Mustang Sally's

634 Main St, Deadwood
(605) 578-2025

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andrew Newcomb

Brutal, insanely overpriced for microwave food.

Terry Pratt

We have actually went there twice or maybe three times. Can't remember. The food was great. The service was excellent. They were very fast and the food was always good no matter what we got. I would highly recommend going there went in Deadwood for any meal, lunch or dinner.

Gypsy Farmer

I stood around waiting to get seated while all the staff didn’t even ask if i been helped or anything, the staff is super weird and rude… dont recommend this place, mediocre food

Mia Llouve

Wow, the hostess at the front are so rude. The girls treated my dad and my sister like they were dumb asking about wait time and as they were explaining they were like “dO yOu uNdErStanD ThAt.” Ew embarssinggg

Coty Tanner

This was a cool place to visit while in Deadwood. The inside decor is awesome, lots of signed jerseys. There is a small video arcade. The staff was nice, bit seemed rather rushed the whole time, kind of making you feel like you need to hurry to be ready to order. Downside was the food. My son's chicken strips were ok, my wife's wings were not cooked long enough to be crispy, and they won't let you get more than 1 flavor for the wings, without a reason as to why. The bad part was my chili dog. It was literally cold, the chili and the hot dog. They make the chili which was ok, but it's far too wet for a chili dog, so the bun was soaked through. So in the long run, when we visit again, we will probably find ourselves eating at a different place. It is a very cool atmosphere though.

M. R.

Great spot on the Deadwood strip. Izzy recommended the best food and drinks!

Todd Brokaw

This place used to be great now the burgers are soaked in water they are tasteless buns are stale.

Jerry King

It's basically comfort food when you need it. Kind of johnny rockets. Hot dogs, burgers, and so forth

Amanda Guest

Expect fried food quality-sampler basket is good for what it is. Fish n chips is just frozen fish, nothing fresh.

Daylene and Brad Hendricks

Stopped in for lunch, had the chicken strips and fries and it was delicious!

John Grothe

Best place to eat, service was awesome, Staff was even better!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Petersen

Great food and great service! Mason made it a great experience and was the best waiter! 10/10 would come again based off his great service and his hospitality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Baumann

Probably one of the worst dining experiences in Deadwood. Food was received fairly quickly and it was ok. Not great by any means. Each of us bought a drink, 1 beer, 1 blueberry mule, 1 regular mule and 1 bloody Mary. When we mentioned to the waitress that the regular mule and the bloody mary were awful, she asked if we wanted new ones. I said I'd like a new bloody mary, never got a new one. The regular mule was returned with one sip out of it. She charged us for both even though we didn't actually get the drink. We'll avoid Mustang Sally's next time and go elsewhere when we are in Deadwood next.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Gina Grimsley

After 9 in the evening about the only place to grab a bite. Service was good, fast and the food was also good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fries, Cheeseburger

princess guinevere

had fish and chips and salad on the side, service is quick, and when i seen the food its obvious why its quick, its store bought frozen fish maybe the fries is real fresh made but the side if salad is also store bought pre-packed in small to go container with small bag of crouton, we were asked what kind of dips, we choose ranch, it was kraft sachet packets, thought it be house made. we were starving so we ate most of it. but definitely not going to come back again. regretted that we didnt eat at dales instead. service is good, server is very nice and warm.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fries, Fish

Loading...