Montana Mike's

1153 Oasis St, New Braunfels
(830) 620-1234

Recent Reviews

Sort by
billy lacy

8/28/2025 7:30pm. Ordered unsweetened tea, it was sweet. Waitress didn't just bring me another tea, she chewed me out and said it was unsweetened, then chewed me out some more after I asked her to leave me alone. I didn't feel like eating, wife had it all to go. Manager did nothing, asked him to not send that waitress back- he did. She was abusive again. We paid for our ruined meal and left. We have eaten there 100 or more times in recent years. 60% of the time, my medium steak was well, well done. I never made a fuss, just had them fix it. No good steakhouse in NB. This isn't really a steakhouse, just a family restaraunt that serves steak. I'm done with MM.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Eric Galvan

My fantastic server mason was incredible. Best service ever!! Drinks stayed filled, food came out quick and treated us like family. Very good sense of humor. Highly recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Killian

Four of us dined, all ordered steaks. Three were overcooked, one of which to the point of dried out leather. Steaks were also very thin, and very pricey for what they were. They re-served (at no cost) the steaks we complained about - which were then cooked correctly. But after eating everything else, pretty much wasted motion. We took them home. Swatted gnats away throughout the meal, saw others doing it too. Waitress service was phenomenally great however, and the other food items were fine. Complementary huge slice of cake for birthday was a nice touch, as most places do. All in all, doubt we'll return.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Julio Mendoza

Sat for 3 hours for the most mid food ever. From Kraft Mac n Cheese to getting someone else’s food 3 times. Still waiting for the check…..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Susan Jentsch

Darrel was a great server and we came in late and he was on point and never complained
Food was good as always and service great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

darrick Phillips

We were served by Darrell and we had the best experience. We also had a great experience with food and staff. Mr. Elliot helped us and was an absolute team player as they were closing and we felt so accommodated. Please give Elliot and Darrell and absolute raise!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diya Patel

We came in 13 mins before closing and we could not believe how amazing the staff and the food was. Our server, Darrell, was so amazing and he had amazing support from his staff serving our table of four. Elliot was so great as well. These two gentlemen deserve more than just a pat on the back! Whenever we are in town, we will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sherry Siegle

Alcohol is very measured not a drip over

Jeannine Harris

Received order and basically that was it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Melanie Warren

We had my parent's anniversary party here a couple of weeks ago and it was great. The staff was friendly and responsive to all our needs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Albert H

Don't

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Edith Mary Stanley

The food was amazing & the wait staff couldn't have been nicer

Christina M

Pick-up is absolutely RIDICULOUS here!!! Received texts that my order was ready and still had to wait 8 minutest to receive my order. People choose curbside/pick-up for a reason. If you are not going to be on it, simply don’t offer it!! And we had two sides missing as well; lovely 🤣

UnknownREknown

Good food. Great service!

Felix Blaksley

This place was pretty mediocre. The waiter brought us our steaks and said “check them to see if they’re cooked right.” Huh? I asked for a medium. How hard was that? I was just unimpressed with the whole vibe over there because they do charge regular steakhouse prices.

Loading...