Our party tried the walleye, the salmon and the vegetarian Jamaican stew and started with the almond dipI had my wedding rehearsal dinner at Sage creek 21 years ago and was happy to see they still had their amazing mixed green salad- didn’t try it today but have fond memoriesKid-friendliness: Multiple families here with a kid menu
Great food and great prices with HUGE glasses of wine. :- ) We scored a high top at the front window which was perfect for viewing everything going on but provided some privacy as the place gets pretty noisy when full. Service was excellent and food is delicious. Highly recommend for dinner
Carole Freeman
This is the only people that did not help me I suffer from chrones disease so nuts are a no asked if I could have plain fish was told it was already prepared spoke about risotto got onions in no it came already prepared risotto rice I had to be very carefull as not to spoil rest of our
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Cameron Raszler
Decently priced and pretty good food. The roasted potatoes were a really good side option with lots of flavor. You can opt to sit at a table or get food service at the bar. They also have a pretty good selection of beers and wines.Parking: Free street parking is tough to find, especially during the summer months when traffic is in town from Custer State Park and other nearby areas. There are some lots off the main road that I believe are free as well.Wheelchair accessibility: The restaurant is located on a wooden boardwalk. There are no steps to get into the restaurant. There are high top and low top tables inside, of which I'm sure they could remove a chair to allow a wheelchair to roll up to the table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Swiss Chicken
Nina Schultz
Had a wonderful meal at Sage Creek Grille! Jenna was our server and was attentive, friendly and took excellent care of us. The food was outstanding! I had the Bourbon Street fettuccine with shrimp. Simply delicious! We sat at the bar and the staff were all gracious and welcoming . Jenn and Renaro could not have made us feel more welcome. The entire experience is one not to be missed if you're traveling to Custer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Passenger01283878552
Very uninformed I asked for fish without nut dressing to have it plain already prepared choose salmon and risotto asked for onion not to be added already prepared there are people with allergies if cooking fresh risotto onion can be taken out not once we're we asked if our meal was ok
Maryann W
The restaurant opened for dinner at 5. By 4:45, a crowd was waiting at the door. By 5:30, every seat in the house, including the bar, was filled. Ambiance is wonderful: photo comparisons on the wall of Custer 100+ years ago and photos from current times were fascinating. The welcome we had from Renaro was warm, generous, and accommodating. As the face of the restaurant, he was exceptional with us and everyone else he seated. Jolene was our waitress, so efficient, accurate, and timely, making sure we had exactly what we needed and when we needed it. Friendly, thoughtful and knew the menu in detail. The entire experience here was top of the line. We’ve been to the “best restaurant in town.” This, in our opinion is the very best.
robertmaster123
Relatively small, but diverse menu including Jamaican, Italian and Korean items. Also selection of burgers and sandwiches. Our meals were very good. Pleasant staff and good service.
John S
Outstanding from the greeting by Ronaldo to the waitress Jenny to the food which was delicious. See write up on yelp! Meal was excellent. I will say watching Ronaldo and Jenny work in concert as with most of the other personnel I witness, they all work together no matter whose customer it is - there overall goal is to be assured each patron has the best experience.
Jennifer Schaller
I highly recommend Sage Creek Grille for its excellent food and wonderful service. Definitely worth a stop for anyone visiting Custer.
Visiting from out-of-state, we saw this place highly rated on TripAdvisors so we decided to try it out! We were not disappointed in the slightest. Food was spectacular and the service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Monica Carrington
We stopped here for a late lunch while traveling. The menu is sophisticated, but we were able to order a couple of burgers with potatoes. They were delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Lang
Excellent food and service. A bit loud inside, mostly due to full house. Definitely recommend it in Custer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Beef Bolognese
Emily Twanmo
We arrived at 5:30 pm on a Friday for dinner. The tables were already full so we sat at the bar. I ordered the Jamaican Stew based on another reviewer’s recommendation, and my husband had the chicken sandwich with bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Both came out of the kitchen piping hot and were absolutely delicious. (I now want to make the stew at home.) Service was attentive and friendly. By the time we left, people were waiting in line to be seated.I highly recommend the Sage Creek Grill, but note that it is deservedly popular so plan accordingly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Fuks
My husband and I both had meals that we hadn't had before, and they were amazing! The people were great, food came quickly, and the bill was low-definitely
Our party tried the walleye, the salmon and the vegetarian Jamaican stew and started with the almond dipI had my wedding rehearsal dinner at Sage creek 21 years ago and was happy to see they still had their amazing mixed green salad- didn’t try it today but have fond memoriesKid-friendliness: Multiple families here with a kid menu
Recommended dishes: Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon Melt, Almond & Panko Crusted Baked Walleye
Great food and great prices with HUGE glasses of wine. :- ) We scored a high top at the front window which was perfect for viewing everything going on but provided some privacy as the place gets pretty noisy when full. Service was excellent and food is delicious. Highly recommend for dinner
This is the only people that did not help me I suffer from chrones disease so nuts are a no asked if I could have plain fish was told it was already prepared spoke about risotto got onions in no it came already prepared risotto rice I had to be very carefull as not to spoil rest of our
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Decently priced and pretty good food. The roasted potatoes were a really good side option with lots of flavor. You can opt to sit at a table or get food service at the bar. They also have a pretty good selection of beers and wines.Parking: Free street parking is tough to find, especially during the summer months when traffic is in town from Custer State Park and other nearby areas. There are some lots off the main road that I believe are free as well.Wheelchair accessibility: The restaurant is located on a wooden boardwalk. There are no steps to get into the restaurant. There are high top and low top tables inside, of which I'm sure they could remove a chair to allow a wheelchair to roll up to the table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Swiss Chicken
Had a wonderful meal at Sage Creek Grille! Jenna was our server and was attentive, friendly and took excellent care of us. The food was outstanding! I had the Bourbon Street fettuccine with shrimp. Simply delicious! We sat at the bar and the staff were all gracious and welcoming . Jenn and Renaro could not have made us feel more welcome. The entire experience is one not to be missed if you're traveling to Custer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very uninformed I asked for fish without nut dressing to have it plain already prepared choose salmon and risotto asked for onion not to be added already prepared there are people with allergies if cooking fresh risotto onion can be taken out not once we're we asked if our meal was ok
The restaurant opened for dinner at 5. By 4:45, a crowd was waiting at the door. By 5:30, every seat in the house, including the bar, was filled. Ambiance is wonderful: photo comparisons on the wall of Custer 100+ years ago and photos from current times were fascinating. The welcome we had from Renaro was warm, generous, and accommodating. As the face of the restaurant, he was exceptional with us and everyone else he seated. Jolene was our waitress, so efficient, accurate, and timely, making sure we had exactly what we needed and when we needed it. Friendly, thoughtful and knew the menu in detail. The entire experience here was top of the line. We’ve been to the “best restaurant in town.” This, in our opinion is the very best.
Relatively small, but diverse menu including Jamaican, Italian and Korean items. Also selection of burgers and sandwiches. Our meals were very good. Pleasant staff and good service.
Outstanding from the greeting by Ronaldo to the waitress Jenny to the food which was delicious. See write up on yelp! Meal was excellent. I will say watching Ronaldo and Jenny work in concert as with most of the other personnel I witness, they all work together no matter whose customer it is - there overall goal is to be assured each patron has the best experience.
I highly recommend Sage Creek Grille for its excellent food and wonderful service. Definitely worth a stop for anyone visiting Custer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Visiting from out-of-state, we saw this place highly rated on TripAdvisors so we decided to try it out! We were not disappointed in the slightest. Food was spectacular and the service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped here for a late lunch while traveling. The menu is sophisticated, but we were able to order a couple of burgers with potatoes. They were delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and service. A bit loud inside, mostly due to full house. Definitely recommend it in Custer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Beef Bolognese
We arrived at 5:30 pm on a Friday for dinner. The tables were already full so we sat at the bar. I ordered the Jamaican Stew based on another reviewer’s recommendation, and my husband had the chicken sandwich with bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Both came out of the kitchen piping hot and were absolutely delicious. (I now want to make the stew at home.) Service was attentive and friendly. By the time we left, people were waiting in line to be seated.I highly recommend the Sage Creek Grill, but note that it is deservedly popular so plan accordingly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I both had meals that we hadn't had before, and they were amazing! The people were great, food came quickly, and the bill was low-definitely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5