Recommended dishes: Sir Pizza Farmers Almanac, Garlic Bread, Dinner Salad
Noah Williford
From out of town with my girlfriend, came to Nashville for a day trip. We have a Sir Pizza in my hometown and decided to stop by. We were seated immediately in what was a very clean and well aesthetic restaurant. My girlfriend ordered a meatball sub and we were told there was no sub bread, so the waitress gave us the alternative of meatballs and garlic bread without even having to ask for a substitution. Service was prompt, food was very good and the substitute was even cheaper than what we had planned on ordering. Great atmosphere, great food, we tipped well and left very happy, highly recommend.
Marcus Whitney
An old Nashville classic. Let’s keep this spot alive!
Renee Martin
Happy girl—getting ready to indulge in my fave small pepperoni/sausage/green olive pizza that I’ve been eating for 35 years. It’s the perfect portion—thin crust, savory sauce, quality minced ingredients, and cut into small squares with triangles on the corners. which are my favorite pieces. (If I skip 1 piece, it’s always the middle one, but that’s rare.) Yeah, I’ve had all the other best of the best NY, Chicago, Italian pizzas all over the country, but I always come home to Sir Pizza.
When I was little, we always went to Shakey‘s Pizza, until they closed. It was also a warm and cozy parlor with such an amazing aroma as soon as you open the door. This is the only other parlor I know of here in Nashville that gives me that nostalgic feeling of my childhood. On my way to Costco, so this was on the way.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tylor
I want to take a moment to commend Melissa’s daughter at Sir Pizza for her great customer service. She was polite, attentive, and made sure my concerns were addressed without any hassle. It’s clear she cares about doing a good job and making sure customers leave satisfied.
When I had a small issue with my order, she handled it efficiently and professionally. On top of that, she gave me her mac and cheese, and I’ve got to say—10/10. That small gesture really made my day and showed her genuine thoughtfulness.
Experiences like this make a difference, and it’s nice to see someone who takes their role seriously. I’ll definitely be back, and I think her efforts deserve recognition. Great job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
Darrell Frye
I have never written a review but with regards to what my wife had to through after being a loyal customer of this Sir Pizza location for over 25 years it would definitely be disrespectful towards my wife to not do so.On Nov 21 at or about 6 pm my wife to this Sir Pizza and ordered the same pizza she always does.Upon getting home and opening the box she immediately open the box and notice the pizza was not baked correctly.She then notified Sir Pizza and talked to a very disrespectful woman whom we found out later was the owner Melissa's daughter. Tonight my wife went in Sir Pizza to talk to Melissa about last night's incident and had to go through so much back and forth to just have a pizza replacement as well as taking the previous pizza as evidence at which time Melissa agreed the pizza was made incorrectly...I don't know Melissa or her daughter nor anyone else at Sir Pizza but I do know my wife ..With that being said my wife who has been a very loyal customer for many years will never step in that Sir Pizza location again..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Leslie
It is always a treat when I can get to west Nashville and rat at this Sir Pizza. Food is delicious and service awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Garrett
My family has bought food (Dine In ,as well as,Take Home) from Melissa's Sir Pizza, (aka.. Sir Pizza) as long as I can remember ( I am 54yrs. young , so a very long time).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob Huff
Best pizza in town. I am born and raised in Nashville and have been going here my whole life. It is a classic Nashville spot in a town. Our city has very few treasures like this left. The indoor seating area is the best, they have incredibly cheap beer prices, literally $3 and $4, and even less for buckets. Hopefully Brittany is your server, she is wonderful.
Had to come to Nashville from Iowa for a week. After the first couple days I was very let down with the pizza here. But on the 3rd day I tried Mellissa's Sir pizza and was overwhelmed with their pizza. Now I've been all over the states and considere myself to be a pretty good pizza judge. So I will say their pizza is one of the best tasting I have had in quit awhile. Today I had one again before we head home, definitely a place I will stop by, next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Royal Feast Pizza
David Norris
The pizza is very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Andy B
The server was extremely nice The food was really good. No complaints here
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Royal Feast Pizza
Hinge Lord
I’ve been coming here since I was a child and it’s one of my favorite restaurants in the entire world. The server Brittany made my 29th birthday by gifting me a branded bottle opener which to me is very significant. This place is more than just a 10/10 restaurant it’s family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Manuel
Amazing family atmosphere. Brittany is the kindest server you could hope for. It’s quick, fair pricing, and delicious. It’s thin crust pizza, which I adore (you can enjoy the toppings without getting overly stuffed on all the dough). Love it.
Love the pizza and people are great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their food is always great
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sir Pizza Farmers Almanac, Garlic Bread, Dinner Salad
From out of town with my girlfriend, came to Nashville for a day trip. We have a Sir Pizza in my hometown and decided to stop by. We were seated immediately in what was a very clean and well aesthetic restaurant. My girlfriend ordered a meatball sub and we were told there was no sub bread, so the waitress gave us the alternative of meatballs and garlic bread without even having to ask for a substitution. Service was prompt, food was very good and the substitute was even cheaper than what we had planned on ordering. Great atmosphere, great food, we tipped well and left very happy, highly recommend.
An old Nashville classic. Let’s keep this spot alive!
Happy girl—getting ready to indulge in my fave small pepperoni/sausage/green olive pizza that I’ve been eating for 35 years. It’s the perfect portion—thin crust, savory sauce, quality minced ingredients, and cut into small squares with triangles on the corners. which are my favorite pieces. (If I skip 1 piece, it’s always the middle one, but that’s rare.) Yeah, I’ve had all the other best of the best NY, Chicago, Italian pizzas all over the country, but I always come home to Sir Pizza.
When I was little, we always went to Shakey‘s Pizza, until they closed. It was also a warm and cozy parlor with such an amazing aroma as soon as you open the door. This is the only other parlor I know of here in Nashville that gives me that nostalgic feeling of my childhood. On my way to Costco, so this was on the way.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I want to take a moment to commend Melissa’s daughter at Sir Pizza for her great customer service. She was polite, attentive, and made sure my concerns were addressed without any hassle. It’s clear she cares about doing a good job and making sure customers leave satisfied.
When I had a small issue with my order, she handled it efficiently and professionally. On top of that, she gave me her mac and cheese, and I’ve got to say—10/10. That small gesture really made my day and showed her genuine thoughtfulness.
Experiences like this make a difference, and it’s nice to see someone who takes their role seriously. I’ll definitely be back, and I think her efforts deserve recognition. Great job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
I have never written a review but with regards to what my wife had to through after being a loyal customer of this Sir Pizza location for over 25 years it would definitely be disrespectful towards my wife to not do so.On Nov 21 at or about 6 pm my wife to this Sir Pizza and ordered the same pizza she always does.Upon getting home and opening the box she immediately open the box and notice the pizza was not baked correctly.She then notified Sir Pizza and talked to a very disrespectful woman whom we found out later was the owner Melissa's daughter. Tonight my wife went in Sir Pizza to talk to Melissa about last night's incident and had to go through so much back and forth to just have a pizza replacement as well as taking the previous pizza as evidence at which time Melissa agreed the pizza was made incorrectly...I don't know Melissa or her daughter nor anyone else at Sir Pizza but I do know my wife ..With that being said my wife who has been a very loyal customer for many years will never step in that Sir Pizza location again..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It is always a treat when I can get to west Nashville and rat at this Sir Pizza. Food is delicious and service awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family has bought food (Dine In ,as well as,Take Home) from Melissa's Sir Pizza, (aka.. Sir Pizza) as long as I can remember ( I am 54yrs. young , so a very long time).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in town. I am born and raised in Nashville and have been going here my whole life. It is a classic Nashville spot in a town. Our city has very few treasures like this left. The indoor seating area is the best, they have incredibly cheap beer prices, literally $3 and $4, and even less for buckets. Hopefully Brittany is your server, she is wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Had to come to Nashville from Iowa for a week. After the first couple days I was very let down with the pizza here. But on the 3rd day I tried Mellissa's Sir pizza and was overwhelmed with their pizza. Now I've been all over the states and considere myself to be a pretty good pizza judge. So I will say their pizza is one of the best tasting I have had in quit awhile. Today I had one again before we head home, definitely a place I will stop by, next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Royal Feast Pizza
The pizza is very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
The server was extremely nice
The food was really good.
No complaints here
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Royal Feast Pizza
I’ve been coming here since I was a child and it’s one of my favorite restaurants in the entire world. The server Brittany made my 29th birthday by gifting me a branded bottle opener which to me is very significant. This place is more than just a 10/10 restaurant it’s family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing family atmosphere. Brittany is the kindest server you could hope for.
It’s quick, fair pricing, and delicious.
It’s thin crust pizza, which I adore (you can enjoy the toppings without getting overly stuffed on all the dough).
Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...