich, Prosciutto, Eggplant Parm, Sandwiches, Sausage Parm
Been wanting to visit this place for a while and finally got the chance to while visiting the Irish Italian festival yesterday and all I can say is WOW!!! Food was amazing - We had the perfectly sliced eggplant parm and also tried the Balboa - could not get enough. The Sarabella's are a wonderful family and while talking with them found out they are from my hometown of Astoria, New York! No wonder their food was soooooooo good!!!!! We came in as customers, but we left as family giving hugs and kisses as real Italian families do!!! Can't wait to visit again and stuff my face with all of the goodies this deli has to offer - OUTSTANDING!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Stop by during the Irish/Italian festival 2023; Great atmosphere, beautiful decor and beautiful people. Everyone was friendly and wonderful to speak to especially Ashley, Jacklyn and Sherrie. They make you feel like you are back at home in NY with family and friends. Love it. Had some good old fashion Cappuccino (awesome - Jacklyn); then I had the Balboa (suggest by Ashley), it was totally wonderful with that brown gravy sauce (YUM :)) and my GF had the Eggplant Parmesan -(OMG) that tomato sauce was fresh and on Point!. We shared and could not decide which one was the best lol. The cheesecake is made from scratch by Mom (Sherrie) and is straight out of NY. I do not have to travel all the way back to get real cheesecake, when NY is right here at Sarabella's. I wish I had the time to take some pictures of the food we ate but did not get a chance to because it was just to good to wait lol. I can say we both left the premises feeling that our family is here with us too.Thank you Carolina Gold for mentioning Sarabella's, for it was not for you, we would have never found them.
My husband saw this place passing by and we decided to have sandwiches for lunch. They had beautiful bubble flying in the air, very colorful with the sunshine. The food was absolutely amazing! My mom and I shared walnut, cranberry chicken salad sandwich, which was delicious! It was homemade and wonderful! My dad and husband had supreme sandwiches, which had such wonderful flavor! The bread was awesome!! They sweetly suggested some chicken, which they cut and warmed for my daughter. She loved it and it tasted great! We decided to try some homemade Tiramisu and Italian Lemon Cake. They were both amazing!! We would definitely come again and recommend!!! Thanks
The meatball is absolutely amazing, when taking my first bite my mouth was experiencing a explosion of flavors unlike anything I’ve ever had before. The meatball was seasoned and flavored to perfection. Complements to the chef, toasted to absolute perfection. I’ve had many meatball subs this this beats subway by far, would definitely recommend coming back to this establishment and trying there food. Don’t even get me started on the pastries they were beyond delicious.
This place is freaking awesome..anybody use to the New York style delis in Florida..their bread comes in twice a week from Brooklyn...It is the best sandwich place @ MYRTLE BEACH period!!!!!You are not going to find a place any better than this..I could eat there all day everyday...absolutely the best
The New Yorker sandwich reminded me of the delicious sandwich I had at Carnegie's in New York City!! The desserts we brought home were ALL amazing - especially the Ricotta cheesecake!!