The food was fantastic, the manager went above and beyond to make sure everything came out excellent, all was very fresh and perfect temp on wings , pizza and fresh cold salad!! I will always come back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Giant Slice
Kristy Lowe
Good pizza! A large is way bigger than any other large I’ve ever seen period!
Food: 4
Service: 5
amvzo FINEART
Amazing Pizza! Come here weekly and they never disappoint. Go all out or keep it simple, it’s always delicious!!! Hand spun dough, that is crispy but airy. Their sauce is amazing, and their cheese pulls to die for! Great place for lunch with wife and 3 kids. They even put on some cartoons for my kids. Recommend this place for anyone who loves authentic New York Pizza!Kid-friendliness: Tv with kid friendly showsWheelchair accessibility: Wheel char ramp to sidewalk and easy entry to shop
One of my favorite spots! Dog friendly and great lunch specials. I can get my giant slice of pizza and a fresh salad. Brewskees next door with outside seating, so my pup can run around. They always have a special going on at Woodrows. Fav munchies are the fried Raviolis and the buttered Garlic Knots. And something about that homemade ranch just hits differently ? Yall are the best! ?Vegetarian options: Build your own, salad, and apps
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Greek Salad, Giant Slice, Extra Marinara, Side of 2oz, Garlic Knots
Akash Shah
Absolute worst pizza I have ever had. Horribly
Food: 1
jelissa cruz
The Round Rock location is 5 stars. This one.. it’s mid. You ask for extra sauce and they give you the driest pizza you could ask for. Felt like I was eating a grilled cheese last time. ?
Food: 1
Alex Fisher
I like the pizza and it was definitely a New York pizza and good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Moiz Arif
All the pizzas were really chewy and hard to eat. The taste was mostly bland and lacked flavor. The crust looked more like plastic except for the margarita pizza which was relatively soft to eat. There is a need to improve the way pizzas are delivered so that they remain hot and worthy to be eaten.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jonathan P.
One word: disappointment. Took an hour for the pizza to be done. Disappointed. Charged me for RANCH? Disappointed. Pizza was not impressive. Would not recommend
Our pager died while we were watering so that was a bummer but incredibly helpful and nice staff. Got the fried ravioli and churro cheesecake. Fried ravioli was AMAZING. Six pieces with marinara, so delicious! Churro cheesecake was also amazing. Good size and delicious.
Jessica G.
Honestly, pretty good! The pizza slice is insanely big and a great value! I always order my pizzas well done and highly recommend other doing so. This is a no fuss, great pizza place!
Maxwell Tarpley-Young
Hard to understand some of the bad reviews, we moved to Austin 6 months ago and truly have not found a go to pizza shop . First time ordering last night during football , got a black olive and mushroom and asked for it well done . There’s good and there’s not good in pizza … this was so good , cooked proper crispy , zero flop , traditional pizza . It was high 8s on the Barstool scale .Also got fried ravioli , arrived hot , crispy not greasy with a good rigotta and cheese filling . Way good too.
Food: 5
Carmen Kim
Brooklyn Pie is conveniently located close to us. The pizza is tasty, not greasy and customizable. The price is reasonable.We ordered 1 large and 1 medium pizza on a Friday night. Our order was around 5. We understand it’s dinner time on a Friday and don’t expect things to be slow. However, we were given a timeline of 20-25 minutes when we ordered online. I arrived for pick up during that time and was asked to wait 10 minutes (no biggie!).. I watched people wait and come and go. Our order took over an hour. From my own experience in the food industry, I understand delays can happen. What’s upsetting was that I had to check on our order 2-3 times as it kept getting forgotten. I was displeased with the lack of customer service and communication. At the end of the day, it’s just pizza and if it’s a longer wait I just want to know so I can plan accordingly since my 2 kids aren’t as patient. I would suggest in the future to give the customer the courtesy of the choice to wait or move on. Instead, I was told they got a lot of Uber orders.. which again would have been nice to know prior to my extended wait time. I’d like to also suggest communication from the staff since no one wants to feel forgotten or wants to have to be the one nagging the serving staff for an update. Offer water or an easy to grab appetizer while your guests wait.. just some ideas.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
bennett p.
Look, Texans don't like good pizza. That's why every NY style pizza you'll get in this city is woefully undercooked. Brooklyn Pie is no exception. So here the hack if your hankering for a good NY style pie. Order from here take it home and finish it properly in your 500 degree oven. It's elite pizza when you get the crust crispy on the bottom. If people down here liked proper pizza I think they would sell it this way, so I'm not holding this against them. This goes for their competitors too (Yaghis, Home Slice, etc). You can maybe try asking for it well done (aka done properly).
The food was fantastic, the manager went above and beyond to make sure everything came out excellent, all was very fresh and perfect temp on wings , pizza and fresh cold salad!! I will always come back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Giant Slice
Good pizza! A large is way bigger than any other large I’ve ever seen period!
Food: 4
Service: 5
Amazing Pizza! Come here weekly and they never disappoint. Go all out or keep it simple, it’s always delicious!!! Hand spun dough, that is crispy but airy. Their sauce is amazing, and their cheese pulls to die for! Great place for lunch with wife and 3 kids. They even put on some cartoons for my kids. Recommend this place for anyone who loves authentic New York Pizza!Kid-friendliness: Tv with kid friendly showsWheelchair accessibility: Wheel char ramp to sidewalk and easy entry to shop
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Giant Slice, Cheese Pizza
One of my favorite spots! Dog friendly and great lunch specials. I can get my giant slice of pizza and a fresh salad. Brewskees next door with outside seating, so my pup can run around. They always have a special going on at Woodrows. Fav munchies are the fried Raviolis and the buttered Garlic Knots. And something about that homemade ranch just hits differently ? Yall are the best! ?Vegetarian options: Build your own, salad, and apps
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Greek Salad, Giant Slice, Extra Marinara, Side of 2oz, Garlic Knots
Absolute worst pizza I have ever had. Horribly
Food: 1
The Round Rock location is 5 stars. This one.. it’s mid. You ask for extra sauce and they give you the driest pizza you could ask for. Felt like I was eating a grilled cheese last time. ?
Food: 1
I like the pizza and it was definitely a New York pizza and good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
All the pizzas were really chewy and hard to eat. The taste was mostly bland and lacked flavor. The crust looked more like plastic except for the margarita pizza which was relatively soft to eat. There is a need to improve the way pizzas are delivered so that they remain hot and worthy to be eaten.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
One word: disappointment. Took an hour for the pizza to be done. Disappointed. Charged me for RANCH? Disappointed. Pizza was not impressive. Would not recommend
Such good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giant Slice, Giant Cheese Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
Our pager died while we were watering so that was a bummer but incredibly helpful and nice staff. Got the fried ravioli and churro cheesecake. Fried ravioli was AMAZING. Six pieces with marinara, so delicious! Churro cheesecake was also amazing. Good size and delicious.
Honestly, pretty good! The pizza slice is insanely big and a great value! I always order my pizzas well done and highly recommend other doing so. This is a no fuss, great pizza place!
Hard to understand some of the bad reviews, we moved to Austin 6 months ago and truly have not found a go to pizza shop . First time ordering last night during football , got a black olive and mushroom and asked for it well done . There’s good and there’s not good in pizza … this was so good , cooked proper crispy , zero flop , traditional pizza . It was high 8s on the Barstool scale .Also got fried ravioli , arrived hot , crispy not greasy with a good rigotta and cheese filling . Way good too.
Food: 5
Brooklyn Pie is conveniently located close to us. The pizza is tasty, not greasy and customizable. The price is reasonable.We ordered 1 large and 1 medium pizza on a Friday night. Our order was around 5. We understand it’s dinner time on a Friday and don’t expect things to be slow. However, we were given a timeline of 20-25 minutes when we ordered online. I arrived for pick up during that time and was asked to wait 10 minutes (no biggie!).. I watched people wait and come and go. Our order took over an hour. From my own experience in the food industry, I understand delays can happen. What’s upsetting was that I had to check on our order 2-3 times as it kept getting forgotten. I was displeased with the lack of customer service and communication. At the end of the day, it’s just pizza and if it’s a longer wait I just want to know so I can plan accordingly since my 2 kids aren’t as patient. I would suggest in the future to give the customer the courtesy of the choice to wait or move on. Instead, I was told they got a lot of Uber orders.. which again would have been nice to know prior to my extended wait time. I’d like to also suggest communication from the staff since no one wants to feel forgotten or wants to have to be the one nagging the serving staff for an update. Offer water or an easy to grab appetizer while your guests wait.. just some ideas.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Look, Texans don't like good pizza. That's why every NY style pizza you'll get in this city is woefully undercooked. Brooklyn Pie is no exception. So here the hack if your hankering for a good NY style pie. Order from here take it home and finish it properly in your 500 degree oven. It's elite pizza when you get the crust crispy on the bottom. If people down here liked proper pizza I think they would sell it this way, so I'm not holding this against them. This goes for their competitors too (Yaghis, Home Slice, etc). You can maybe try asking for it well done (aka done properly).