Montana Mike's
1153 Oasis St, New Braunfels
(830) 620-1234
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
The food was amazing & the wait staff couldn't have been nicer
Pick-up is absolutely RIDICULOUS here!!! Received texts that my order was ready and still had to wait 8 minutest to receive my order. People choose curbside/pick-up for a reason. If you are not going to be on it, simply don’t offer it!! And we had two sides missing as well; lovely 🤣
Good food. Great service!
This place was pretty mediocre. The waiter brought us our steaks and said “check them to see if they’re cooked right.” Huh? I asked for a medium. How hard was that? I was just unimpressed with the whole vibe over there because they do charge regular steakhouse prices.
The chicken Alfredo is bomb and hit the spot!
Great food, good portions, and fair prices. Would have like to see military or LEO discounts though.
5/22/25. We drove from Seguin six of us . Waited 10 minutes for a table . No problem. Went to bar and ordered drinks . Bar tender looked confused when my wife ordered a lemon drop martinis. After five minutes waiting on drinks our table became available. We sat at the table in front of the bar for ten minutes. No waitress ever approached us , never saw our drinks or the bartender. We finally gave up and left . Several empty tables but people waiting for a table? Saw the busboy sitting on his phone the whole time . Empty tables all around. Did the manager quit or something? It was crazy . We usually enjoy this place. We left went to salt grass and had an amazing dinner. Do better Mikes
Went on a Sunday after church and there wasn't a wait. Plenty of tables available. Service was very good and I had a melt in your mouth ribeye! Literally one of the best steaks in forever. My only complaint is every single side we had was bland. The okra, Mac n cheese, green beans. Everything needed seasoning. Even the Cesar salad was bland. But...I'd return just for the steak! The pic is my son's 22 oz sirloin!
This restaurant is above average on value and the food is exceptional. Service is great. You can't go wrong here.
Steak was too salty
Restaurantji Recommends
The steak was soft, ez to cut, not much fat. plenty of room. daylight space or dark area... bar as well. beside the motel 6. decent location.
Keep in mind this is my second ever experience here. I decided to take some friends for dinner after work. The waiter, I didn't catch his name was very kind and courteous. My review stems from the quality of the food and likely has to to do with the kitchen staff.
First was the fried zucchini that came out with hair fried into it, even though I overlooked that I did bring it up. One of the ranch containers also had a fly imbedded in it, then was covered up and served to us. Once again we're not hard people to please, so we overlooked this and continued to eat our food. The waiter was informed of both things, offered to take the food back but honestly after a 10 hour day we just wanted to eat some food.
On our way out we got one last refill for our drinks, however one of us had tea and we are certain the refill was not tea at all once tasting.
The bill was over $100, I made sure to tip the waiter as I know none of this was his fault but I will not be returning to Montana Mike's in the future or ever again. I wanted to like y'all, I wanted to support a local business. But please take a look in the kitchen, it could be so much better. Especially if I'm going to pay those high prices.
Everything is average, but so are the prices. So if you want average service with average food and delicious rolls, come here on Tuesdays. Kids eat free.
Was in TX for my grandsons wedding, and had dinner with him, my son and his wife. Dinner was so good and the waiter, Durel was the best. (Not sure I spelled the name correctly). Would highly recommend.
I would leave no stars if I could. Refused take out orders on mother's Day. My mother is in a nursing home and is unable to go to their establishment. Refused to make an accommodation. Spend your money elsewhere.
Loading...