My husband and I had the 10oz sirloin. It was tender and delicious cooked to perfection. We highly recommend the sweet potato fries and mashed potatoes. Staff were attentive and kind, and we didn’t wait long for our food. The only thing I didn’t like was that my water and lemonade tasted bad…city water? Space was rustic and clean.
Decoy Doggers
Nice place. A bit pricey, but good food.
oilworm620
Food was great!!! Servers are awesome! Spend about $120 not including tip!
Nancy Klumpp
Very pricey 55 for steak and the quality was poor. 6 people we all ordered different items. It’s one thing to have higher prices for a quality meal but none of us were satisfied. The waitress informed us it was prime meats. Our experience did not reflect that. Would not recommend or return.
Megan Stith
Food was great!! The casual atmosphere fit our crew perfectly. Steaks were cooked exactly as ordered. Lyndsey was a great server!! I'm happy!
Paul Tavella
The staff and ownership are dedicated to your dining experience. My wife and I had a great meal and drinks. A great place to reflect on the days events and enjoy yourself.
Phil Bankester
We happened upon the 1885 and couldn’t have been more pleased. The staff was extremely pleasant, the atmosphere was perfect, and the food was excellent.
Dorene Bankester
Absolutely fabulous service, food, & atmosphere💖
Jeremy Holtquist
The chicken fried steak was awful the gravy looked like it was a day old the chicken fried steak straight out of a box. Not worth $27.00
David Rojas
Beautiful place but the food was definitely bland. Chicken fried steak tasted out of a box, mac n cheese tasted like chalk with over cooked noodles
Restaurantji Recommends
Cream - 116 Main St
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Coffee & Tea
This was our favorite restaurant that we tried in the Black Hills. We initially planning on visiting another restaurant that night, but the other restaurant had an hour and a half wait, so we decided to see what else was out there and we are so glad that we found 1885! We got right in at 1885. My husband had the ribeye, which the waitress asked us to cut into before she left to make sure it was cooked to expectations. It was and that small touch was much appreciated. He said it was the best steak he'd had in a long time - and he eats a lot of steak. I had the Cajun Walleye, which was also delicious. Perfectly seasoned and cooked so that it was moist and flakey. Our teenage kids also really enjoyed their burgers and fries. The wait staff was quick, attentive and courteous. All around a great experience! We would highly recommend this restaurant and will go back next time we are in the Black Hills.
Kid-friendliness: The menu and atmosphere were very welcoming for young and older kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Potato Fries, Sweet Cinnamon Butter and Hot Bread, Rib Eye Seasoned and Cooked to Perfection
Jane Doe
Hill City was a last minute decision on our trip to SD. We were hungry after spending the day outside, so we pulled up restaurants here and decided on the 1880 Steakhouse & Saloon. As we walked up to the front doors it already smelled amazing. We were greeted with a friendly waitress and she took good care of us! My husband had the ribs and I had the ribeye (I did share my steak with him) and we shared the blueberry peach cobbler...everything was AMAZING!! So happy we stopped here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rib Eye Seasoned and Cooked to Perfection
Paolo Donatello Doneda (Pablito)
Dry hamburger, rushed service, at 8pm they started washing the floors with us still at the table. High prices, even for South Dakota.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Amy Master
The food was AMAZING!! The bread and homemade butter was phenomenal! The steak was the best steak I’ve ever had. Our server was amazing. 10/10 experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
donna mcdermott
Food was awesome and reasonably priced. We will definitely go again!
My husband and I had the 10oz sirloin. It was tender and delicious cooked to perfection. We highly recommend the sweet potato fries and mashed potatoes. Staff were attentive and kind, and we didn’t wait long for our food. The only thing I didn’t like was that my water and lemonade tasted bad…city water? Space was rustic and clean.
Nice place. A bit pricey, but good food.
Food was great!!!
Servers are awesome!
Spend about $120 not including tip!
Very pricey 55 for steak and the quality was poor. 6 people we all ordered different items. It’s one thing to have higher prices for a quality meal but none of us were satisfied. The waitress informed us it was prime meats. Our experience did not reflect that. Would not recommend or return.
Food was great!! The casual atmosphere fit our crew perfectly. Steaks were cooked exactly as ordered. Lyndsey was a great server!! I'm happy!
The staff and ownership are dedicated to your dining experience. My wife and I had a great meal and drinks. A great place to reflect on the days events and enjoy yourself.
We happened upon the 1885 and couldn’t have been more pleased. The staff was extremely pleasant, the atmosphere was perfect, and the food was excellent.
Absolutely fabulous service, food, & atmosphere💖
The chicken fried steak was awful the gravy looked like it was a day old the chicken fried steak straight out of a box. Not worth $27.00
Beautiful place but the food was definitely bland. Chicken fried steak tasted out of a box, mac n cheese tasted like chalk with over cooked noodles
Restaurantji Recommends
This was our favorite restaurant that we tried in the Black Hills. We initially planning on visiting another restaurant that night, but the other restaurant had an hour and a half wait, so we decided to see what else was out there and we are so glad that we found 1885! We got right in at 1885. My husband had the ribeye, which the waitress asked us to cut into before she left to make sure it was cooked to expectations. It was and that small touch was much appreciated. He said it was the best steak he'd had in a long time - and he eats a lot of steak. I had the Cajun Walleye, which was also delicious. Perfectly seasoned and cooked so that it was moist and flakey. Our teenage kids also really enjoyed their burgers and fries. The wait staff was quick, attentive and courteous. All around a great experience! We would highly recommend this restaurant and will go back next time we are in the Black Hills.
Kid-friendliness: The menu and atmosphere were very welcoming for young and older kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Potato Fries, Sweet Cinnamon Butter and Hot Bread, Rib Eye Seasoned and Cooked to Perfection
Hill City was a last minute decision on our trip to SD. We were hungry after spending the day outside, so we pulled up restaurants here and decided on the 1880 Steakhouse & Saloon. As we walked up to the front doors it already smelled amazing. We were greeted with a friendly waitress and she took good care of us! My husband had the ribs and I had the ribeye (I did share my steak with him) and we shared the blueberry peach cobbler...everything was AMAZING!! So happy we stopped here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rib Eye Seasoned and Cooked to Perfection
Dry hamburger, rushed service, at 8pm they started washing the floors with us still at the table. High prices, even for South Dakota.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
The food was AMAZING!! The bread and homemade butter was phenomenal! The steak was the best steak I’ve ever had. Our server was amazing. 10/10 experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was awesome and reasonably priced. We will definitely go again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...