Pies delicious. For best choice, get there when they open. Small, homemade pie shop my favorite....coconut cream
Todd K.
Cute place with super friendly staff tried the chocolate cream and chocolate pecan pies. Enjoyed both.
Susanna C.
Cutest pie shop with lotions, jams and more. Make sure to go early, once they sell out they close! We were able to buy half and half.
Christen S.
Great service and good pies! Disappointed at the limited flavors available but still will be back.
Marc G.
This is a MUST stop for anyone heading to Fredricksburg. These pies are so good your going to want to try one of everything. My favorite which I've had multiple times is the Buttermilk pie. It's like a mix between a custard and cream brûlée in a homemade crust. Whatever your choice of pie, you will Or be disappointed. Very friendly and they do have other items for sale.
Heaven N.
My husband and I stopped by while we were visiting Fredericksburg and OMG! The pumpkin pie is so so good! We'll definitely be coming again! We also loved the cozy, home-y feeling and the friendly service. Very welcoming! 10/10! Definitely recommend
Vivian K.
Heavens to Betsy ... the pies are GOOD!!! At the advice of the shop owner, I ordered a piece each of the chocolate-pecan, the peach pecan... and the key lime pie was for my honey. Everything was lovingly made from scratch (the peach was her grandma's recipe), and with real fruit, quality ingredients, and any sweetness added was done so with expert-level restraint. We're only in town a few more days, so we will be visiting as much as possible until then!
Cynthia C.
Great pie. Had the coconut cream pie. Awesome crust! Hubby had the chocolate meringue and he loved it!
Alesa S.
Delicious, high quality pies! Never disappointed by them! Order early for Thanksgiving and Christmas!
I851DOcarls
Great food and EXCELLENT SERVICE!! Dog friendly. Best waitress I’ve had in Fredericksburg. Will definitely return!
Oh. My. Goodness. Gracious. Why would you even come to Fredericksburg if you don't come to Fredericksburg Pie!?!? Come early, because they sell out - because it's SO GOOD! The pie and the coffee are DELICIOUS, the ambiance is charming, and all the extra little things for purchase are fantastic. I can tell that the proprietors put all their love and excellence into their homemade pies and service. I highly recommend!! I can't wait to come back 30 times so I can taste rest each sampling
Sarah B.
The peach bourbon pecan pie was excellent! My husband had the cherry pie; it wasn't for me, but he enjoyed it! My only negative is I feel the prices were a little high considering, especially as I used to work at a bakery and have made quite a fair share of pies. But it was an enjoyable stop, very cute location, and the pie was delicious.
Laura W.
I'm so disappointed and surprised. The reviews of this place were pretty good. We were in the mood for key lime pie (which they were out of), we ended up taking home a slice of peach and a slice of berry pie. Boy were we disappointed. The pies were both dry, not sweet or flavorful at all, ans the crust was mediocre. I can get better pies at HEB. Sadly, we do not recommend this place and we will never go back.
Raine B.
A must-stop when you're in Fredericksburg and rightfully so!! The people are so sweet! The store and the decorations were so cozy and cute! We really appreciated such kind service! I'm not a huge pie person, but this place won my heart! I picked Coconut Meringue, while my friend got Lemon Meringue. We were so delighted with the meringues! We usually find toppings too sweet, but it was just PERFECT in taste and consistency. The fillings were also SO DELICIOUS! I got a side of ice cream to pair, and it was a nice palate cleanser in between bites. They sell coffee and lots of small goods here as well! We got here around 12:30 noon, and they were already halfway through their pies! I now understand why they're always quick to sell out! Their pies are WONDERFUL!!
Julie V.
The German chocolate pie was amazing and great people to work with! I wasn't able to make it in time and they left it for me outside on ice so it wouldn't get ruined.
Pies delicious. For best choice, get there when they open. Small, homemade pie shop my favorite....coconut cream
Cute place with super friendly staff tried the chocolate cream and chocolate pecan pies. Enjoyed both.
Cutest pie shop with lotions, jams and more. Make sure to go early, once they sell out they close! We were able to buy half and half.
Great service and good pies! Disappointed at the limited flavors available but still will be back.
This is a MUST stop for anyone heading to Fredricksburg. These pies are so good your going to want to try one of everything. My favorite which I've had multiple times is the Buttermilk pie. It's like a mix between a custard and cream brûlée in a homemade crust. Whatever your choice of pie, you will Or be disappointed. Very friendly and they do have other items for sale.
My husband and I stopped by while we were visiting Fredericksburg and OMG! The pumpkin pie is so so good! We'll definitely be coming again! We also loved the cozy, home-y feeling and the friendly service. Very welcoming! 10/10! Definitely recommend
Heavens to Betsy ... the pies are GOOD!!! At the advice of the shop owner, I ordered a piece each of the chocolate-pecan, the peach pecan... and the key lime pie was for my honey. Everything was lovingly made from scratch (the peach was her grandma's recipe), and with real fruit, quality ingredients, and any sweetness added was done so with expert-level restraint. We're only in town a few more days, so we will be visiting as much as possible until then!
Great pie. Had the coconut cream pie. Awesome crust! Hubby had the chocolate meringue and he loved it!
Delicious, high quality pies! Never disappointed by them! Order early for Thanksgiving and Christmas!
Great food and EXCELLENT SERVICE!! Dog friendly. Best waitress I’ve had in Fredericksburg. Will definitely return!
Restaurantji Recommends
Oh. My. Goodness. Gracious. Why would you even come to Fredericksburg if you don't come to Fredericksburg Pie!?!? Come early, because they sell out - because it's SO GOOD! The pie and the coffee are DELICIOUS, the ambiance is charming, and all the extra little things for purchase are fantastic. I can tell that the proprietors put all their love and excellence into their homemade pies and service. I highly recommend!! I can't wait to come back 30 times so I can taste rest each sampling
The peach bourbon pecan pie was excellent! My husband had the cherry pie; it wasn't for me, but he enjoyed it! My only negative is I feel the prices were a little high considering, especially as I used to work at a bakery and have made quite a fair share of pies. But it was an enjoyable stop, very cute location, and the pie was delicious.
I'm so disappointed and surprised. The reviews of this place were pretty good. We were in the mood for key lime pie (which they were out of), we ended up taking home a slice of peach and a slice of berry pie. Boy were we disappointed. The pies were both dry, not sweet or flavorful at all, ans the crust was mediocre. I can get better pies at HEB. Sadly, we do not recommend this place and we will never go back.
A must-stop when you're in Fredericksburg and rightfully so!! The people are so sweet! The store and the decorations were so cozy and cute! We really appreciated such kind service! I'm not a huge pie person, but this place won my heart! I picked Coconut Meringue, while my friend got Lemon Meringue. We were so delighted with the meringues! We usually find toppings too sweet, but it was just PERFECT in taste and consistency. The fillings were also SO DELICIOUS! I got a side of ice cream to pair, and it was a nice palate cleanser in between bites. They sell coffee and lots of small goods here as well! We got here around 12:30 noon, and they were already halfway through their pies! I now understand why they're always quick to sell out! Their pies are WONDERFUL!!
The German chocolate pie was amazing and great people to work with! I wasn't able to make it in time and they left it for me outside on ice so it wouldn't get ruined.