I bought 2 small pcs. It was $18. So it was $9 per piece. I thought it was an expensive $$$ for a small piece of pie, so it might be a super delicious pie. Nope. Ordinary... just a pie that had no specialty for that price. I eat pie often and I know what a good pie is.
Danny Moore
Awesome baked goods. Everything is fresh and made locally, even their bagels! Everyone working there is very friendly and nice even the owner. We only bought a few items because we were just passing through town but will definitely be back to try more and highly recommend if you like fresh baked items give him a try.
Megan S.
No photos because everything was eaten! We had the suggested turtle pie - it was so soft and not dense, absolutely delicious. We had the banana cream, the coconut cream, and the chocolate cream (yes we have a type) and they were all so good. Our service was odd, she stayed in the back and answered questions through a window until we ordered... but the pie was so good that I would go back.
Ricky
Overpriced day old pie, nothing special.Unfriendly staff to customer.Would not stop here again.
Daniel A.
Unreal Pies! Some of the best pie I've had! This is homemade pie at its finest. Got greeted with a friendly welcome and then had some of the tastiest pie with unreal fresh filling, crumbly topping and a thin flakey crust. This review might be simple but don't underestimate these delicious pies!! loved these Blackberry Peach & Peanut Butter Silk Pies!
Abbah Galadeemh
I truly Recommend Mrs Heyley crypto she's the best professional crypto expert with good percentage ROI capability with proven record. After being scammed by fake platform i lost 8,000 USD to them, nevertheless I was still convinced that they are still genuine platform out there, luckily for me i found one and was able to recover my losses I deeply recommend her trading skills and extensive experience in the cryptocurrency field. Reach to her on Email : [email protected] What'sApp+15513552580
Thomas Perry
These may be the best pies you will ever eat. So why did I give them one star? You need to cash in your 401(k) to buy a pie. I recently ordered a sugar-free banana cream pie which I have done many many times. The last time I picked one up it was $28 which is pretty expensive but for special occasions they’re great. I picked one up today and it was $41. When I asked why they said “inflation“. Well inflation is around 8%, that price increases is about 58%. Don’t get me wrong these pies are fantastic but The price is ridiculous, unfortunately I won’t be back.
1953Cully
People, if you like this place, you''ll love Lynnville TN's Pie Company - a big assortment with friendly owners, Also a worthwhile adventure to shop in Lynnville TN
Robert Schrumpf
Delicious and friendly. The customer in front of us bought the last slice of coconut cream pie. Need more pie.
Really delicious and reasonable prices. I ordered a peach praline pie for a birthday and was able to pick it up within 24 hours of order!
Bill B.
This place started off in a coat closet and now they are downtown! Really good pie. I never had strawberry rhubarb pie before them. As soon as I had it my life changed for the better. I got a promotion at work, I found an oil reserve in my backyard, and my dog came back to me. Also their customer service is really good.
Audrea H.
Love pie. Then go here! You can get pie by the slice or a whole pie. I must go to spot if in downtown Columbia TN!!!
Athena Jeffers
Very unfriendly girl. Tried to call manager and she wouldn't let me talk to them. Way too high priced for a turtle "pie" which is brownie inside.of.pie crust! Not impressive at all. If I wanted a brownie I would have gotten a mix at the store! Also the whip cream is not whipped cream at all.....it's cheap cool whip so for $22 for 3 slices. Won't go back.
Angela W.
Awesome custom coconut cakes!! My friends and I are repeat customers-having taste tested other bakeries in town and been sorely disappointed by comparison, we will always choose Pie Sensations!!
Nearly $45 for 1 pie, they’re ok, seems greedy
I bought 2 small pcs. It was $18. So it was $9 per piece. I thought it was an expensive $$$ for a small piece of pie, so it might be a super delicious pie. Nope. Ordinary... just a pie that had no specialty for that price. I eat pie often and I know what a good pie is.
Awesome baked goods. Everything is fresh and made locally, even their bagels! Everyone working there is very friendly and nice even the owner. We only bought a few items because we were just passing through town but will definitely be back to try more and highly recommend if you like fresh baked items give him a try.
No photos because everything was eaten! We had the suggested turtle pie - it was so soft and not dense, absolutely delicious. We had the banana cream, the coconut cream, and the chocolate cream (yes we have a type) and they were all so good. Our service was odd, she stayed in the back and answered questions through a window until we ordered... but the pie was so good that I would go back.
Overpriced day old pie, nothing special.Unfriendly staff to customer.Would not stop here again.
Unreal Pies! Some of the best pie I've had! This is homemade pie at its finest. Got greeted with a friendly welcome and then had some of the tastiest pie with unreal fresh filling, crumbly topping and a thin flakey crust. This review might be simple but don't underestimate these delicious pies!! loved these Blackberry Peach & Peanut Butter Silk Pies!
I truly Recommend Mrs Heyley crypto she's the best professional crypto expert with good percentage ROI capability with proven record. After being scammed by fake platform i lost 8,000 USD to them, nevertheless I was still convinced that they are still genuine platform out there, luckily for me i found one and was able to recover my losses I deeply recommend her trading skills and extensive experience in the cryptocurrency field. Reach to her on Email : [email protected] What'sApp+15513552580
These may be the best pies you will ever eat. So why did I give them one star? You need to cash in your 401(k) to buy a pie. I recently ordered a sugar-free banana cream pie which I have done many many times. The last time I picked one up it was $28 which is pretty expensive but for special occasions they’re great. I picked one up today and it was $41. When I asked why they said “inflation“. Well inflation is around 8%, that price increases is about 58%. Don’t get me wrong these pies are fantastic but The price is ridiculous, unfortunately I won’t be back.
People, if you like this place, you''ll love Lynnville TN's Pie Company - a big assortment with friendly owners, Also a worthwhile adventure to shop in Lynnville TN
Delicious and friendly. The customer in front of us bought the last slice of coconut cream pie. Need more pie.
Restaurantji Recommends
Really delicious and reasonable prices. I ordered a peach praline pie for a birthday and was able to pick it up within 24 hours of order!
This place started off in a coat closet and now they are downtown! Really good pie. I never had strawberry rhubarb pie before them. As soon as I had it my life changed for the better. I got a promotion at work, I found an oil reserve in my backyard, and my dog came back to me. Also their customer service is really good.
Love pie. Then go here! You can get pie by the slice or a whole pie. I must go to spot if in downtown Columbia TN!!!
Very unfriendly girl. Tried to call manager and she wouldn't let me talk to them. Way too high priced for a turtle "pie" which is brownie inside.of.pie crust! Not impressive at all. If I wanted a brownie I would have gotten a mix at the store! Also the whip cream is not whipped cream at all.....it's cheap cool whip so for $22 for 3 slices. Won't go back.
Awesome custom coconut cakes!! My friends and I are repeat customers-having taste tested other bakeries in town and been sorely disappointed by comparison, we will always choose Pie Sensations!!