Old Mill Creamery

Turkey was here.
Got a 16 oz coffee.

My husband and I went here and got pumpkin cheesecake, coconut, and banana pudding flavors of ice cream and they were all delicious! We did a sample of the oatmeal cream pie, but just didn't think it had much flavor. I would recommend tasting some samples before ordering to see which you like/don't.

Cute little ice cream shop- highly recommend the Whiskey Ribbon flavor ice cream. Loved the waffle bowl option!

Great ice cream!!

Good service. Nice place to visit after walking around the surrounding shops. The ice cream is creamy and very tasty. The attitude in the shop is very friendly/down home.

I got the waffle bowl which comes with two generous scoops of ice cream. I loved the brown butter black walnut and the espresso with the chocolate chips was really good. I also got an extra scoop of banana pudding for an extra dollar. I liked it. The quality of their ice cream gets a 5 star in my opinion. The selection is good and I'd come back for the brown butter black walnut for sure but I give their selection a 4 star because they don't have any sorbets and they didn't have any sherbets, even though they usually have orange sherbet I guess.

They have a really nice patio to eat on with lots of tables. However if it's raining (like it was when we went) there is not indoor seating and there are only 3 benches that are under the awnings.

We would definitely go back

great selection, great ice cream friendly staff, will be back!

Seriously some of the best ice cream I've ever had. I want expecting it to be this great.

Ice cream was great I had the Reese cup and it was the best I’ve had since I’ve been down here, nice seating area with things for the kids to do out front, prices were very affordable honestly probably a little too cheap, sad part is they weren’t even busy I’ll definitely be back for more before we leave!!! Only negative was(constructive criticism) girls behind the counter were a little awkward two out of the three of them just didn’t seem like they wanted to be there/do anything the one girl was doing everything but I know how hard it is finding good help!

The staff is wonderful. This place would get five stars, but there is no real cream for coffee ... in a creamery! We don't do chemical fake creamers. Had to take the coffee to my truck and get my own milk out of the cooler.

Really good ice cream. Price is comparable

Great little shop. Strawberry flavor was awesome

Fun selection of ice cream flavors. I got the banana pudding and my husband ordered blue berry muffin.

Great service and very yummy ice cream!

The ice cream is very very good a must try.