“We've been living in the Boro for almost a year now, and let me tell you, finding the perfect pizza spot was quite the adventure! Thankfully, this app makes it super easy to customize our own special pizza just the way we like it. Plus, the delivery is prompt, and the food always arrives piping hot. And can we talk about the garlic butter? It's the perfect dip for the crust—so delicious! Yum!“
“THIS Papa Johns on S. Rutherford does it all right and everytime! THIs one has gotten every one of my orders correct and has been too delicious to take a pic even when I’ve been late to pick up. Whoever runs THIS store Desperately Needs to teach the one on Old Fort Pkwy how to work- from ground up. Old fort location should be ashamed. They’re out right thieves and know it but don’t care- with they’re No deliveries and @partial refunds””.” Yall Still owe me money and should shut down! But S Rutherford- yall the best- hands down!!“
“I'm really surprised at the rating this location has. We ordered pizza from hungry howies just down the road and we ordered online. For some reason, the store was closed and it still allowed us to order. When we went there to pick up the food only then did we notice the store was closed. We decided to come to papa John's and the customer service was amazing!! The manager gave me a nice discount for my military service and what I'm going to assume was compassion for the situation we were in as we had to wait even longer to get pizza due to hungry howies being closed. The pizza was definitely delicious and I highly recommend this location. Thanks yall“
“The bad reviews genuinely make me laugh. It's just a bunch of oldies getting mad they can't order with their land-line home phones even though online ordering is so easy, a two year old could do it. I've been going here since I was a kid and even though management has surely changed, I have never had any issues with service or food quality. I want to especially highlight the service because every time I'm in there, people are so rude to them. They have always been kind and helpful to me, and especially in this day and age, good service needs to be recognized. Order online and you'll never have a problem or have to wait for your food ever again. It literally tells you when it will be done, so there's no reason to complain.“
“I ordered from a friend's house and put the address backwards on accident. The driver still got to me and apologized for the time. She went above and beyond in my opinion. Great driver, great food and I will definitely be ordering from this location again!“
“Wow!! I order from Papa John's often. Tonight I had to leave a review. The pizza was fresh and delicious!! The driver was an absolute sweetheart. 5 stars all the way!! Best service I've ever received from any delivery company. Thank you Papa Johns for top notch service!!“