Always our favorite! Went this past Saturday night and food and service were amazing as always! Seated immediately when we arrived and the waiter recommended a great bottle of Champagne which was delicious. Service was very efficient but not rushed and food was spectacular! Overall great place for a date night!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Serhii Kozlov
Delicious twists on traditional comfort food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben
Took my wife here for her birthday and had a great time. The oysters were fantastic and the staff was great!
John
We've had excellent dining experiences at Gemma in the past, so we were looking forward to our visit. Our reservation for two at 6:15 was honored promptly, and we were seated right away. The food was very good, but the service fell short of expectations. Our server was barely present throughout the meal, and the timing of the courses was poorly managed with long gaps between dishes, followed by items arriving out of order. Overall, the lack of attentive service detracted from an otherwise enjoyable meal.
Cindi
It was our first visit there and we will definitely go back! Service was wonderful and our food was delicious! Good cocktails!
bradley voyles
Full but not overpacked on a Thursday night. The staff was attentive but not pushy or intrusive. Food was a pasta and scallop dish. Simple dishes prepared well and served comfortably. They comped an appetizer for my wife’s birthday. The breaded olives and pecans came to the table toasty and tasty. Everyone was welcoming. Price was reasonable for quality, service & atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Faris
Love that place, comfortable vibe, welcoming, the food is amazing and the service is really good. Great for date night, or even a casual preppy dinner with friends or family
Baydoun Baydoun
Gemma feels cozy yet sophisticated—perfect for an evening out. I had the seared scallops with corn purée and a seasonal salad. Each plate was bright, light, and beautifully seasoned. The scallops were caramelized just right. The wine list is well-curated, and service strikes that balance between friendly and polished. Comfortable, consistent, and deeply satisfying.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Marcia
This is the second meal I have had at Gemma in the last few months. Both times were over-the-top delicious. I ordered the scallops the first time and the salmon on the second visit. Since they were both excellent consider this post is an overwhelming recommendation. Wine list is nice...so is the cocktail "Basil Beauty." Lucious. Enjoy! I'm going back soon
Irene
Jeremy was an excellent waiter who helped me tremendously with my special eating needs. He also made excellent recommendations. One thing I had deserves special mention. The Moules Frites were the best I've ever had. It was a simple dish but so delicious with no fishy taste and the mussels were tender, not stringy, easy to eat. I would go back for those alone. Next time I'm going with my sister and we will get them for an appetizer and share them!!
The olives and pecans have no business being that addictive. Loved the mol frites and was too full to finish the Cajun ribeye and arrabiata pasta! Beautiful dinner thank you so much
Sadie
The food is always fabulous however this time the lamb chops were extra yummy! The salad special was on point. Sweet Jeremy was a great server, he was patient with us and gave us time to chat for a bit before we ordered. There was also a young man who helped him, sorry I didn't get his name but he was so cute and funny. The manager came to apologize for not getting our brussels sprouts out, and we were grateful as we were stuffed after eating all our meal. We had to dash off to the theater so didn't have dessert. We will be back! 
Raul
The food, the food was just phenomenal and extremely well prepared. Every bit of it was esquisite. The staff was amazing, service was great and very attentive. The prices were not too high for the service and food. Expect to pay $100 for 2 without drinks.
Doug
Excellent food across the board from appetizers to dessert. The only downside is that the cocktails are expensive for what they are.
Ryan
We had a very nice meal at Gemma. The Rabbit Pappardelle was outstanding and the burrata was delicious. A few of the other appetizers were solid, although not memorable. The restaurant is very cozy and the wait staff is exceptional. Certainly worth dining here!
Always our favorite! Went this past Saturday night and food and service were amazing as always! Seated immediately when we arrived and the waiter recommended a great bottle of Champagne which was delicious. Service was very efficient but not rushed and food was spectacular! Overall great place for a date night!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious twists on traditional comfort food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Took my wife here for her birthday and had a great time. The oysters were fantastic and the staff was great!
We've had excellent dining experiences at Gemma in the past, so we were looking forward to our visit. Our reservation for two at 6:15 was honored promptly, and we were seated right away. The food was very good, but the service fell short of expectations. Our server was barely present throughout the meal, and the timing of the courses was poorly managed with long gaps between dishes, followed by items arriving out of order. Overall, the lack of attentive service detracted from an otherwise enjoyable meal.
It was our first visit there and we will definitely go back! Service was wonderful and our food was delicious! Good cocktails!
Full but not overpacked on a Thursday night. The staff was attentive but not pushy or intrusive. Food was a pasta and scallop dish. Simple dishes prepared well and served comfortably. They comped an appetizer for my wife’s birthday. The breaded olives and pecans came to the table toasty and tasty. Everyone was welcoming. Price was reasonable for quality, service & atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love that place, comfortable vibe, welcoming, the food is amazing and the service is really good. Great for date night, or even a casual preppy dinner with friends or family
Gemma feels cozy yet sophisticated—perfect for an evening out. I had the seared scallops with corn purée and a seasonal salad. Each plate was bright, light, and beautifully seasoned. The scallops were caramelized just right. The wine list is well-curated, and service strikes that balance between friendly and polished. Comfortable, consistent, and deeply satisfying.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
This is the second meal I have had at Gemma in the last few months. Both times were over-the-top delicious. I ordered the scallops the first time and the salmon on the second visit. Since they were both excellent consider this post is an overwhelming recommendation. Wine list is nice...so is the cocktail "Basil Beauty." Lucious. Enjoy! I'm going back soon
Jeremy was an excellent waiter who helped me tremendously with my special eating needs. He also made excellent recommendations. One thing I had deserves special mention. The Moules Frites were the best I've ever had. It was a simple dish but so delicious with no fishy taste and the mussels were tender, not stringy, easy to eat. I would go back for those alone. Next time I'm going with my sister and we will get them for an appetizer and share them!!
Restaurantji Recommends
The olives and pecans have no business being that addictive. Loved the mol frites and was too full to finish the Cajun ribeye and arrabiata pasta! Beautiful dinner thank you so much
The food is always fabulous however this time the lamb chops were extra yummy! The salad special was on point. Sweet Jeremy was a great server, he was patient with us and gave us time to chat for a bit before we ordered. There was also a young man who helped him, sorry I didn't get his name but he was so cute and funny. The manager came to apologize for not getting our brussels sprouts out, and we were grateful as we were stuffed after eating all our meal. We had to dash off to the theater so didn't have dessert. We will be back! 
The food, the food was just phenomenal and extremely well prepared. Every bit of it was esquisite. The staff was amazing, service was great and very attentive. The prices were not too high for the service and food. Expect to pay $100 for 2 without drinks.
Excellent food across the board from appetizers to dessert. The only downside is that the cocktails are expensive for what they are.
We had a very nice meal at Gemma. The Rabbit Pappardelle was outstanding and the burrata was delicious. A few of the other appetizers were solid, although not memorable. The restaurant is very cozy and the wait staff is exceptional. Certainly worth dining here!
Loading...