Came in for a late reservation. Their phone message says you don't need a reservation... but you need a reservation. Made a reservation at 10 am Monday for dinner that night and got the last available time at 8:30. Everything else was booked up. Unfortunately, the prime rib was sold out. But I had the ribeye and it was Awesome! Cooked perfect medium rare. One in our group ordered one "Blue Rare". Apparently, most places rarely get this right for her, but she loved it. Came cooked perfectly. Our waitress Nicole was Awesome! Perfectly attentive. Cheerful. If you needed a refill on water or drinks, she was there before you realized you needed something. Other than them being out of a couple things at the end of the night, the experience was perfect.
Melissa
Service was great and love the decor. This time the food wasn't great. My steak was over cooked and my family all had prime rib and just no flavor. Huge quantity but little flavor. Disappointing for $300 bill. Service was great so we didn't say anything just won't be back again this trip.
Dustin
Our server was fantastic. Food was amazing - we'll be back, for sure. It would be nice to have a barista for additional coffee drinks...
Annette
Overall, we had a mediocre experience at Legend's. Even though we had reservations, we still had to wait for about 10 minutes to receive a text that our table was ready. The restaurant is located downstairs in the hotel. The prime rib was a huge portion and very tender. However, I was disappointed in the flavor. It was very bland with little to no flavor. We received poor service from our waiter. He never returned to ask if we wanted refills, if the food was up to par, or if we wanted to order more cocktails. We had to flag him down to order dessert. He seemed very put out about this request. Overall, we had a mediocre experience at best. I was expecting more since this is the place that everyone recommends when coming to Deadwood.
Scott
The food was excellent. Had the bison ribeye, would probably just opt for the prime rib next time. It was not all that special. Also had the lobster dinner which was very good. The toffee dessert was outstanding. The green goddess salad dressing definitely stood out as a highlight. The place itself, however, was quite noisy, so would have liked a little quieter place for our anniversary celebration.
Linda K.
Our steaks were perfectly prepared and delicious. Nicole provided excellent service with an upbeat, friendly and positive attitude. We'll be back!
Angela
Steaks were cooked as ordered and very flavorful. Baked potato was not hot. Wine glass was chipped.
Stacy
Fabulous dinner! We do not usually dine at diner restaurants but this one is a keeper for sure. If we ever find ourselves back in the area we will definitely stop by here again.
Jane
Soup of the day was outstanding. Our filets were tender—loved the way the green beans were prepared and the bread. Would recommend eating there.
Ed
Reservation through Open ensured we were seated on time during a very busy festival. Service at Legends was exquisite and food served to perfection as always.
This is a great place for a nice cozy dinner. Amazing food with a great atmosphere. Very nice place.
Lori
Always have great food and great service. The atmosphere is comfortable and classic and noise level is low enough you can converse comfortably.
Ken
Fantastic experience, food was delicious, well prepared and cooked to order. Service was wonderful and hope to return soon!
Polly
I took my out of state friends and they all said it was the best meal they've ever had! They would have told me if it wasn't...they are picky and don't like trying new things!
Matthew
I have eaten at Legends twice and both times the experience was exceptional. The food was amazing and the service was excellent. We both had the Steak Oscar and a wedge salad. The steak was cooked to perfection and the salad with the green goddess dressing was the best we ever had. Our server Jordan was very attentive and personable. I highly recommend visiting this restaurant. Prices may be a little high but worth it.
Came in for a late reservation. Their phone message says you don't need a reservation... but you need a reservation. Made a reservation at 10 am Monday for dinner that night and got the last available time at 8:30. Everything else was booked up. Unfortunately, the prime rib was sold out. But I had the ribeye and it was Awesome! Cooked perfect medium rare. One in our group ordered one "Blue Rare". Apparently, most places rarely get this right for her, but she loved it. Came cooked perfectly. Our waitress Nicole was Awesome! Perfectly attentive. Cheerful. If you needed a refill on water or drinks, she was there before you realized you needed something. Other than them being out of a couple things at the end of the night, the experience was perfect.
Service was great and love the decor. This time the food wasn't great. My steak was over cooked and my family all had prime rib and just no flavor. Huge quantity but little flavor. Disappointing for $300 bill. Service was great so we didn't say anything just won't be back again this trip.
Our server was fantastic. Food was amazing - we'll be back, for sure. It would be nice to have a barista for additional coffee drinks...
Overall, we had a mediocre experience at Legend's. Even though we had reservations, we still had to wait for about 10 minutes to receive a text that our table was ready. The restaurant is located downstairs in the hotel. The prime rib was a huge portion and very tender. However, I was disappointed in the flavor. It was very bland with little to no flavor. We received poor service from our waiter. He never returned to ask if we wanted refills, if the food was up to par, or if we wanted to order more cocktails. We had to flag him down to order dessert. He seemed very put out about this request. Overall, we had a mediocre experience at best. I was expecting more since this is the place that everyone recommends when coming to Deadwood.
The food was excellent. Had the bison ribeye, would probably just opt for the prime rib next time. It was not all that special. Also had the lobster dinner which was very good. The toffee dessert was outstanding. The green goddess salad dressing definitely stood out as a highlight. The place itself, however, was quite noisy, so would have liked a little quieter place for our anniversary celebration.
Our steaks were perfectly prepared and delicious. Nicole provided excellent service with an upbeat, friendly and positive attitude. We'll be back!
Steaks were cooked as ordered and very flavorful. Baked potato was not hot. Wine glass was chipped.
Fabulous dinner! We do not usually dine at diner restaurants but this one is a keeper for sure. If we ever find ourselves back in the area we will definitely stop by here again.
Soup of the day was outstanding. Our filets were tender—loved the way the green beans were prepared and the bread. Would recommend eating there.
Reservation through Open ensured we were seated on time during a very busy festival. Service at Legends was exquisite and food served to perfection as always.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a great place for a nice cozy dinner. Amazing food with a great atmosphere. Very nice place.
Always have great food and great service. The atmosphere is comfortable and classic and noise level is low enough you can converse comfortably.
Fantastic experience, food was delicious, well prepared and cooked to order. Service was wonderful and hope to return soon!
I took my out of state friends and they all said it was the best meal they've ever had! They would have told me if it wasn't...they are picky and don't like trying new things!
I have eaten at Legends twice and both times the experience was exceptional. The food was amazing and the service was excellent. We both had the Steak Oscar and a wedge salad. The steak was cooked to perfection and the salad with the green goddess dressing was the best we ever had. Our server Jordan was very attentive and personable. I highly recommend visiting this restaurant. Prices may be a little high but worth it.
Loading...