Noni's Pizza Place Plus

Placed an order online, food was ready by the time we got there (10 min). Everything was delicious, and the staff were very friendly. Originally ordered onion on our pizza, and as soon as the order was submitted, they called to say they were so sorry, but they were out of onion. Even offered to give us a refund. Great customer service and quick response time. Highly recommend, we will be back next time in the area.

I have lived here for 12 years. I have watched his place go through three owners and the newest owner of this place. This is the best quality of food that I have had from a pizza place. I no longer order from Pizza Hut well one the food is disgusting, but this is my new found place to order pizza, wings, pasta, breadsticks, cheese sticks, because they have came a long ways and new food is amazing and the prices are Cheap, considering what the food market is the two guys that work there are awesome and friendly. They definitely make it pleasurable to visit this establishment. I made this review originally two weeks ago but today on February 10, 2023. I am updating my review because I can only do one. I just want to say Michael that works inside. Here is awesome great guy do an amazing job for running an establishment by himself with no delivery driver no cook and then to find out that the owner value Sam and appreciate him was another plus about this that I like I highly recommend people trying this place the pizza is amazing. The wings are amazing. I got those for the first time tonight. I don’t think the price is really too high at all when considering you look at Pizza Hut, Papa John’s and Domino’s so Michael thanks for doing a great job and keep it up. I’ll see you next week again sometime for pizza and wings.

Very friendly, great service, quick and the best pizza we have had in a decade

Very good pizza! We had the veggie and a cheese pizza. Both were delicious. The two guys working were very nice! We will be back for sure!

I’ve been waiting a while before I ordered from here just because I knew they were new and needed time to get into the groove and get established. It’s been about a year, maybe, since Noni’s took over the previous owners. My first order was a large supreme and large cheese bread sticks. Order arrived very quick on a “rush hour” order submitted around 6:30. The pizza was exactly as I ordered and to be honest, it tasted like a frozen pizza. I paid around like $46.00 for a Large supreme and large cheese bread sticks. The dough was completely flat and tough with no seasoning and the cheese bread was worse. The pizza sauce that came with the cheese bread was bomb.com but anything beyond that was pretty terrible. Mushrooms were definitely from a can and all the other toppings did not taste fresh at all. I can’t get past that dough- it was awful. Prices are 100% not in line with local competitors and quality is definitely Terrible. It seriously tasted like a frozen pizza….. like a low quality Dijorno that forgot to rise. I could easily call and get my money back but I’m not because I’m hoping this company pockets it, cuts their loses and bounces. I will never order this pizza again. This is an honest review from a local who lives down the road.

Have visited often and very satisfied. Pizza is always ready when they say it will be ready. Great customer service also. Will be a regular customer.

Great service and great employees and didn’t have to wait long best pizza around close for sure!

This is the first writing I've made since the most recent ownership change. I'm glad to report that all is well. This is still a good pizza place, and I still recommend it.

Very yummy large Pepperoni pizza! Carryout and delivery. Sweet owner and delicious food!

I fell in love with Nonis PPP ! It's hard to find a good pizza place. But this place is good food and friendly staff.

We live local and have tried it 3x since it has changed names. It is just not good anymore. I have tried the meatball sub and they were so tough and dry I could not eat it. My kids will eat the cheese pizza but the crust is tough and nothing taste fresh. This last time we tried the boneless wings and they were nuggets with some sauce drizzled on them. The price went way up after the name change and the food just does not match the price. Too many other options close by! Delivery was fast .

Stromboli was not even warm in the middle and the cheese was not melted.Driver forgot some of the order. He then came back leaving it to get rained on with no knock on the door. When we noticed this we called to let them know we were missing some of the order. The driver lied and said he put it on the porch while he was dropping the food the first time.Very disappointed in the whole experience, and we didn't even bring up the Stromboli as it is a Busy Saturday night and stuff happens.

We ordered a large Supreme pizza and a cheese sticks. The dough was old and flat and didn't taste good. We was really hoping for a good pizza but it wasn't! I worked at pizza place plus back from other owners...over 10 yr experience in pizza ..Couldn't eat cheese sticks! Would not recommend. Would add a pic if able.

My great-grandparents had the first pizzeria on Staten Island, NY so we are picky about our pizza. Noni's is, by far, the BEST pizza in the area!!

I have lived here for a long time and it is the best pizza I have tried definitely going back