This is my 2nd time going here each time I was looked at like what do u want. Horrible customer service or either racism probably both. The cashier saw I was wearing a mask started coughing and did not go wash her hands. It was probably done purposely. I turned around and walked out. I will never return again .
Summer Armistead
The owner and her staff are always pleasant and kind. The pies and thumbprint (peppermint are my favorite) cookies are always fresh and tasty. They have the best key lime and strawberry pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
april pinto
We’re in love with these pies, and the service and especially their to-go ice cream and pie desserts!!! Best pies on the planet!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Micah A.
Best pie around!!! My top faves are the Key Lime (SOOO good, not too tart at ALL), I-40, and Coconut Cream. I cannot wait to try the Lemon Meringue and all the other flavors. Perfect for a birthday, anniversary, corporate gift, etc. They even offer different sizes, too! The service is impeccable, online ordering was a breeze (go directly to the website - super easy!) and the little shop is so cute and smells absolutely delicious. They even had free samples when I stopped in today - YUM.
Sarah Sibigtroth
Absolutely the best pie ever ♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buttermilk Pie, Apple Pie, Lemon Pie
Ryan
My wife and I have loved this place for a long time and have been happy to support it. We have spent more money on these pies than we care to admit! Unfortunately the prices continue to skyrocket and one small 4" pie now cost EIGHT DOLLARS. That is bonkers. We backed off coming as much when the price went up to $6.50 and went in tonight and were shocked to see the $8 on the board. I understand the cost for ingredients has gone up significantly -- but you guys are truly pricing out people that love what you are doing. We would much rather give our money to you guys over Nothing Bundt Cakes or Crumbl. Is this price hike going to continue? Have you considered providing greater discounts to regulars or greater discounts for buying 4 or more? (4 small pies for $27 is also way too high).
Rogue Jiu-Jitsu
The best Coconut Cream Pie. No questions asked!
Amy H.
Great pies and great service! Highly recommend! Best pies around and they are all made there from scratch. Soooo good!
Kirsten Thompson
Love their Key Lime Pie, especially since they have it daily year round! We even get Key Lime Pie at Christmas. Love it. They have regular 9” pies, 4” pie that you can get in a 4 pack to mix and match flavors, and packs of 2” pies for a party.
Wow, order fast, great pick up, and even better.yummy taste!!! One of our faves in town.
Justin Luzier
Incredible pies! A must for any holiday gathering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crystal Cooper
Amazing pies for Thanksgiving
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Southern Custard Pie 9, Apple Pie, I-40 Pie 4
Maddie Lasater
We used Buttermilk Sky Pies for our wedding this past November! Amy and Wade were nothing but helpful and all of our guests loved their pies! It was such a sweet touch to our wedding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marilee H.
We love Buttermilk Sky Pies!!! The coconut cream and key like are our go to pies for bdays - we don't even bother with cakes any more.
This is my 2nd time going here each time I was looked at like what do u want. Horrible customer service or either racism probably both. The cashier saw I was wearing a mask started coughing and did not go wash her hands. It was probably done purposely. I turned around and walked out. I will never return again .
The owner and her staff are always pleasant and kind. The pies and thumbprint (peppermint are my favorite) cookies are always fresh and tasty. They have the best key lime and strawberry pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’re in love with these pies, and the service and especially their to-go ice cream and pie desserts!!! Best pies on the planet!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pie around!!! My top faves are the Key Lime (SOOO good, not too tart at ALL), I-40, and Coconut Cream. I cannot wait to try the Lemon Meringue and all the other flavors. Perfect for a birthday, anniversary, corporate gift, etc. They even offer different sizes, too! The service is impeccable, online ordering was a breeze (go directly to the website - super easy!) and the little shop is so cute and smells absolutely delicious. They even had free samples when I stopped in today - YUM.
Absolutely the best pie ever ♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buttermilk Pie, Apple Pie, Lemon Pie
My wife and I have loved this place for a long time and have been happy to support it. We have spent more money on these pies than we care to admit! Unfortunately the prices continue to skyrocket and one small 4" pie now cost EIGHT DOLLARS. That is bonkers. We backed off coming as much when the price went up to $6.50 and went in tonight and were shocked to see the $8 on the board. I understand the cost for ingredients has gone up significantly -- but you guys are truly pricing out people that love what you are doing. We would much rather give our money to you guys over Nothing Bundt Cakes or Crumbl. Is this price hike going to continue? Have you considered providing greater discounts to regulars or greater discounts for buying 4 or more? (4 small pies for $27 is also way too high).
The best Coconut Cream Pie. No questions asked!
Great pies and great service! Highly recommend! Best pies around and they are all made there from scratch. Soooo good!
Love their Key Lime Pie, especially since they have it daily year round! We even get Key Lime Pie at Christmas. Love it. They have regular 9” pies, 4” pie that you can get in a 4 pack to mix and match flavors, and packs of 2” pies for a party.
Best damn pie I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow, order fast, great pick up, and even better.yummy taste!!! One of our faves in town.
Incredible pies! A must for any holiday gathering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pies for Thanksgiving
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Southern Custard Pie 9, Apple Pie, I-40 Pie 4
We used Buttermilk Sky Pies for our wedding this past November! Amy and Wade were nothing but helpful and all of our guests loved their pies! It was such a sweet touch to our wedding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love Buttermilk Sky Pies!!! The coconut cream and key like are our go to pies for bdays - we don't even bother with cakes any more.