The service is great and a lot of selection for this ice cream shop. Recommended, ice cream hand dipped cone!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flavor
So Disappointed G.
Han da down the best ice cream we've had in town. The oat mill creampie is so creamy and delicious. Tastes very oaty. The chocolate is also very good. A must stop when passing thru.
Melissa Rouse
We come to the Old Mill Creamery every time we visit the area! The Banana Pudding ice cream and Oatmeal Creme Pie Ice Cream are both AMAZING!!! This time we even purchased pints to take back to the cabin and enjoy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Cream Pie
Louis and Elaine
The Old Mill Creamery is a well stocked ice cream shop with a super friendly staff. The stock a large variety of ice cream flavors as well as muffins and other delicious treats. There is also a very nice outdoor seating area with tables and chairs for the use of their customers.Vegetarian options: Very few meat itemsDietary restrictions: Be aware of restrictions before ordering.Parking: Large lot across streetKid-friendliness: Very kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Fully accessible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flavor
Tracy Forde
Typical ice cream shop but again the employees looked bored or really angry we were there. The specialty is oatmeal creme pies but we didn't feel welcome enough to order it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Cassandra N.
My mom specifically asked me to take her there so that she could get coconut ice cream and when we get there they have decided to not make that flavor right now so she was incredibly disappointed and got what they said would be the closest thing to it and she said it was just OK. Keep in mind that I've been hearing about about this coconut ice cream now for a year ... My biggest complaint with them is that they do not have any vegan ice cream. One in three people are lactose intolerant so it boggles my mind at this point in time why every ice cream place doesn't have vegan ice cream and candidly nobody should be eating dairy in its current state, it's not healthy. I will say their employees were very friendly and very helpful as best they could be. The store was clean and welcoming. We were just very disappointed that the coconut wasn't available and they didn't have vegan.
Anne Marie Zielinski Baese
Went in for a scoop of ice cream for my daughter. Asked for a sample and girl behind counter was so unfriendly. She never spoke until I paid for the ice cream, when she told me the total. My daughter and husband thought the ice cream was delicious. The big problem came in when I went back in to buy bottles of water. A different girl was working the counter. When I went to pay, I saw the rude girl sitting in the back, eating a bag of funyuns, licking her fingers, and looking at her phone. The girl who waited on us asked the rude girl to help other customers. The rude girl proceeded to come out from the back and start waiting on people, giving out samples and scooping ice cream, without ever washing her hands. She was just LICKING HER OWN FINGERS! She was using the scoop, handing people ice cream samples, and touching cones and other food and giving it to patrons. I went outside, told my husband, and we threw away the rest of the ice cream. We were both so incredibly disgusted. That rude girl needs to be re-educated on basic hygiene and how germs are spread. Or she should just be outright fired because of the combination of her disgusting and disease-spread practices and her terrible customer service skills!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Javier Fernandez
Some of the best ice cream I've had.
Dan Wirth
Very good. Was extremely relieved to find out the "Whiskey Ribbon" wasn't alcoholic. The only person "getting wasted" was my diabetic friend, Carl (God rest his soul). 10/10 would go again, it's what Carl would have wanted.
The wait was short. The ice cream was awsome. They sell other sweets also.
Brittany K.
Such yummy ice cream, and lots of outdoor seating available! My husband and I really enjoyed our treats, and the staff was really friendly. Highly recommend!
Aimz4
We had ice cream in a cup here. It was good. Nice lil treat while strolling the area. The place is clean and people were nice.
Liz B.
We stopped in at Old Mill Creamery during our first visit to PF. The shop is located in a cute area surrounded by other shops, sitting area outside and lawn games. There is a large selection of flavors and the ice cream is so delicious. They were so helpful and allowed us to sample so that we could decide between flavors...there were so many good choices!!! I sampled the coconut and the peanut butter. Such a hard decision but peanut butter won and it did not disappoint!! My husband got two scoops - coffee and butter pecan. Can't wait to visit next time we are in the area. I'm definitely having the coconut!!!
Jeanne D.
Wonderful location, good service and terrific ice cream place - what more could you ask from a place on a lovely sunny afternoon. Hubby got a one scoop of black cherry, and I received a 2-scoop cup of coffee topped with coconut ice creams. I was in heaven with the coconut pieces in the ice cream that I intentionally lingered over it. The coffee flavor was also very good and I enjoyed it very much. This is a must stop for everyone!!
The service is great and a lot of selection for this ice cream shop. Recommended, ice cream hand dipped cone!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flavor
Han da down the best ice cream we've had in town. The oat mill creampie is so creamy and delicious. Tastes very oaty. The chocolate is also very good. A must stop when passing thru.
We come to the Old Mill Creamery every time we visit the area! The Banana Pudding ice cream and Oatmeal Creme Pie Ice Cream are both AMAZING!!! This time we even purchased pints to take back to the cabin and enjoy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Cream Pie
The Old Mill Creamery is a well stocked ice cream shop with a super friendly staff. The stock a large variety of ice cream flavors as well as muffins and other delicious treats. There is also a very nice outdoor seating area with tables and chairs for the use of their customers.Vegetarian options: Very few meat itemsDietary restrictions: Be aware of restrictions before ordering.Parking: Large lot across streetKid-friendliness: Very kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Fully accessible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Flavor
Typical ice cream shop but again the employees looked bored or really angry we were there. The specialty is oatmeal creme pies but we didn't feel welcome enough to order it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
My mom specifically asked me to take her there so that she could get coconut ice cream and when we get there they have decided to not make that flavor right now so she was incredibly disappointed and got what they said would be the closest thing to it and she said it was just OK. Keep in mind that I've been hearing about about this coconut ice cream now for a year ... My biggest complaint with them is that they do not have any vegan ice cream. One in three people are lactose intolerant so it boggles my mind at this point in time why every ice cream place doesn't have vegan ice cream and candidly nobody should be eating dairy in its current state, it's not healthy. I will say their employees were very friendly and very helpful as best they could be. The store was clean and welcoming. We were just very disappointed that the coconut wasn't available and they didn't have vegan.
Went in for a scoop of ice cream for my daughter. Asked for a sample and girl behind counter was so unfriendly. She never spoke until I paid for the ice cream, when she told me the total. My daughter and husband thought the ice cream was delicious. The big problem came in when I went back in to buy bottles of water. A different girl was working the counter. When I went to pay, I saw the rude girl sitting in the back, eating a bag of funyuns, licking her fingers, and looking at her phone. The girl who waited on us asked the rude girl to help other customers. The rude girl proceeded to come out from the back and start waiting on people, giving out samples and scooping ice cream, without ever washing her hands. She was just LICKING HER OWN FINGERS! She was using the scoop, handing people ice cream samples, and touching cones and other food and giving it to patrons. I went outside, told my husband, and we threw away the rest of the ice cream. We were both so incredibly disgusted. That rude girl needs to be re-educated on basic hygiene and how germs are spread. Or she should just be outright fired because of the combination of her disgusting and disease-spread practices and her terrible customer service skills!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Some of the best ice cream I've had.
Very good. Was extremely relieved to find out the "Whiskey Ribbon" wasn't alcoholic. The only person "getting wasted" was my diabetic friend, Carl (God rest his soul). 10/10 would go again, it's what Carl would have wanted.
Chocolate and Almond Joy. Nice.
Restaurantji Recommends
The wait was short. The ice cream was awsome. They sell other sweets also.
Such yummy ice cream, and lots of outdoor seating available! My husband and I really enjoyed our treats, and the staff was really friendly. Highly recommend!
We had ice cream in a cup here. It was good. Nice lil treat while strolling the area. The place is clean and people were nice.
We stopped in at Old Mill Creamery during our first visit to PF. The shop is located in a cute area surrounded by other shops, sitting area outside and lawn games. There is a large selection of flavors and the ice cream is so delicious. They were so helpful and allowed us to sample so that we could decide between flavors...there were so many good choices!!! I sampled the coconut and the peanut butter. Such a hard decision but peanut butter won and it did not disappoint!! My husband got two scoops - coffee and butter pecan. Can't wait to visit next time we are in the area. I'm definitely having the coconut!!!
Wonderful location, good service and terrific ice cream place - what more could you ask from a place on a lovely sunny afternoon. Hubby got a one scoop of black cherry, and I received a 2-scoop cup of coffee topped with coconut ice creams. I was in heaven with the coconut pieces in the ice cream that I intentionally lingered over it. The coffee flavor was also very good and I enjoyed it very much. This is a must stop for everyone!!