New York Pizza

2204 Elliston Pl, Nashville
(615) 327-3663

Recent Reviews

oday maloul

This place needs to

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tess Wolf

15/10 absolutely delicious pizza by the slice. Can’t recommend enough!!!

Heywood M.

Yep. Hung at Corner Bar at Elliston. Went next door for a slice. Same STUNNINGLY POOR service and attitude. Avoid this fucking place. Worthless. They so do NOT give a shit about the customers.

clay savage

I know microwaved pizza when I’ve had one. But that wasn’t the worse part. Zero customers but 3 employees sitting around on their phones. I had to get the cashiers attention . I order a cheese slice. Take 5 minutes for some reason . I use the restroom which was filthy. Smelled of Urine. I’ve used cleaner bathrooms IN nyc. Surely there Is better pizza in Nashville I was just in town for a show.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kenneth R.

Not even good as drunk food. Was super excited seeing the sign, only to get served pieces of cardboard with melted government cheese on top. Worst drunk food I've had in a while, save yourself some money and just go to McDonalds down the road.

Patrick

such a bad pizza. actually tasted like a bland cracker with cheese on it. stay far away from this dump and go to michelangelo’s right around the

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Angel Nicolodi

Pizza looks good but it’s the wrong pizza they don’t have hand tossed and just gave me what they have. For 14 it should have some flavoring I had to put salt on it to taste something!!! Step up your game and the pizza crust is too

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jorge de Cardenas

Worse pizza I have ever had. Definitely not NY style pizza. I suspect my pizza was not freshly made.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Theresa C.

The food was absolutely disgusting!! I swear it was worse then a frozen TV dinner. Nothing New York about it!!! And OVERPRICED!!!!! There were cock roaches on the floor. They did not have ice and was charged 3$ for a 20 oz. HOT soda. I spent 50$ and ate nothing! The bathrooms were despicable!!! I don't know how they passed a health inspection. The spinach dip tasted like microwaved cream cheese! The spaghetti wasn't even spaghetti.. it was fettuccine noodles served in a hefty plastic container with paper plates and plastic silverware! Super sketchy environment! Owners were sitting outside smoking hookah and on their phones... no regard for the business or paying customers. When I told them how I felt about their business and food the only thing I was offered was a "sorry".. I would not be shocked if this store was just a front for a drug business or sex trafficking ring.. the city should really look into this hell hole!

Ami Ami

The marinara was cold and tasted of tomato paste. The cheese was poor quality on my calzone, and the crust was bready. And who puts marinara inside a calzone? Would not eat here again, I don't recommend. That calzone went in the trash.Vegetarian options: Cheese Calzone

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Boricua Fishing

A little extra sauce could boost it up but is good pizza nice crust. the owner or the manager was very kind I would comeback next time I am in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Nashville Tennessee

Don’t get me wrong…it’s good pizza! But they put some kind of middle eastern spice in their sauce that changes it from being authentic NY Style Italian Pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Diana Llerondez

Pizza wasn't N.Y style pizza at all,no A/C and no ice at all. No customer service at

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

M K

Truely terrible pizza. Not at all NY style. They managed to mess up every componet of the pizza. NY thin crust was way too thin. Crust was burnt at the edges and soggy in the middle. Margarita was like 75% crust with sauce and 25% mozzarella. The sauce was super sweet for some reason (gross). The mozzarella was cooked too much and hard and chewy. Just overall a sad example of pizza.Save your time and money and go somewhere else. Jets and Two Boots are right down the street!

Food: 1

Service: 2

Brian Lambrecht

The roaches on the floor under the tables along the walls (during my second and last visit) were enough to get this place banned off of my list for good. Everyone who works here looks miserable, the atmosphere is depressing, and the pizza isn't that great anyway. They charge $2.50 per ingredient on the pizza; one of the ingredients I got was spinach - they literally put ONE spinach leaf on each slice after they cut it, like it was basil or something. Ridiculous.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More