Julie and Jonathan are top notch in bringing the laughs, the good time, and the food. Haha. Can't wait to go back. This place is the best gem in El Paso because of people like them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Miriam Arriaga
It was me and my husband’s first time at this place and we loved it! The service is great and the food was amazing. It’s a must when you visit El Paso! ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Lorraine Chavira
My parents and I wanted to try something different so we searched nearby restaurants and this one popped up first. From the minute we walked in we were intrigued with the place. The staff is like family. Very attentive and super friendly. Make sure to order a pizza and you get a serenade. {When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie…that’s A’more} Can’t wait to go back!
One of the coolest places to visit in El Paso! Atmosphere is amazing, food is delicious, and the staff treats you like family. Very excited to go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dazza gallegos
It’s a great experience definitely a must the atmosphere is wonderful the people who work there are great and make you feel like home and the food is my favorite been there twice and definitely will be going again
Jenny Gallegos
Robert and Jonathan were amazing such awesome personalities and energy made us feel like family. Everything was delicious even my little one was in love with the sauce and bread.
I have been coming to this place since i was a kid, so for around 20 years. This place has been the place I go to for birthdays, friend gatherings, school and even dates. The atmosphere is beyond great, the owners are incredibly friendly and the staff is phenomenal. If you have a chance try it. You will not find a similar place anywhere in el paso.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake with Spoleone Ice Cream
Michael Liljedahl
Pizza was great. The decor was a little
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paloma Cardiel
I REALLY wanted to like this place. The service was great. Our server Julie, was amazing. The food was meh. We had the appetizer melody and everything except the pizza rolls were flavorless. I had the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, the sauce is basically flavorless, the shrimp were fine. I got the salad (you have a choice of soup or salad with entrees and you get a bread roll) and it was overdressed with Italian dressing and had whole baby carrots in it for some reason. I will say, the pizza looks promising. A table next to us ordered a pizza and it looked really good. The red sauce they use for the pizza also comes with the appetizers and that was really good. Also, they seriously need to get someone in there to dust everything off AT LEAST once a week. It’s giving more dusty vibes than ghostly vibes. Eek!
If I can give this restaurant a 20/10 stars, I would! My boyfriend Christian and I had the most amazing and delicious experience here! Julie was our server and she gave us what felt like royal treatment, she was kind and caring and we shared a lot of fun and laughs. The entire staff were incredible and kind! This restaurant is our personal favorite Italian restaurant because it truly tastes like homemade quality Italian food. The environment is so fun and unique, as unprofessional paranormal investigators they let us walk around and explore the entire restaurant and the staff gave us their personal stories and the ghosts who reside there. The best dinner experience we can ask for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natasha Norman
Let me start by saying I really, REALLY wanted to like this place so it pains me to write this. I’ve seen and read all about the history of this place and it peaked our interest so my partner and his family decided to try it tonight for dinner. We went in through the back entrance to the haunt/bar side of Monteleone’s and having never been there before staff kindly walked us through to the restaurant side showing us where the entrance was ?. We were seated in a smaller room that was casino themed at a halved casino table. I will say the placement was a little awkward as the four of us were facing the wall and the high chairs with no bar rest in front of us made it a weird position for our legs. All of the servers and staff were VERY SWEET, and so kind and attentive! However our food in one word was very BLAND. We ordered the zucchini sticks to start and they were flavorless and not cooked long enough?(too crunchy like eating a raw zucchini). I ordered the baked rigatoni with mushrooms (an extra charge of $2 or so) and again I’m sad to say this was so, so bland. The plate was hot but the pasta was not. It had melted cheese on top but even then I had to add salt to doctor it up. The meat sauce was too acidic. My partner ordered ravioli with meat sauce and it was four large raviolis but according to him “if I knew it was just going to be four I would’ve ordered something else”. Our meals did come with a choice of soup or a salad. I opted for a salad but even then the salad was ‘eh’ even with ranch. The others had the soup and it came in a tall very narrow cup with one small meatball and crackers that was just ‘okay’.I know this place is supposed to read dark and haunt-y but to me, at least where we sat, it was giving musty, dusty, crusty… like even the padding on the table felt sticky and the chairs definitely had some questionable stains on them. I’m glad I went to experience it for myself but I would sadly never eat here again. The food isn’t it.??
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Sarah Cano
Julie, Robert, Jonathan & Karla gave AMAZING service. This place is so charming & wholesome ?<3
Julie and Jonathan are top notch in bringing the laughs, the good time, and the food. Haha. Can't wait to go back. This place is the best gem in El Paso because of people like them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
It was me and my husband’s first time at this place and we loved it! The service is great and the food was amazing. It’s a must when you visit El Paso! ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
My parents and I wanted to try something different so we searched nearby restaurants and this one popped up first. From the minute we walked in we were intrigued with the place. The staff is like family. Very attentive and super friendly. Make sure to order a pizza and you get a serenade. {When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie…that’s A’more} Can’t wait to go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, Chocolate Cake with Spoleone Ice Cream, Homemade Provolone Wedges, 16 Pizza
One of the coolest places to visit in El Paso! Atmosphere is amazing, food is delicious, and the staff treats you like family. Very excited to go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s a great experience definitely a must the atmosphere is wonderful the people who work there are great and make you feel like home and the food is my favorite been there twice and definitely will be going again
Robert and Jonathan were amazing such awesome personalities and energy made us feel like family. Everything was delicious even my little one was in love with the sauce and bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, Homemade Provolone Wedges, Pizza, Alfredo Shrimp Alfredo, Lasagna and Penne
I have been coming to this place since i was a kid, so for around 20 years. This place has been the place I go to for birthdays, friend gatherings, school and even dates. The atmosphere is beyond great, the owners are incredibly friendly and the staff is phenomenal. If you have a chance try it. You will not find a similar place anywhere in el paso.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake with Spoleone Ice Cream
Pizza was great. The decor was a little
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I REALLY wanted to like this place. The service was great. Our server Julie, was amazing. The food was meh. We had the appetizer melody and everything except the pizza rolls were flavorless. I had the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, the sauce is basically flavorless, the shrimp were fine. I got the salad (you have a choice of soup or salad with entrees and you get a bread roll) and it was overdressed with Italian dressing and had whole baby carrots in it for some reason. I will say, the pizza looks promising. A table next to us ordered a pizza and it looked really good. The red sauce they use for the pizza also comes with the appetizers and that was really good. Also, they seriously need to get someone in there to dust everything off AT LEAST once a week. It’s giving more dusty vibes than ghostly vibes. Eek!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Love this place ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Truly amazing food and the staff were great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I can give this restaurant a 20/10 stars, I would! My boyfriend Christian and I had the most amazing and delicious experience here! Julie was our server and she gave us what felt like royal treatment, she was kind and caring and we shared a lot of fun and laughs. The entire staff were incredible and kind! This restaurant is our personal favorite Italian restaurant because it truly tastes like homemade quality Italian food. The environment is so fun and unique, as unprofessional paranormal investigators they let us walk around and explore the entire restaurant and the staff gave us their personal stories and the ghosts who reside there. The best dinner experience we can ask for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Let me start by saying I really, REALLY wanted to like this place so it pains me to write this. I’ve seen and read all about the history of this place and it peaked our interest so my partner and his family decided to try it tonight for dinner. We went in through the back entrance to the haunt/bar side of Monteleone’s and having never been there before staff kindly walked us through to the restaurant side showing us where the entrance was ?. We were seated in a smaller room that was casino themed at a halved casino table. I will say the placement was a little awkward as the four of us were facing the wall and the high chairs with no bar rest in front of us made it a weird position for our legs. All of the servers and staff were VERY SWEET, and so kind and attentive! However our food in one word was very BLAND. We ordered the zucchini sticks to start and they were flavorless and not cooked long enough?(too crunchy like eating a raw zucchini). I ordered the baked rigatoni with mushrooms (an extra charge of $2 or so) and again I’m sad to say this was so, so bland. The plate was hot but the pasta was not. It had melted cheese on top but even then I had to add salt to doctor it up. The meat sauce was too acidic. My partner ordered ravioli with meat sauce and it was four large raviolis but according to him “if I knew it was just going to be four I would’ve ordered something else”. Our meals did come with a choice of soup or a salad. I opted for a salad but even then the salad was ‘eh’ even with ranch. The others had the soup and it came in a tall very narrow cup with one small meatball and crackers that was just ‘okay’.I know this place is supposed to read dark and haunt-y but to me, at least where we sat, it was giving musty, dusty, crusty… like even the padding on the table felt sticky and the chairs definitely had some questionable stains on them. I’m glad I went to experience it for myself but I would sadly never eat here again. The food isn’t it.??
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Julie, Robert, Jonathan & Karla gave AMAZING service. This place is so charming & wholesome ?<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5