New York Pizza and Pints IV

I have been disappointed lately with restaurants with 4.5+ stars and decided to give it a chance for a NY pizza place with low stars and I loved the pizza! I Ordered DoorDash. I do recommend!

Solid Pizza and Salad. Homie in here working by himself was holding this place together! I’m always inspired by guys working by themself and serving people timely. As a New Englander, this pizza passes. It’s a 7.1 TX slice.

a gentleman hit the nail on the head with the pizza being as close to a true NY style pizza & it being as good as it gets for the area. this will be my go-to when i’m in the mood for pizza. he was also spot on with the atmosphere needing a little extra oomph.

a lot of other reviewers have been fairly dramatic, if we are being honest. for example complaining about light sauce but you’re going in to eat a NY style pizza … cmon. anyways, if you could get somebody in this store to spic up the vibes & properly run the place, this place would be A1! 🍕

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely Delicious!

I can’t say enough good things about this place! The pizza is absolutely phenomenal—perfectly crispy crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and toppings that are always fresh and generously portioned. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and every bite is packed with flavor.

Beyond the food, the service is top-notch. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always makes sure you have everything you need. Whether dining in or taking out, the experience is always seamless.

If you’re a pizza lover, this is the spot for you. Highly recommend!

The food takes too long, no beer or soda coolers were full. There used to be a girl before and she takes good care of customers now she is gone and the men in the restaurant only speak Spanish and do not understand what I’m talking to them. If you have a lot of time and need to waste it then give this restaurant a try.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The little Edgar was working hard but pizza was gross and under cooked. Place was dirty and understaffed. All of the Parmesan shakers were empty half of the Coke selections in the fountain machine were empty floors were sticky, just gross. The one over in the Allen outlets is much better..

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

My family and I have eaten here several times, and while the pizza is good, the customer service is consistently terrible.

During our first visit, I showed up to pick up an order only to find that it hadn’t even been started. Apparently, a cook took our order in the back but never wrote it down!

Most recently, we ordered a pizza for delivery at 6:09 PM, and as I write this at 8:10 PM, there’s still no sign of it. To make matters worse, I tried calling to check on the order, but no one answered the phone.

Good food alone doesn’t make up for such poor service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Hands down the best New York-style pizza I’ve found in Texas! As a pizza lover, I’m always on the hunt for that authentic, thin, foldable slice with a perfect ratio of crispy crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese and this place nailed it. The crust has that perfect char, and each bite takes me back to my favorite NYC pizzerias. They don’t skimp on toppings, either, and the flavors are just right without being overly greasy. Friendly staff, great atmosphere, and the taste makes it absolutely worth the visit. If you’re craving real NY pizza, this is the spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I honestly think their oven thermostat is broken. Ordered the cheese bread and when I asked if they could remake it I was told “that’s the way the bread is” and offered a refund. We ordered slices and when they came out they were just as burnt.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

I love this place. But my last two order have been absolutely terrible. Both incorrect orders (like none of the staff speaks English)

And tonight when I came in the cook tried to make it right, but rushed the pizza and it was so soggy when I got home the kids didn’t even want it anymore and I had to recook the whole pizza in my oven.

Plus, I’m pretty sure I was over charged. Huge waste of $45.

Management- I’d like for you all to make this right. I’m happy to give feedback. We really love your food but the last two times we have come in have been very, very poor.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

I go to the counter and the person behind the counter doesn’t understand basic English? When I tried to ask him a question he just pushed me off and asked me to leave? What a horrible experience for a business that looks like they really need my business.

Do better.

Service: 1

As someone who has loved this place for awhile it has become unbearably unprofessional, very very disappointed… over Father’s Day my family had ordered food online for our event and when we went to go pick up all the way from Celina they were locked, lights off and no one there; even though they were supposed to be open. Finally got ahold of someone after HOURS of trying to resolve this issue and she had apologized and given us the offer of a free pizza to accommodate the time and issue. However, today we went to order over the phone to order a large pizza and also our free comped pizza and when we called they said “English not good” and hung up on us 3 different times. Never coming here again and warning everyone about this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Their daily special is great! Pizza was ok but big slice. It's too thin for me, but not bad. Loved they had black cherry soda on tap! Meatball sub had no meatballs! Just small pieces of meat and sauce. That I did not like but I didn't order eat. My friend didn't either.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

We arrived, there was no one in the room, the tables were completely dirty, we asked for the order, we gave the service tip and while waiting for 25 or more, the girl arrived with the pizza in the box, saying that we cannot eat there since they are 2 employees and we questioned him because he didn't say it from the beginning and the person who was working in the kitchen comes to the table saying exactly the same thing and that he notified the employee to tell us but she never did. She never cleaned anything around us and just sat there folding boxes. During all this time, another couple arrived after about an hour of being there and they told them from the beginning and they left, that is, they lost sales because they did not have employees, and with my experience in restaurants, one on the floor and one in the kitchen is possible since it is not possible. It's waiter service, I'm still amazed at this deal. I did stay to eat because the excuse is not valid and I was not going to eat the extra large box of pizza anywhere else since I was not going back to my house. How unfortunate that a place where they have an exquisite pizza on several occasions has not had a pleasant time eating at this establishment. In the time that I have been sitting here writing this, it has been an hour and a half, only the couple came in and they did not let them consume in the establishment, nor have I seen delivery looking for food, so my question is that two employees can't? There will be no total they are losing money. The service girl in the salon doing cash and on her cell phone.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Ordered and paid for a pizza online. When I arrived to pick it up the employee was extremely rude. She tried to make me pay a second time for the pizza. The pizza itself was missing sauce, and two other ingredients. Not to mention part of the crust was burnt black. I will not be getting pizza here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1