DiCarlo's Pizza - Knoxville

524 S Gay St, Knoxville
(865) 770-8443

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Italian Ice
Pizza Roll
Half Tray
2 Slices
Box

Featured items
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.
BOX
6 slice of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
WATER
Bottled spring water.

PIZZA
BOX
6 slice of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
TAKE N BAKE KIT
Ready-to-bake take home pizza kit.

TOPPINGS
BANANA PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of thick-cut banana peppers.
MIXED PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mixed peppers.
SAUCE CUP - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of DiCarlo's sauce.
MIXED OLIVES - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of black and green olives.
CHILI OIL - 2oz Cup
2oz cup of fried chilis in olive oil.
MUSHROOMS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mushrooms.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
PEPPERONI - 1oz Cup
1oz cup of DiCarlo's pepperoni.

EXTRAS
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
ITALIAN ICE
Made from scratch in small batches.

DRINKS
WATER
Bottled spring water.
COCA-COLA
Old-fashioned glass bottled Coke.
MILO'S TEA
Milo's sweet tea since 1946.
PERONI
Beer brewed in Italy since 1963.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+24 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+23 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

A category of its own. Go here if you’re looking to try something new. At $3/slice it is worth the risk to try something new. The hot crispy crust and fresh toppings are the perfect combination.

Some people don’t understand it, to each their own. It’s existed since 1945 and can’t be compared to a NY style slice if that’s what you’re craving.

The gentleman working was fantastic at balancing customers and all the steps of making...
October 2025
The pizza is good, I would choose regular style pizza over their cold topping style. If you are buying by the slice you’ll probably want to get at least 3-4 slices. I got 2 and was disappointed, I would have ordered more but my 2 slices took a long time to prepare. The staff were not very helpful even though I told them it was my first time to DiCarlos. They were out of crushed red pepper which I thought was a little shocking for a pizza place. Every other restaurant was...
September 2025
Growing up in Wheeling WV, i have been eating DiCarlo's pizza since childhood . Kaz and his wife have done a great job bringing an Ohio Valley favorite to TN that taste just has good as any up north. Thank you!
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Knox Box Karaoke - 522 S Gay St Unit 102
Cocktail Bar, Beer Bar, Karaoke
The Spice & Tea Exchange of Knoxville - 522 S Gay St
Tea
Five Thirty Lounge - 530 S Gay St
Lounges, Cocktail Bar

DiCarlo's Pizza - Knoxville

524 S Gay St, Knoxville, TN 37902
(865) 770-8443