Sinfully Sweet Cathedral Bakery

They had lots of cakes to choose from, they looked colourful and nice, and this fooled us to buy their biggest birthday cake!!!
We bought it before testing a small cup cake first to check how they taste!!
In the birthday party everyone agreed that the cake was excessively sweet and very sticky, like glue!! :((
We finally discarded almost half the $85 cake untouched plus all the left overs in the guest plates who couldn't finish their cakes!!
We wasted almost $100 including tip on this big cake, whereas we should have bought a better one from Safeway for less than half the price, and most importantly that people would more possibly enjoy it.
I suggest testing and purchasing a small cupcake from them first and then if you like it going for a big cake like this !!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Custom Birthday Cake

We bought a couple frozen Saskatoon Berry pies today to share with friends. Holy smokes. Lots of berries, amazing crust. Wonderful wonderful pies. Can’t recommend enough.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place, wonderful staff and mouthwatering backed goods.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Perfect little cake but was EXTREMELY disappointed in the topper. I asked for a simple happy birthday in gold or something to match the aesthetic of the cake instead I got this. Makes sense as to why she didn’t show me the topper I noticed when I got back to my car it was such an eye sore & I was so disappointed . Looks like they used a worn out sharpie marker! Part of the topper missing due to me being mad and taking a bite of frustration from the corner before I took a picture. Point being love the place and have been coming here for a long time, first time I’ve been disappointed just wanted to make the cake decor aware this isn’t acceptable and I would’ve rather her not put nothing at all over this.

Where to start I bought a lot of different items for my wife's birthday party. The peach pie was disgusting. Half the tarts where not even cooked. And the chocolate muffins where moist but the taste was lacking.
I do not recommend this bakery.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Great experience! Couldn’t decide what kind of cake I wanted for my birthday so instead we stopped in to pick a variety from their ready made cupcakes. Each flavour was delicious, perfectly moist cake, decadent icing. Perfect level of sweetness in my opinion. They were very helpful and kind to us as well. We will definitely be back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This bakery needs to be your go-to place! They have come through for me over the years in so many ways, from designing a stunning wedding cake that tasted so delicious I still have guests raving about it 6 years later, to spit on event cakes, and themed birthday cakes. Recently, my husband and I had a bit of a communication mix up and we went in asking for a custom birthday cake last minute (I do not recommend doing this ever), yet with a smile and a bead of sweat they saved the day and created an amazing cake for the birthday!
There’s a reason why they are always brought up when people ask for bakery recommendations, they are skilled, friendly and care about their work and their customers.

My daughter who’s obsessed with nightmare before Christmas asked for her 4th bday party in June to be jack skellington themed so we did just that. This cake was UNREAL. Looked amazing, tasted amazing, wasn’t too sweet and was moist and made to perfection. Everyone kept raving about it at the party. I had talked with Eryn about my idea and let her work her magic. It was phenomenal customer service and product! Thank you sooo much!! 10000 stars! ⭐️

Pretty disappointed. The service was great. They were responsive through emails and let me pick up without a deposit. After reading and hearing all the reviews about how tasty their food was I am severely let down. $50 for 12 cupcakes and what I paid for was for them to look cool essentially. The cupcakes were dry and flavourless (no vanilla taste whatsoever) and the icing was inedible. So I guess service was good and the cupcakes looked nice, but I’d rather have bought a poster for $12 since I can’t eat a poster either…

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

This bakery has the best cupcakes I have ever tasted! The cake is so moist and the flavors are out this world! I did just as she said, leave them out on the counter for a short while before eating. They are amazing!

Literally the best! Ordered a special slot machine themed cake for my dads 50th birthday with red velvet flavour. Tasted amazing 10/10.

Bought 6 different cupcakes and every one of them were crumbly and fell apart and a bit dry. Icing is way too sweet.

The service was ok 6 out of 10, a little lacking in communication. I asked for light icing, but it seemed to be mostly icing. 2 out of 10. So over the top sweet. 2 out of 10. The birthday cakes looked ok 6 out of 10. The cake was a marble which I found a little dry and tasteless. 4 out of 10. I most likely will not use this place again.

Bewildering cup cake selection

The products I purchased were days old and overpriced, the staff was unwelcoming. I won’t return.