I see all of these reviews and no one mentions that it is on the other side of Philips Street. I posted a picture of the door and hopefully that helps. On the other hand, I suppose that you could enter from the bar, Hi Hello (or is it Hello Hi). Basically, if you're on Philips Street, there really isn't a sign pointing you to Pizza Cheeks. Hi Hello (or Hello Hi) has a pizza neon sign in their window, but that doesn't really mean anything other than they maybe serve pizza because it sure doesn't say Pizza Cheeks inside. The NY style pizza is really good. It's a little on the saltier side, but I still found myself wanting another slice. And I probably should've gotten two slices, but I opted for the focaccia that is on their menu. It was bread. Nothing more. I ordered dipping sauces for it, but the bread itself was bland.
Chris Cook
Wow! Just had the most amazing culinary experience at Pizza Cheeks, and I'm absolutely buzzing to share it! Let's dive right in: their meatball sliders are a revelation. Imagine the most succulent, perfectly seasoned meatballs, each a masterpiece of flavor, nestled between slices of heavenly bread that's just the right combination of crispy and soft. It's like they've captured the essence of comfort food and elevated it to a gourmet experience.But wait, there's more! The true highlight of Pizza Cheeks isn't just their mouth-watering sliders; it's the delightful presence of Ceara at the window. Her smile? Infectious. Her service? Impeccable. She doesn't just sell you a burger; she enchants you with her charm, making every bite of those sliders taste like a slice of heaven. The way she presents the sliders, with a twinkle in her eye and a joy in her service, turns a simple meal into a memorable event. Kudos to Pizza Cheeks for not just their culinary prowess, but for having a gem like Ceara making the experience unforgettable. If you haven't tried these meatball sliders yet, you're missing out on a gastronomical delight of epic proportions!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joey R.
A bit tricky to find if you don't know what you are looking for, there is a single counter in a hallway at the back of the Hello Hi bar, restraunt staff was fast, friendly, and helpful. We just bought 2 slices for about $5 a piece and they did not disappoint!, will absolutely return for lunch soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey
Zach W.
Cool place w the bar attached. The pizza was good for NY style, I'm a pub Chicago pizza guys, so.. in town for work but recommend to try and if local I'd go eat often.
Katie L Kruger
Ordered a pizza got delivered to our house. Had a huge hair in one of the pieces of pizza was disgusting. Call to see what they could do about it. Best they could do is give me 50% off next order- never ordering from them again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dylan McD
I travel for a living and have eaten pizza anywhere and everywhere- this place holds up with ANY NY, Connecticut, NJ, etc type joint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darla Bumgardner
We have been searching for NY style pizza…. This was close, however the pizza (we think it’s the crust) was super salty. Texture, toppings, and crust consistency were all excellent… just way too salty.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Jane Fixsel
Great place to go. Little hard to find at first, needs better street signage. Will definitely go again. They need to fix their wobbly backyard tables.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Pepper Flakes Added
Jessica larocca
Great atmosphere. Bartender was server. Seemed like he was not a happy guy. Food was New York style pizza which was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Allison P.
This place is phenomenal. Best pizza that I have had in Sioux Falls by far. The crust is chewy and delicious and (sleeper pick but,) their ranch is really good ! Their late night slices are bomb- classic pepperoni is a 10/10. You should definitely order from here.
Located in the back of the Hello Hi Tiki bar. We ordered a couple slices of pepperoni pizza. One can order pizza by the pie or by the slice. Whole pizzas are large (18”). Pizza is thin crust and was delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
Tiffany H.
Finally a good pizza place in Sioux Falls. 10/10 New York style pizza! The crust was perfectly crispy while the cheese was nice a gooey. Decent amount of toppings, and only took about 15 minutes from the time I placed the order.
William G.
Sassy, deaf, likely menopausal counter staff. At least the pizza was pretty good, but still twice the price of dominos.
Colleen Weber
I was a Pizza Cheeks virgin until today. There are no words. The delicious pizza (the best in Sioux Falls hands-down) is second only to the wonderful people who work here. Zaryn (?sp) could tell I was needing some assistance due to my recent knee surgery. Before she could even offer, there stood Seth with my pizza in hand and asked if he could walk me to my car!!! Who does that? Well the staff at Pizza Cheeks do!! He carefully placed the pizza in my car, then turned to give me a big hug (it's all good cuz I'm a hugger) and offered his best for a rapid recovery. I am forever "ruined" as I won't be able to eat any other pizza. Love you all at Pizza Cheeks!!! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
XvoseEthereal
For some reason the dough just tastes off. Must be local water or something. Anyways spendy ingredients only go so far if you don't have a good canvas! Good luck mr tyler.
I see all of these reviews and no one mentions that it is on the other side of Philips Street. I posted a picture of the door and hopefully that helps. On the other hand, I suppose that you could enter from the bar, Hi Hello (or is it Hello Hi). Basically, if you're on Philips Street, there really isn't a sign pointing you to Pizza Cheeks. Hi Hello (or Hello Hi) has a pizza neon sign in their window, but that doesn't really mean anything other than they maybe serve pizza because it sure doesn't say Pizza Cheeks inside. The NY style pizza is really good. It's a little on the saltier side, but I still found myself wanting another slice. And I probably should've gotten two slices, but I opted for the focaccia that is on their menu. It was bread. Nothing more. I ordered dipping sauces for it, but the bread itself was bland.
Wow! Just had the most amazing culinary experience at Pizza Cheeks, and I'm absolutely buzzing to share it! Let's dive right in: their meatball sliders are a revelation. Imagine the most succulent, perfectly seasoned meatballs, each a masterpiece of flavor, nestled between slices of heavenly bread that's just the right combination of crispy and soft. It's like they've captured the essence of comfort food and elevated it to a gourmet experience.But wait, there's more! The true highlight of Pizza Cheeks isn't just their mouth-watering sliders; it's the delightful presence of Ceara at the window. Her smile? Infectious. Her service? Impeccable. She doesn't just sell you a burger; she enchants you with her charm, making every bite of those sliders taste like a slice of heaven. The way she presents the sliders, with a twinkle in her eye and a joy in her service, turns a simple meal into a memorable event. Kudos to Pizza Cheeks for not just their culinary prowess, but for having a gem like Ceara making the experience unforgettable. If you haven't tried these meatball sliders yet, you're missing out on a gastronomical delight of epic proportions!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A bit tricky to find if you don't know what you are looking for, there is a single counter in a hallway at the back of the Hello Hi bar, restraunt staff was fast, friendly, and helpful. We just bought 2 slices for about $5 a piece and they did not disappoint!, will absolutely return for lunch soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey
Cool place w the bar attached. The pizza was good for NY style, I'm a pub Chicago pizza guys, so.. in town for work but recommend to try and if local I'd go eat often.
Ordered a pizza got delivered to our house. Had a huge hair in one of the pieces of pizza was disgusting. Call to see what they could do about it. Best they could do is give me 50% off next order- never ordering from them again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
I travel for a living and have eaten pizza anywhere and everywhere- this place holds up with ANY NY, Connecticut, NJ, etc type joint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been searching for NY style pizza…. This was close, however the pizza (we think it’s the crust) was super salty. Texture, toppings, and crust consistency were all excellent… just way too salty.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great place to go. Little hard to find at first, needs better street signage. Will definitely go again. They need to fix their wobbly backyard tables.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza with Pepper Flakes Added
Great atmosphere. Bartender was server. Seemed like he was not a happy guy. Food was New York style pizza which was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
This place is phenomenal. Best pizza that I have had in Sioux Falls by far. The crust is chewy and delicious and (sleeper pick but,) their ranch is really good ! Their late night slices are bomb- classic pepperoni is a 10/10. You should definitely order from here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Located in the back of the Hello Hi Tiki bar. We ordered a couple slices of pepperoni pizza. One can order pizza by the pie or by the slice. Whole pizzas are large (18”). Pizza is thin crust and was delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
Finally a good pizza place in Sioux Falls. 10/10 New York style pizza! The crust was perfectly crispy while the cheese was nice a gooey. Decent amount of toppings, and only took about 15 minutes from the time I placed the order.
Sassy, deaf, likely menopausal counter staff. At least the pizza was pretty good, but still twice the price of dominos.
I was a Pizza Cheeks virgin until today. There are no words. The delicious pizza (the best in Sioux Falls hands-down) is second only to the wonderful people who work here. Zaryn (?sp) could tell I was needing some assistance due to my recent knee surgery. Before she could even offer, there stood Seth with my pizza in hand and asked if he could walk me to my car!!! Who does that? Well the staff at Pizza Cheeks do!! He carefully placed the pizza in my car, then turned to give me a big hug (it's all good cuz I'm a hugger) and offered his best for a rapid recovery. I am forever "ruined" as I won't be able to eat any other pizza. Love you all at Pizza Cheeks!!! Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For some reason the dough just tastes off. Must be local water or something. Anyways spendy ingredients only go so far if you don't have a good canvas! Good luck mr tyler.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice, Tomato Ricotta