Eilenberger's Bakery

512 N John St, Palestine
(903) 729-2176

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David Wright

This is not the best fruitcake. So disappointed. Don’t like the cinnamon taste. Would not order again.

Food: 2

Carol Schaefer

Very disappointed in 3lb. Fruitcake. Tastes bland, soft mushy texture since most of the fruit and nuts are on the top. Additionally, rather than candied pineapple, there is a green candied fruit which would have kept me from ordering if I read it in the ingredient description. Expected more when pay about $75.00 with shipping.Only gave it one star because the shipping and delivery was exactly as promised.

Oscar Nolasco

World class customer service! My grandmother had fruitcakes ordered through Goodbelly and received one tin without a lid. She was upset and called and spoke to someone in customer service. She solely wanted a lid for the tin. Not only was the bakery extremely apologetic, but they sent and entirely new fruitcake. The cake itself is incredible, not too sweet and perfectly moist. 10/10 will be using them again and again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carol Stockel

Trying to find a fruitcake as good as Costco used to sell 4 yrs ago. Eilenberger's isn't close. Lots of fruit and nuts but the cake portion is a little too moist. Mostly taste nutmeg. Uses high fructose corn syrup in recipe, not real sugar. Tiny fruitcake for the price. Edit- slicing cake was almost impossible, very sticky.

Dennis L.

Everyone in Palestine, and the surrounding area, knows about this place. I did not until recently. What a pleasant surprise to find such a historic and delicious bakery hidden in a town with at least 50 Mexican restaurants. Will become a regular stop as I transit Anderson County.

Ty Cobble

Delicious foods, great help with my inquiries. I will return for Christmas goodies?❤️

Colby Collier

Service and sweets are impeccably good. Heather is awesome!

Dana Robinson

My favorite cookie in the worldAPRICOT ANGELS

Valarie Prather

The bakery to go to for great cookies!

Hans Karl Umkehrer

Great selection, everything delicious, and a great old bakery

Lacey Davis

Good people

Brad George

Closed on the weekends!

Joe Ramos

Great food

Heather “Heather B” OBrien

Their cookies and bars are delicious!

Eleanor

It is too high. They wanted $25 shipping for one cake. They have lost my business and I am sure that they don't care.

Loading...