46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Bulverde

I drive 45 minutes just to go here... it's worth it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Perfect Pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Family gathering celebrating birthdays! Restaurant setting was perfect, food was beyond excellent, adult beverages cold. Been a fan for years!

I tried the New Yorker & added sausage for the first time & it’s was delicious!

Awesome pizza, one of my favorites. If you like NY style, this is the spot

My family and I visited this restaurant, but unfortunately, we did not feel welcomed upon arrival. Although the restaurant was empty, neither the host nor the staff acknowledged us, even after we greeted them. We ultimately decided to leave due to the lack of engagement. A warm welcome goes a long way in creating a positive dining experience, and I hope the restaurant considers improving in this area.

I didn't feel the pizza was very good. Very expensive! Beware to half your pizza is an 8.95 upcharge. The $8.95 salad is a 4x4 to-go container.

Employee pulled into the parking lot next to my car and slammed their door into my car and just walked off didn't do anything about it. If this is fine for y'all then I couldn't imagine coming here to eat. If taking responsibility and doing the right thing is beyond y'all then I would imagine that is how customers are treated as well.

The food here is so good! I used to live in Austin and, honestly, it’s been a little depressing going from a ton of great pizza options (Homeslice, Yaghi’s, Via 313, etc.) to...well, Canyon Lake. Villanova’s used to scratch the itch when they got it right, but when they didn’t—whoof. Then they closed, and I resigned myself to the price and convenience of Domino’s.

I’ll be real: I knew about 46th Street long before I tried it, but the reviews and photos online didn’t exactly inspire confidence. One day I was driving by, said “screw it,” turned around, ordered a pie, and waited. Took it home—and so glad I did. Whether I'm feeling lazy, having pizza and a movie night with my partner, or hosting my mom, I find myself going back more and more. Bonus surprise: their desserts are legit! I don't know if they're made in-house or sourced fresh, but they’re good.

Service is excellent. They always answer the phone, the pizza is ready when they say, and the cashiers are patient and pleasant. Abby helped me most recently—offered me extras, showed me the dessert options, and gave me a full rundown of the chocolate mousse cake (I grabbed cheesecake this time, but do yourself a favor and try the carrot cake when it’s available). Reece made our pizza this time—sometimes it’s Pablo, one of the managers, who’s always zipping around making sure everything’s running right. Pizza was still hot, fresh, and foldable when I got home.

Atmosphere feels noncommittal, like if you threw a sports bar, a moody Italian pizzeria, and a NYC tourist trap in a blender. It’s fine—I’d eat in without hesitation, just not with enthusiasm. One ding: constant Fox News feed on the back wall. Not trying to catch up on the world’s problems while picking up a pie. How about no news instead?

Very disappointed- I’ve had this pizza before and it was great. Tonight I called around 7 to place an order for pickup. I was placed on hold for a few minutes (totally fine! It’s Friday night) and when the phone was answered I ordered 2 pizzas. I waited and then was asked to order again. So I did. I asked for 1 medium meat lovers and 1 small Quattro Formaggio. I was asked to repeat the second option again. Then with no response I was placed on hold. He answered again and asked me to repeat it again so I did and specified that it was the 4 cheese pizza. Then in the background I heard mumbling with the man who was taking my order saying he couldn’t understand the second item. I tried clarifying but I waited another 2 minutes before I heard “Hello” in another voice and then was hung up on. If it’s a pizza you don’t have anymore just tell me, no biggy, just give 10% more effort to customer service please and try to have employees understand the items on the menu.

Service: 1

Damn good pizza!

Terrible tasting pizza, you can maybe fool the native residents here but not people who have grown up with great tasting pizza their whole lives ..pizza is an American staple at least for a hundred years now....this joint needs a menu revamp on ingredients or management because the quality is seriously lacking ..call Gordon Ramsey or something..i sure as heck wont be back

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Calzone

I love their pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I've been here three times at various times. Each time was perfection.
They have beer and wine, if you're into those.
They have much, much more than pizza. All the pastas, all the salads.
My favorite so far is the manicotti.
They use superior ingredients in every dish and pizza.
Speaking of, the pizzas are made with love. You can tell.
You should go and have a delicious meal.

Oh, also, the fried mozzarella was insanely good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza in the area by far!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5