over the past month I've eaten at Islamorada twice and will have to say it's improved I had pretty much written it off my list but had visitors in that wanted to eat on the lake it really surprised us give it another try
Nalani Keltz
Great personnel, Lisa our server was very knowledgeable & helpful. My pasta was great, as we're the fish & chips my partner had. Will go again, it's fun to eat, then walk around Bass Pro.
Chris B
Gotta be honest here. For the price of most dishes, the food sucks. After at least 5 years, I decided to give it another try. What was I thinking? I won’t be back.
Lane F.
Great location... Service is what I expected. Not attentive, never asked if we wanted refills during our lunch and a bit rushed. Oh, there was only 2 other people dining. The food is less than stellar. The "famous" Islamorada fish sandwich was tasteless and slid off the bun after 2 bites. The tartar sauce for the sandwich was even more bland than the sandwich. Thus, I just partook of the fish and fries. Can't recommend this place. Too many other restaurants in this area that provide better service and a better food product.
clinton3004
Trippindicular-me, it was an absolute pleasure to have you visit us again! We appreciate you taking the time to positively rate and review us! We are glad you joined us again, and hope to see you soon.
mdbake2018
Thanks for leaving us a review, clinton3004. We appreciate all your feedback-good and bad- because we will use the information to continue to improve our guests’ experiences! Hopefully we will have the pleasure of serving you again soon.
Brian Hiatt
Had the fried shrimp. Nothing spectacular in my opinion. Josh our server was fantastic. Great young man.
Noel Krause
The restaurant is superb and roomy, the food was delightful and the prices were very economical. quickly, efficient service and very attentive staff members. Recommended.
Yikes is all I can say. What a horrible restaurant. The hostess was weird and rude, the waiter was polite but the food was cheap tasting, expensive, and bland. Best part was the French fries. Kids pizza is like a red Barron, the veggies are just green beans that taste microwaved. Really not impressed at all and it’s really really costly. Definitely won’t be back.
Liz Burk
Great food and amazing atmosphere. Came here on Black Friday with a group of friends. It was pretty busy but we still got great service. I’m just disappointed I didn’t know about this place sooner. I’ve been coming to bass pro shops since they opened and only found out about the restaurant from a man up front talking about shrimp. I’ve never noticed the restaurant mentioned on any signs or commercials. It amazes me that all of this time I had no idea bass pro had a restaurant and neither did my friends. Now that I did find it I hope to visit frequently. I definitely recommend this place. The portifino was good and I also enjoyed the views even though it was a rainy day.
Anna Kuykendall
Cool ambiance, expensive for the amount and quality of food though. Also slow service, but friendly. I ordered a $22 plate and left hungry and also wasn't impressed, also my kids had their kids meal items. We had to stop at a drive through on the way home to order some food as everyone was still hungry. Fun place to sit and nice people but probably won't go back.
Carly Mascarenas
Waited to be seated on Thursday 11/14/19. Was never greeted or assisted, although I saw more than one member of the wait staff. Left without ever being acknowledged :(
cyndi smith
Staff is friendly and great. Love the view of the lake as well as the decor inside.
over the past month I've eaten at Islamorada twice and will have to say it's improved I had pretty much written it off my list but had visitors in that wanted to eat on the lake it really surprised us give it another try
Great personnel, Lisa our server was very knowledgeable & helpful. My pasta was great, as we're the fish & chips my partner had. Will go again, it's fun to eat, then walk around Bass Pro.
Gotta be honest here. For the price of most dishes, the food sucks. After at least 5 years, I decided to give it another try. What was I thinking? I won’t be back.
Great location... Service is what I expected. Not attentive, never asked if we wanted refills during our lunch and a bit rushed. Oh, there was only 2 other people dining. The food is less than stellar. The "famous" Islamorada fish sandwich was tasteless and slid off the bun after 2 bites. The tartar sauce for the sandwich was even more bland than the sandwich. Thus, I just partook of the fish and fries. Can't recommend this place. Too many other restaurants in this area that provide better service and a better food product.
Trippindicular-me, it was an absolute pleasure to have you visit us again! We appreciate you taking the time to positively rate and review us! We are glad you joined us again, and hope to see you soon.
Thanks for leaving us a review, clinton3004. We appreciate all your feedback-good and bad- because we will use the information to continue to improve our guests’ experiences! Hopefully we will have the pleasure of serving you again soon.
Had the fried shrimp. Nothing spectacular in my opinion. Josh our server was fantastic. Great young man.
The restaurant is superb and roomy, the food was delightful and the prices were very economical. quickly, efficient service and very attentive staff members. Recommended.
I enjoyed the fried pickles
Beautiful restaurant
Restaurantji Recommends
Yikes is all I can say. What a horrible restaurant. The hostess was weird and rude, the waiter was polite but the food was cheap tasting, expensive, and bland. Best part was the French fries. Kids pizza is like a red Barron, the veggies are just green beans that taste microwaved. Really not impressed at all and it’s really really costly. Definitely won’t be back.
Great food and amazing atmosphere. Came here on Black Friday with a group of friends. It was pretty busy but we still got great service. I’m just disappointed I didn’t know about this place sooner. I’ve been coming to bass pro shops since they opened and only found out about the restaurant from a man up front talking about shrimp. I’ve never noticed the restaurant mentioned on any signs or commercials. It amazes me that all of this time I had no idea bass pro had a restaurant and neither did my friends. Now that I did find it I hope to visit frequently. I definitely recommend this place. The portifino was good and I also enjoyed the views even though it was a rainy day.
Cool ambiance, expensive for the amount and quality of food though. Also slow service, but friendly. I ordered a $22 plate and left hungry and also wasn't impressed, also my kids had their kids meal items. We had to stop at a drive through on the way home to order some food as everyone was still hungry. Fun place to sit and nice people but probably won't go back.
Waited to be seated on Thursday 11/14/19. Was never greeted or assisted, although I saw more than one member of the wait staff. Left without ever being acknowledged :(
Staff is friendly and great. Love the view of the lake as well as the decor inside.