McNally's Irish Pub

We had the Shepard pie for lunch. It was 80% mashed potatoes. Very little meat on the bottom layer. We were able to find 2 peas and 2 kernels of corn. It was very warm and had a good amount of cheese. The flavor was good but mostly potatoes. Not worth $22

Good food, good service, beautiful bar restaurant. Food and drink are on the upper price range, but quality is very good.

The new McNally's menu is much better than the previous McNally's menu. There are more choices for lunch and dinner. I was there with a friend for lunch and I had the Beef Philly which was delicious. Wait staff was attentive, but we waited well over 30 minutes for our food to be delivered (1 pm on a Thursday). We were told they were still hiring kitchen staff.

The reimagined McNally’s is as nice physically as the old. We sat on the patio, which has always been a great spot in nice weather. The wait person did a very good job with service, and was working extremely hard during a peak and crowded time. My steak was tender with a good flavor. All pluses. On the negative side, someone was surreptitiously smoking a cigarette near us, which was not only illegal and rude, but very obvious. The staff did nothing. Several tables around us were angry about the smell as she used a tree for an ashtray. Also bad, my wife ordered a Cobb salad with grilled chicken. The chicken was dark and very fatty. The server had no idea what it was, and after asking the kitchen, it turned out to be thigh meat and not breast. While chicken thighs have become popular for some dishes, it was rather disgusting on a salad. We have never seen a dish with thighs where the menu did not actually state that fact. So, overall good, but definitely needs some work to win us over.

Went there today for dinner. Good food and service. Really good corned beef and the French dip was good. Will definitely be going back.

Went there Saturday afternoon sat on patio they ignored us shitty service won't go back

Closed. - was a good spot

So very sad to learn that this place is closed now.

Wheelchair accessibility: All on first floor no

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich

Good vibes

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Very pleasant experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was a Monday night it was closed? They hv the Best bangers n mash on the menu!!! So sad we missed it. McNally’s is a regular spot for us when traveling into SF fr CO!!!

One of the places I absolutely have to go every time I'm in town. Everything is absolutely amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Boyfriend and I went last night and both had the corned beef and cabbage. The corned beef was inedible. Was hard to chew…could hardly cut it…had to spit it out because of how hard it was to chew. The cabbage and potatoes were fantastic.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Great atmosphere and some of the best Guiness in Sioux Falls!