Amico's New York Pizza

Best food in the city

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quick seating with service. Ordered a couple of appetizers…calamari and meatballs with pizza to go. Relaxed and enjoyed time there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Complimentary Garlic Bread, House Special

What a great meal! We drove from Franklin to eat at Churchill's and it was closed. Decided to go across the street to Amico's and I am glad we did. The entire family LOVED it. Not a bad entry on the table. Thanks for the great service too!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

I placed a DoorDash order for a chicken tender basket, but there was no option for their buffalo sauce on DoorDash. So I placed the order and then called asking if I could have a side of buffalo sauce and was told that they can’t change the order. When I asked if they could add a side of buffalo sauce the girl was very rude and said no , and that if I wanted buffalo sauce, I could cancel the order and then place a pick up order to come get it. Instead of simply placing a small cup of buffalo sauce with the order. Not to mention if I had canceled the order, it wouldn’t refund me because they had already started preparing it. Mind you, I called immediately after placing the order. I would completely understand if I was asking to Completely change the order. But all I asked for was a side sauce.

Food: 5

Service: 2

We had several dishes including the pizza, manicotti with marinara sauce, and the cannolli's. Everything was very good! We will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

As a regular, I highly recommend. The pizza is spectacular! Every dish I have ordered has exceeded my expectations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always good.

Should have listened to the many reviews about owner's nasty attitude. Food should be to a higher standard if you are lacking that much professionalism.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The attitude of the owner belongs in new york, tennessee folks dont have time for this. The food is NOT worth the attitude. Take your northern trash back up to ny.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Some of the best pizza in Nashville

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

We love the garlic knots! Best New York style pizza in Nashville!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband, best friend, her husband and niece went in for dinner last night. First time my husband and I have been, the food was ok, nothing fabulous (Sorelles in Eagleville is better!! Hands down!!) but it was ok. The bad part was when we got our bill and noticed that a 20% gratuity had already been added to our bill and then we were given the handheld machine to finish our payment and it was asking for another tip?!?!?!?!? What? Keep in mind, even though there were 5 of us at this table, we had 2 separate checks and 20% was also added to my friends bill as well. We have eaten at a number of places and have NEVER experienced a place that adds a 20% tip to your bill without asking for such a small number of people. Last time I checked the normal number for pre-added tip was 8 or more, nowhere near 2-5 people!! Our oldest daughter works at Del Frisco in Brentwood and she doesn't have that right unless it's a party of 8 or more. Even if the food had been awesome, (which it was NOT) this is enough for us to never return again. Very bad business. Don't take that privilege away from your customers. That's so rude.

My favorite spot! I had no idea the vodka sauce had prosciutto in it (I am a vegetarian), and they instantly remade my pasta to be meat free. So kind & very friendly service!

Great NY style pizza! The meat cravers came with a variety and ratio of meat. Cheese was very stringy. Garlic rolls were good, I would rave specifically about them. Pizza came out in good time. It actually beat our rolls! 😂 Service was prompt and delightful.

Decent pizza but there's a lot better new York style pizza in Nashville. The penne ala vodka is really good. Service is quick but not always friendly