Beth Marie's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Just ordered from you guys for the 1st time. It took an hour to get delivered. It was melted. The fact that you don’t have a product that from store to home is edible is terrible. Spend some money on proper packaging for deliveries of your product if you’re going to use Uber Eats or DoorDash! I’m sure it’s great if I come there but you fail at your delivery! I wasted $27.00 on 3 pints. That’s just your charge and not all the other charges for delivery. If you’re too cheap to properly ensure your product can be delivered the same way from store to home then stop offering delivery. You failed a 1st time customer. Other ice cream places have it figured out and charge the same or less.

This Place is Majestic. The ice cream was so good that I am so happy that I went there. You must go if you want good ice cream with a lot of flavors to choose from. Only thing is that they don't have cotton candy sometimes.

A must try if you are in Denton. Hands down the best ice cream we have tried. Cute decor too!

This place is a hiden Gem..
There ice cream flavors are vwry clore or right on point to the natural flavors..
Loved it.
I tried there lemon drop, chocolate cayenne, dark sunset and all there are amazing.

Lots of flavors to choose from including seasonal favorites. The flavor & texture of every ice cream I tried was excellent.

What a sad sad disappointment.. the weeks before Christmas.. no bubble gum, no old fashioned sodas... my cherry limeade was just the worst.. the worker asked me if I wanted it carbonated...then proceeded to open an old tonic bottle, (flat) and made the worst tasting red drink... ice cream was great ...i was grateful and thankful and goodness knows theyre out numbered here... but just a huge dissapointment... I asked the worker again, if this was the 'carbonated version' and he said yes.
The one lactose free option is sherbet. Just so sad... 3.50 for a flat grenadine with little tart.

Ice creams are great, many options, fresh waffle cone. I love different flavors.
Some Staff members gets very frustrated when specially with long line and if you ask to try new flavor. I understand but there are enough staff to handle it.
It’s remind me Brooklyn ice cream from NY Brooklyn.

Tasty ice cream. inside is always air conditioned in the summer. They got good (I'm pretty sure homemade?) waffle cones too. They have dog treats too! Inside makes me think of old fashioned ice cream parlor. Like the goofy goobers place in the SpongeBob SquarePants movie back in the early 2000s

Delicious and I LOVE YOU GUYS for staying open late. Please always have Bees Knees, I feel like a fairy when I eat it 🥰

I personally feel they should take lemonade off the menu. The worst lemonade I had in my life.

Seems like a tourist trap.. $9 dollars for two ice cream cones with one scoop each wow...I have never heard of ice cream by the ounce... The flavors we choose were way too sweet and tasted old.

Keep trying to find a local ice cream shop that is worth the hype and money.

This place is a classic. Real home-made ice cream with unique flavors. Real fresh made waffle cones. Atmosphere and staff are always welcoming. It's a great place to bring the crew and hang out while you eat desert or bring your friends from out if town to show them a piece of Denton history and culture. Either way you won't leave disappointed!

Only giving it 4 stars because they don’t have a soda fountain and the one worker we got was pretty cold, you could tell he was ready to go home. But the ice cream we got was great and so was the atmosphere! We were there at 11pm and it was packed, long line, but the line moved really fast!

If you want a good old fashioned experience, Beth Marie's is the place to go for the best ice cream. They offer a couple dairy free options and have so many options for different ways to have dessert. They have tables for dine in. Their prices are great and their servings are just right. The old school feel makes this place what it is. We love coming here!

Well this was a disappointment. Came in for the old fashioned soda fountain and apparently they don't do that anymore. Decided to get ice cream instead, only to find that the apple caramel was flavorless. It was basically just vanilla. The butterscotch soda was fine but not mixed well at all. At least the chocolate chip cookies were good.