Carmine's Italian

1170 Sidney Baker St S, Kerrville
(830) 315-1170

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Heidy Teague

Great service and amazing food ..we loved everything about this place!! The waitress was very friendly and attentive, we did not wait long for our food, which was served hot and fresh. We do not live in Kerrville, but we will be returning just to go back to Carmine's!

Linda Pounds

Y’all keep up the great work!

Larry Hullum

Best pizza in Kerrville!!

Robert Wippermann

Carmine's is an original NY city pizza shop. Great pizza with that great NY pizza crust that is faithfully made here.
Great Italian dishes from spaghetti to seafood. All fresh ingredients that make restaurant food so tasty. Daily specials. I eat here regularly.

Dietary restrictions: Splurge once in a while, although italian food is healthy

Parking: There's only about 12 parking spots for three businesses, but usually, there's an open one.

Kid-friendliness: They have a kids sized menu and enjoy children there since this is a family run business with Carmines adult children working in the kitchen.

Chris Wilkinson

The food has been good in the past but seems like the urge to provide quality Italian is becoming lost.

Spaghetti tonight was bland, sauce tastes like ragu off the shelf.

Salad lettuce was browning.
Hope to see it take a turn for the better.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

John Wilson

This will be short. There's no beer or wine. It's BYOB. We left without eating.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

dude thingg

10/25/2024

Lunch time: Hi, do yall deliver? "No, I'm sorry sir".... are yall on doordash? Uber eats? "No I'm sorry sir"

Dinner time: Hi, can I make a to go order, "I'm sorry sir we stop taking to go orders at 8PM...

"Hi, welcome to Dominos,"

Service: 1

Marina Longnickel

OVERCHARGED US!!!!
We ordered a pepperoni pizza and a supreme pizza, as well as 25 wings (which they didn't specify were boneless on the phone when we called)
So let's say $23 for each pizza based on the posted prices (which is obscene for a gas station quality pizza with slices about half the size of Sbarro) and $22 for wings. That's $68. WE GOT CHARGED $85!!! Even if accounting for tax that's 26%???
I will be doing a chargeback with my bank and the can enjoy the shit record on their payment gateway.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Felipe Barbosa

Terrible decor, decent food and service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

Jason Kendrix

Ordered Ckn Parm to go, was burnt and inedible. Lucky they're on the other side of town or I'd go back. Not returning.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Gloria Kyzer

Food was decent, there is an extra charge for a tiny garlic roll. Political affiliation is apparent.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

lisa brooks

Couldn’t eat here. There was a huge Trump banner.

Jason Brown

Best pizza in kerrville bu a mile great service great atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls

jorge rodriguez

We took a day trip to Kerrville to come see the Cross and decided to stop at Carmines afterwards. We heard various things about the food, especially the pizza ? so we were curious.

I will say off the bat there are some unusual things about it. They serve no wines or liquors, they do have ☕, but no espresso or cappuccinos. I am from New York and these are normally givens at an Italian spot. Also atmosphere wise it was very empty which caught us off guard for a Saturday.

Yes, the pizza is as big as they say for an individual slice. Huge and these will fill you up fast. Quality wise the pepperoni, cheese and Marguerite slices were good, but the supreme was dry, uninspired, and over cooked.

My wife had the chicken Parm. Hers was overcooked, though it looked good initially. She liked the spaghetti, ? I found it plain with little flavor.

Our waiter was quite nice and helpful. We made sure to leave him a good tip.

We are not sure we would go back personally, but I am glad we did try it.

Kid-friendliness: Decent kids menu for little ones.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Cheese Pizza

Ronnie Dean

My wife and I are from Waco. We came to Kerrville with a group to drive the twisted sisters highways. We Ate dinner here tonight. Fantastic food! Fantastic service and a fantastic environment. Everything was delicious, if I lived here , we would eat here all the time!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...