I think that the pizza is amazing! It is different and every bite is wonderful! My favorite is the Hawaiian pizza with Xtra pineapple. OMG, it is awesome! And then my husband and I pair our pizza with a salad. Their salads have just the right amount of everything you want on your salad. If I am being honest, I think the salads are even better than the pizza. But if you put the two together....in my opinion....best meal ever!! The only reason I only gave them 4*s and not 5 is because the woman who answered the phone did not listen very well to our order we placed on the phone, because even though she repeated our order back to us, when our order arrived (via delivery) our dessert calzone was missing from the order. And the delivery driver would not go back to get it for us because he said it was not on the order that was placed?? I tried to call to get them to bring it since it was their mess up, but nobody ever answered the phone! I expected them to fix their mistake, but they did not do so!! Especially since we frequent this establishment since we live so close to it!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Bernadine Dillon
Nicest people.. customer service was above any place I've been .. Definitely will be back and tell others
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harold B.
Great pizza and wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Millner
I've already posted this once but after waiting in line for 30+ mins to place an order for one pizza and cheese sticks after working in the hot sun throwing hay bales! With only one car in front who got their food quickly. The guy asked us one time if we had a call in order and we said no we wanted to place an order for the above items. He says ok I'll be right back after 5 more answered phone calls I said they can keep their pizza and I'll never eat their again 😭😭 especially since it is the only pizza I can eat that doesn't make me sick for days or a week!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Subhasish Nanda
Excellent food, one of the best pizza I have had. Stumbled on this gem on our road trip. Excellent service and a very nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beck C
They have great food and great customer service. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neal Evans
I eat here way too often
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Giovanni Yara
Best service in the region. Super friendly and helpful team leader-manager. The food was okay. Overall with the stop for supper.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Darlene Alaimo
I ordered a pizza and it's doughy undercooked,top side. I looked at reviews on Google and seen another lady charge $23 for large pineapple n ham. a large one topping 10.99 so extra topping is $10.00. lady says it's because it's specialty pizza. aother issue we had same experience with pineapple ham. she did offer for me to come back n replace under cooked pizza.
Jennifer Boylan
Great food and the employees are awesome! I highly recommend this location!!
Basic. But surprisingly decent spaghetti. Not over cooked much. Great service by team leader shift mngr. A one time stop for me as driving thru TN and grabbed a nearby hotel. Low cost!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Shana Mosley Buell
They have great pizza, delivery is always good too
mikala brown
Basic pizza but when you don’t have other options it’s good! Their buffet is the best thing they have.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Pizza Buffet
Annita Oxford
Traveling from Texas to New Jersey and due to weather conditions, we had to make an unplanned stop and get a hotel to wait out weather. Not wanting to get out and drive for food, we order delivery. We had the pizza, the BarBQ boneless wings, and the salad. The cost was very reasonable. I spent 50 ish $ but we ordered a lot. So I was pleased with the price. I've spent way more for less at other places. Now, for my thoughts on quality and service. Pizza was perfect, wings were great, and the salad was wonderful. The veggies were fresh, and yes, I am a very picky person about everything, especially my food. They even have Italian dressing. Seems that since the covid epidemic, almost no restaurants have the only dressing I use, so I was a very happy girl. I appreciate the honesty of the lady on the phone when I asked about how long it would take to receive my order. And to my suprise it arrived much sooner than I had expected. In response to the low rated reviews they have from a few people. No, my order was 100% correct even with the special request I made to my order. Nothing was undercooked, burnt or greasy. Staff was honest, pleasant and helpful. Yes it is a small town cafe type place. Sadly due to our own mishaps my boyfriend ended up going back to the restaurant in person and said that the place is exceptionally clean inside. In his opinion the place is clean enough to eat of the floor. Place smelled nice and clean and restrooms are very clean. I have a feeling some of those low reviews they have came from people who were already having a bad day or were mad about other things and let's just say I think the they took out their frustrations on the Pizza Plus review. So YES, I would recommend this establishment to everyone. Sorry to say I don't have any photos to share but the photos shared by other reviews about cleanliness are accurate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Gamble
At 50 years of age, I just almost consumed quite possibly the worst excuse for a steak sandwich I’ve ever experienced. It wasn’t even prepared the way that I asked for it to be prepared. The “steak” was some kind of minced patty. The sauce was acceptable. I ate what I could to eliminate my hunger, and no more than that.
The soda had some kind of weird flavor to it, so I was unable to consume it, as well.
It’s been almost 30 years since I last ate at a Pizza Plus. Tonight, I was reminded why.
I think that the pizza is amazing! It is different and every bite is wonderful! My favorite is the Hawaiian pizza with Xtra pineapple. OMG, it is awesome! And then my husband and I pair our pizza with a salad. Their salads have just the right amount of everything you want on your salad. If I am being honest, I think the salads are even better than the pizza. But if you put the two together....in my opinion....best meal ever!! The only reason I only gave them 4*s and not 5 is because the woman who answered the phone did not listen very well to our order we placed on the phone, because even though she repeated our order back to us, when our order arrived (via delivery) our dessert calzone was missing from the order. And the delivery driver would not go back to get it for us because he said it was not on the order that was placed?? I tried to call to get them to bring it since it was their mess up, but nobody ever answered the phone! I expected them to fix their mistake, but they did not do so!! Especially since we frequent this establishment since we live so close to it!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Nicest people.. customer service was above any place I've been ..
Definitely will be back and tell others
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've already posted this once but after waiting in line for 30+ mins to place an order for one pizza and cheese sticks after working in the hot sun throwing hay bales! With only one car in front who got their food quickly. The guy asked us one time if we had a call in order and we said no we wanted to place an order for the above items. He says ok I'll be right back after 5 more answered phone calls I said they can keep their pizza and I'll never eat their again 😭😭 especially since it is the only pizza I can eat that doesn't make me sick for days or a week!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Excellent food, one of the best pizza I have had. Stumbled on this gem on our road trip. Excellent service and a very nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have great food and great customer service. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I eat here way too often
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best service in the region. Super friendly and helpful team leader-manager. The food was okay. Overall with the stop for supper.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I ordered a pizza and it's doughy undercooked,top side. I looked at reviews on Google and seen another lady charge $23 for large pineapple n ham. a large one topping 10.99 so extra topping is $10.00. lady says it's because it's specialty pizza. aother issue we had same experience with pineapple ham. she did offer for me to come back n replace under cooked pizza.
Great food and the employees are awesome! I highly recommend this location!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Basic. But surprisingly decent spaghetti. Not over cooked much.
Great service by team leader shift mngr. A one time stop for me as driving thru TN and grabbed a nearby hotel. Low cost!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
They have great pizza, delivery is always good too
Basic pizza but when you don’t have other options it’s good! Their buffet is the best thing they have.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Pizza Buffet
Traveling from Texas to New Jersey and due to weather conditions, we had to make an unplanned stop and get a hotel to wait out weather. Not wanting to get out and drive for food, we order delivery. We had the pizza, the BarBQ boneless wings, and the salad. The cost was very reasonable. I spent 50 ish $ but we ordered a lot. So I was pleased with the price. I've spent way more for less at other places. Now, for my thoughts on quality and service. Pizza was perfect, wings were great, and the salad was wonderful. The veggies were fresh, and yes, I am a very picky person about everything, especially my food. They even have Italian dressing. Seems that since the covid epidemic, almost no restaurants have the only dressing I use, so I was a very happy girl. I appreciate the honesty of the lady on the phone when I asked about how long it would take to receive my order. And to my suprise it arrived much sooner than I had expected. In response to the low rated reviews they have from a few people. No, my order was 100% correct even with the special request I made to my order. Nothing was undercooked, burnt or greasy. Staff was honest, pleasant and helpful. Yes it is a small town cafe type place. Sadly due to our own mishaps my boyfriend ended up going back to the restaurant in person and said that the place is exceptionally clean inside. In his opinion the place is clean enough to eat of the floor. Place smelled nice and clean and restrooms are very clean. I have a feeling some of those low reviews they have came from people who were already having a bad day or were mad about other things and let's just say I think the they took out their frustrations on the Pizza Plus review. So YES, I would recommend this establishment to everyone. Sorry to say I don't have any photos to share but the photos shared by other reviews about cleanliness are accurate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
At 50 years of age, I just almost consumed quite possibly the worst excuse for a steak sandwich I’ve ever experienced. It wasn’t even prepared the way that I asked for it to be prepared. The “steak” was some kind of minced patty. The sauce was acceptable. I ate what I could to eliminate my hunger, and no more than that.
The soda had some kind of weird flavor to it, so I was unable to consume it, as well.
It’s been almost 30 years since I last ate at a Pizza Plus. Tonight, I was reminded why.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...