The Good Witch Cake Shop

We worked with Shelby to make our wedding cakes, and she did an amazing job! We had three separate cakes with different flavors, and they tasted fantastic! I wanted more of a vintage style cake, and I showed her a picture of some examples I had found on Pinterest, and she delivered!

Cupcakes dry and frosting is tasteless. The frosting also leaves a weird layer of lard on your tongue and teeth.

My husband and friends surprised me on my birthday during the rally with this giant, beautiful and amazingly delicious chocolate cake. I was told how accommodating the bakery was making sure the cake was boxed up just so we could take it on our motorcycles. They helped make my birthday perfect!!

My husband and friends surprised me on my birthday during the rally with this giant, beautiful and amazingly delicious chocolate cake. I was told how accommodating the bakery was making sure the cake was boxed up just so we could take it on our motorcycles. They helped make my birthday perfect!!

Visited here a couple of weeks ago while staying in Sturgis on vacation. Both the scone and the quiche were some of the best I've ever had so went back for more the next. Everything was absolutely delicious and the service was great!

Website said it’s open at 7 got there at 8 and it was closed not going to be in business very long. If you advertise your open, then you’re closed.

Literally the CUTEST bakery ever with super nice customer service and delicious treats!

Wow,They interviewed the owner of this establisment after the news yesterday evening. After checking out the website, it stated open on Saturday, until 2 pm. We drove 50 miles to visit this shop, 9:30 AM and the shop was closed.What an awful disapppintment, no way to run a business.

Wonderful customer service! Every treat on the tray was delicious.

Great variety, everything I tried tastes wonderful!!

My husband and I ordered our wedding cake through The Good Witch, from out of state. We could not have been happier with the entire experience! Shelby worked with us to finalize everything from separate states and it was super delicious and beautiful! Thank you so much for helping to make my wedding day perfect!

Shelby at The Good Witch Cake Shop is AMAZING! We were looking for a wedding cake vendor in the Black Hills and another vendor had recommended this shop. From the minute we walked in for our cake tasting, we knew this was the place we wanted to work with. Shelby was so friendly and really wanted to get to know us and what we wanted. The buttercream is sooo light and smooth - so so delicious. She totally nailed our cake design and the jumbo cupcakes were such a hit! We were able to get many flavors so everyone at the wedding could pick their favorite. We would hire The Good Witch Cake Shop to do desserts at any event! Highly recommend!

Beautiful place, very good cakes, Lovely staff.Unfortunately they don't have decaf ,and with my heart condition i can't have normal coffee,so i just took a sip from my husband's!

Exceeded expectation, went above and beyond for us on such a short notice. Will be the only place I order custom cakes from for here on out!!!! It was also absolutely delicious!

Don't know, sign showed open but another sign showed closed until 7:45 A.M. I wanted to 8:06 and checked the door - lockef.