Amico's New York Pizza

My husband, best friend, her husband and niece went in for dinner last night. First time my husband and I have been, the food was ok, nothing fabulous (Sorelles in Eagleville is better!! Hands down!!) but it was ok. The bad part was when we got our bill and noticed that a 20% gratuity had already been added to our bill and then we were given the handheld machine to finish our payment and it was asking for another tip?!?!?!?!? What? Keep in mind, even though there were 5 of us at this table, we had 2 separate checks and 20% was also added to my friends bill as well. We have eaten at a number of places and have NEVER experienced a place that adds a 20% tip to your bill without asking for such a small number of people. Last time I checked the normal number for pre-added tip was 8 or more, nowhere near 2-5 people!! Our oldest daughter works at Del Frisco in Brentwood and she doesn't have that right unless it's a party of 8 or more. Even if the food had been awesome, (which it was NOT) this is enough for us to never return again. Very bad business. Don't take that privilege away from your customers. That's so rude.

My favorite spot! I had no idea the vodka sauce had prosciutto in it (I am a vegetarian), and they instantly remade my pasta to be meat free. So kind & very friendly service!

Great NY style pizza! The meat cravers came with a variety and ratio of meat. Cheese was very stringy. Garlic rolls were good, I would rave specifically about them. Pizza came out in good time. It actually beat our rolls! 😂 Service was prompt and delightful.

Decent pizza but there's a lot better new York style pizza in Nashville. The penne ala vodka is really good. Service is quick but not always friendly

3% fee for a credit card on a carry out.
Asks for a tip for routine tasks like you get at a store or McDonald's at a counter.

Great place for good family Italian. Good pizza, pasta, subs, and chicken. You can go on a date or have a big family dinner. There are a handful of tables outside.

Their deep dish pizza was amazing, I got a meat lover with pineapple and mixed white and red sauce as a base best pizza I've ever had.

God bless the girl at the front counters heart! My mom ordered my pizza & two salads for her & my dad at 5:00 for take out. Now this was on a Friday, but we were notified that it would be ready by 6:30. When my mom arrived around 6:37 they hadn’t even put my pizza in the oven! The cashier was very sweet, but at this point it was almost 7. My mom wanted to cancel the order & the manager was nice about it but the owner? The owner had the audacity to yell at my mom for ‘not wanting to wait five more minutes’. Then the owner made a ‘big announcement’ if a customer is to order on a Friday they need order at 4 o’clock. 4:00 pm? The average person isn’t even off of work yet! Delicious food but an owner who needs anger management has lost my family’s service for good.

We got the pizza ask for a little more done and it was good but it wasn’t Crispy enough and the fried cheese was ok wouldn’t get them again and the cheese toast was good I would get that again we would probably be back

Very tasty. Will definitely go back. Stromboli was large enough we were able to share and was still full.

Good food, good serviced. Small place, but it stays packed. They owners are great people. If you want good New York style pizza, this is place.

We called in for a takeout, was told it would be an hour. When I got the to pick it up I was about 10 minutes early. The place was packed the food smell was amazing. Checked in and paid told they were running a little behind. Got the
Pie in about 15 minutes brought it home, we were extremely pleased how good it was. Growing up in the northeast we are accustom to excellent pizza. This was one as well ! Definitely will be going back to try some on the dishes.

One of our favorite local places. A hidden gem in Nolensville. The feel is homey, warm, and small town.

Best pizza within 3 hours of a drive.

Great neighborhood pizza parlor. The food is real New York style pizza. Loved the sauce. Our server was very good.