Came to Amarillo from Rogersville TN to watch my sister in law graduate with her masters and she got a reservation for 9 to Macaroni Joe’s… it was amazing! The bread was spot on and we ordered the kids Mac and cheese as an appetizer! So yummy. I had the lasagna and it was terrific! I live 18 hours away but if I ever come back this way I am making this a priority to stop again!! Thank you for making a special day even more special with great food!
Mikayla Banks
The food is always amazing and the service is top tier! My husband took me out for my 30th birthday and we had the best experience! Josh took such good care of us and was big part of the positive experience! Get the fried green tomatoes and thank me later!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam Rogers
Good food. They were out of coffee.
Deborah
We ate at a table in the bar Our waitress/bartender Kyla was great. Everyone enjoyed their drinks and entrees!
Amber Hernandez
Went there two times in the last month and honestly will never be back. The first time was mid October we had a large party. Some of our party ordered the 5 oz filet and what came out was like 2 oz filets and they were all over cooked and wrong. The drinks from the bar were terrible. I asked for an espresso martini with a little bit of cream and it came out like ice cream it had so much cream and zero foam on top. The asked for a dirty martini slightly dirty it was the dirtiest one I had gotten in my life. Fast forward to two weeks later we decided to give it another try, same exact thing not one persons steak at the table was cooked right the pastas had no flavor and the bar drinks were terrible. For a place where our bill for 4 people was 250$ + this is absolutely inexcusable. Will not be back here again.
amber doden
Went there two times in the last month and honestly will never be back. The first time was mid October we had a large party. Some of our party ordered the 5 oz filet and what came out was like 2 oz filets and they were all over cooked and wrong. The drinks from the bar were terrible. I asked for an espresso martini with a little bit of cream and it came out like ice cream it had so much cream and zero foam on top. The asked for a dirty martini slightly dirty it was the dirtiest one I had gotten in my life. Fast forward to two weeks later we decided to give it another try, same exact thing not one persons steak at the table was cooked right the pastas had no flavor and the bar drinks were terrible. For a place where our bill for 4 people was 250$ + this is absolutely inexcusable. Will not be back here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Chris
Great experience. My family and I went for my birthday and had a wonderful time as always.
John V
Fantastic first experience of this honey hole. Excellent wide ranging menu light on the Italian influence expected. We can personally vouch for the Lasagna and the Chicken Picatta(not Pacatta). Both were some of the best to be had. I heard lots of praise for the fried green Tomatoes. I will say they looked better than any I've ever seen elsewhere. The servers at the bar were entertaining and very active. They were also a great help in making our choices for dinner. Nice atmosphere that apparently has been in existence for the thirty to forty years I recommend and will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stormy
This is our go-to for special occasions or date nights. Atmosphere feels like eating in a piazza in Italy. High class dining experience with amazing service! The bread is amazing, we order bayou sauce for dipping. The chicken spaghetti is my typical order. The steak is also great as well as the green chile chicken farfalle. Tiramisu is great dessert!
Adding to my previous review; we’re here again and the chicken was amazing, I love the chicken spaghetti and green chilie chicken. The chefs here are very talented! Our server Diana was friendly and attentive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu
Taryn Scott
We ordered a Togo order. 3 meals in one bag and 2 in the other. Checked our bag. Missing one meal and an app. Went back inside got the issue fixed only to make it home and have the complete wrong entree in one bag. Beyond irritating since overall 3 items were wrong for the price of the food. The food tasted incredible, but service will hinder our future visits.
Wonderful restaurant. Food was absolutely delicious and service was excellent. Absolutely beautiful decor. Highly recommend.
Stacey
First time I've ever had a less than satisfactory experience at Macaroni's Joes. I ordered a filet. The meal was served promptly, however my steak was overcooked, and the two sides (potatoes and broccolini) were lukewarm at best. Someone came by to check on how the meal came out (may have been a manager?), and I said the sides were not warm. She offered to get new servings, but I declined, not wanting my steak to then get cold. She did not offer anything else. When my server brought my ticket, I also reported to him that my steak was overdone and the sides were not hot and he apologized and thanked me for bringing it to his attention, but again, that is all that was done. I think an adjustment to my bill should have been offered. I don't like paying over $50 for a meal that I can't even enjoy.
Macy Barker
The best chicken spaghetti!
Bobby
The perfect date night. The food was more than amazing. The wine selection is definitely worth it.  Definitely coming back to enjoy more dates there. 
Richard Kanderas
Exceptional! Wonderful for a romantic date. Surprisingly vibrant flavors, and a good robust house red. Never disappointed.
Came to Amarillo from Rogersville TN to watch my sister in law graduate with her masters and she got a reservation for 9 to Macaroni Joe’s… it was amazing! The bread was spot on and we ordered the kids Mac and cheese as an appetizer! So yummy. I had the lasagna and it was terrific! I live 18 hours away but if I ever come back this way I am making this a priority to stop again!! Thank you for making a special day even more special with great food!
The food is always amazing and the service is top tier! My husband took me out for my 30th birthday and we had the best experience! Josh took such good care of us and was big part of the positive experience! Get the fried green tomatoes and thank me later!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food. They were out of coffee.
We ate at a table in the bar Our waitress/bartender Kyla was great. Everyone enjoyed their drinks and entrees!
Went there two times in the last month and honestly will never be back. The first time was mid October we had a large party. Some of our party ordered the 5 oz filet and what came out was like 2 oz filets and they were all over cooked and wrong. The drinks from the bar were terrible. I asked for an espresso martini with a little bit of cream and it came out like ice cream it had so much cream and zero foam on top. The asked for a dirty martini slightly dirty it was the dirtiest one I had gotten in my life. Fast forward to two weeks later we decided to give it another try, same exact thing not one persons steak at the table was cooked right the pastas had no flavor and the bar drinks were terrible. For a place where our bill for 4 people was 250$ + this is absolutely inexcusable. Will not be back here again.
Went there two times in the last month and honestly will never be back. The first time was mid October we had a large party. Some of our party ordered the 5 oz filet and what came out was like 2 oz filets and they were all over cooked and wrong. The drinks from the bar were terrible. I asked for an espresso martini with a little bit of cream and it came out like ice cream it had so much cream and zero foam on top. The asked for a dirty martini slightly dirty it was the dirtiest one I had gotten in my life. Fast forward to two weeks later we decided to give it another try, same exact thing not one persons steak at the table was cooked right the pastas had no flavor and the bar drinks were terrible. For a place where our bill for 4 people was 250$ + this is absolutely inexcusable. Will not be back here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great experience. My family and I went for my birthday and had a wonderful time as always.
Fantastic first experience of this honey hole. Excellent wide ranging menu light on the Italian influence expected. We can personally vouch for the Lasagna and the Chicken Picatta(not Pacatta). Both were some of the best to be had. I heard lots of praise for the fried green Tomatoes. I will say they looked better than any I've ever seen elsewhere. The servers at the bar were entertaining and very active. They were also a great help in making our choices for dinner. Nice atmosphere that apparently has been in existence for the thirty to forty years I recommend and will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is our go-to for special occasions or date nights. Atmosphere feels like eating in a piazza in Italy. High class dining experience with amazing service! The bread is amazing, we order bayou sauce for dipping. The chicken spaghetti is my typical order. The steak is also great as well as the green chile chicken farfalle. Tiramisu is great dessert!
Adding to my previous review; we’re here again and the chicken was amazing, I love the chicken spaghetti and green chilie chicken. The chefs here are very talented! Our server Diana was friendly and attentive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu
We ordered a Togo order. 3 meals in one bag and 2 in the other. Checked our bag. Missing one meal and an app. Went back inside got the issue fixed only to make it home and have the complete wrong entree in one bag. Beyond irritating since overall 3 items were wrong for the price of the food. The food tasted incredible, but service will hinder our future visits.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Wonderful restaurant. Food was absolutely delicious and service was excellent. Absolutely beautiful decor. Highly recommend.
First time I've ever had a less than satisfactory experience at Macaroni's Joes. I ordered a filet. The meal was served promptly, however my steak was overcooked, and the two sides (potatoes and broccolini) were lukewarm at best. Someone came by to check on how the meal came out (may have been a manager?), and I said the sides were not warm. She offered to get new servings, but I declined, not wanting my steak to then get cold. She did not offer anything else. When my server brought my ticket, I also reported to him that my steak was overdone and the sides were not hot and he apologized and thanked me for bringing it to his attention, but again, that is all that was done. I think an adjustment to my bill should have been offered. I don't like paying over $50 for a meal that I can't even enjoy.
The best chicken spaghetti!
The perfect date night. The food was more than amazing. The wine selection is definitely worth it.  Definitely coming back to enjoy more dates there. 
Exceptional!
Wonderful for a romantic date.
Surprisingly vibrant flavors, and a good robust house red.
Never disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...