Had high hopes for this cute local shop but it was very mediocre. No oreos in my Chocolate Nutella Oreo ice-cream pint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge
Brandon Raper
Outstanding ice cream and outstanding service. Don't miss this spot when you're in town.
Amber Sauvage
Great atmosphere and delishious homemade ice cream. We came when there were several large groups arriving at the same time. The employees were patient and efficient (there were a ton of kids to serve and only 2 people working). Very impressed
Guadalupe Lang
Love the ice cream. Love the atmosphere.
Judy Grove
From the sidewalk, the smell will draw you in!! The ice cream and homemade waffle cones were amazing.
Debbie Woodbury
Icecream was excellent though the scoops were modest. We had 3 issues with the place: 1. there was no line but they still did not allow sampling so we didn’t dare try their unique flavors 2. they charged extra for the cone 3. they had only paid water… The whole experience just felt a little chilly to us. Place was clean though, and icecream was tasty.
Olga Rojas
All ice creams are super tasty, every year we visit Custer is inevitable, pass and consume ice cream every day, great, excellent attention, it is a mandatory stop.
Jen Mulder
Awesome ice cream! We stopped here about 430 and it wasn’t too crowded compared to the line about 12:30. Friendly people and the waffle cone, according to my hubby, was really good! He had toffee ice cream and I had vanilla with hot fudge.
Justin Brenner
Some of the best ice cream and definitely the best waffle cone we have had on our trip to South Dakota. Definitely a must stop in custer for ice cream!!
Linda Ray
Excellent ice cream! There were 6 of us, and everyone loved theirs.
Good variety of tasty ice cream. Can certainly get busy.
Courtney V.
THE BEST ICE CREAM YOU WILL EVER HAVE!!!! they homemake all of their products and you can tell. the best waffle cones and ice cream you'll find. AND the best customer service. horatio's never disappoints!
Rick H.
THIS PLACE SMELLS SO GOOD! You walk by and you get smells from the street that draws you in. Problem with leaving your doors wide open on the street like that to attract customers is FLIES EVERYWHERE! Ot is so unbearable! So awful!! I'm not talking like 4; I'm talking like 30! Stop in if you like flies mixed in with your overpriced orange pineapple sugar cone.
Melissa Terzis Proakis
The cone was soggy/stale and I made the mistake of getting the chocolate chip cookie. Don’t do that. It tasted like last week.Update: my family convinced me to go in and tell them. So I told them the cookie tasted like it was 3 weeks old. They apologized and did nothing. I tossed it in the trash and they didn’t offer anything back. Not that I needed it but still, a cookie has to be atrocious for me to not eat it. The rest of the fam also tasted it. All spit it out. Gross.
Andrielle Walsh
Pretty good ice cream! The simplicity of the menu was great! Staff was kind, friendly and clean! Atmosphere was clean, but boy were they busy! Only complaint was that the pistachio was either not pistachio, or they gave a different type of ice cream on accident. Prices aren't too bad either.
Had high hopes for this cute local shop but it was very mediocre. No oreos in my Chocolate Nutella Oreo ice-cream pint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge
Outstanding ice cream and outstanding service. Don't miss this spot when you're in town.
Great atmosphere and delishious homemade ice cream. We came when there were several large groups arriving at the same time. The employees were patient and efficient (there were a ton of kids to serve and only 2 people working). Very impressed
Love the ice cream. Love the atmosphere.
From the sidewalk, the smell will draw you in!! The ice cream and homemade waffle cones were amazing.
Icecream was excellent though the scoops were modest. We had 3 issues with the place: 1. there was no line but they still did not allow sampling so we didn’t dare try their unique flavors 2. they charged extra for the cone 3. they had only paid water… The whole experience just felt a little chilly to us. Place was clean though, and icecream was tasty.
All ice creams are super tasty, every year we visit Custer is inevitable, pass and consume ice cream every day, great, excellent attention, it is a mandatory stop.
Awesome ice cream! We stopped here about 430 and it wasn’t too crowded compared to the line about 12:30. Friendly people and the waffle cone, according to my hubby, was really good! He had toffee ice cream and I had vanilla with hot fudge.
Some of the best ice cream and definitely the best waffle cone we have had on our trip to South Dakota. Definitely a must stop in custer for ice cream!!
Excellent ice cream! There were 6 of us, and everyone loved theirs.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good variety of tasty ice cream. Can certainly get busy.
THE BEST ICE CREAM YOU WILL EVER HAVE!!!! they homemake all of their products and you can tell. the best waffle cones and ice cream you'll find. AND the best customer service. horatio's never disappoints!
THIS PLACE SMELLS SO GOOD! You walk by and you get smells from the street that draws you in. Problem with leaving your doors wide open on the street like that to attract customers is FLIES EVERYWHERE! Ot is so unbearable! So awful!! I'm not talking like 4; I'm talking like 30! Stop in if you like flies mixed in with your overpriced orange pineapple sugar cone.
The cone was soggy/stale and I made the mistake of getting the chocolate chip cookie. Don’t do that. It tasted like last week.Update: my family convinced me to go in and tell them. So I told them the cookie tasted like it was 3 weeks old. They apologized and did nothing. I tossed it in the trash and they didn’t offer anything back. Not that I needed it but still, a cookie has to be atrocious for me to not eat it. The rest of the fam also tasted it. All spit it out. Gross.
Pretty good ice cream! The simplicity of the menu was great! Staff was kind, friendly and clean! Atmosphere was clean, but boy were they busy! Only complaint was that the pistachio was either not pistachio, or they gave a different type of ice cream on accident. Prices aren't too bad either.