Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

My husband brought two slices home. 18.00. NEVER again. It would be different if it was worth it. I ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza. It was dry, hard and I'm sure it tasted like the cardboard box it came in. I wasn't there, but I gave one star for service, because the workers should have known better than to serve a slice that looked like this. I feel like I was robbed and won't be going back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

I went in around lunch time to try their giant slice with pepperoni. I was very disappointed with the pizza here. The bread was hard, the cheese was hard, and even though the slice was indeed giant, it had no flop. As someone who loves NY style pizza this was really bad.

Employees and the service here were great, but I wouldn't come back here for the food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Great pizza. The girl at the counter didn't inform me of lunch specials.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Giant Pepperoni Slice

I think the pizza tastes great. I was alright with spending ~28 dollars (with a small tip+tax) for a 14"-4 topping pizza every now and again. They upped the price of the same pizza to 31 dollars before tip and tax. That is INSANE to me.

Each topping now costs more but it's because they claim everything is more expensive now, and not because they are adding more of that topping to the pizza. I understand price increases, but I already thought they were reaching for that ~28 dollar price.

Look at the included picture and judge for yourself if you think that's $3 worth of pepperoni, $3 worth of ricotta, $3 worth of italian sausage, or $3 worth of black olives. I don't think it is. Especially the black olives. The blanket $3 per topping is pretty telling to me that they just want every cent they can get from you. There is no way they should charge the same $3 for black olives and Italian sausage.

I brought up this price increase to a worker while overpaying for the pizza and she acknowledged that it was expensive and only offered that it was because ingredients cost more. I commented that at these prices, I won't be coming back. At the end of the transaction she just turned away and left without a word. I didn't raise my voice and maybe spoke for 20 seconds about the topic while paying. The way she just left without a word as soon as she gave me the receipt felt pretty disrespectful.

I would've given them 3 stars with the above comments because it's ultimately up to you whether or not you think a ~31 dollar (before tax/tip) pizza is worth it. Unfortunately, they have messed up my order a few times. I always ask for ricotta but on more than one occasion they have given me mozzarella instead. It's pretty upsetting when a pizza place can't tell the difference between cheeses, and that was before the price increase.

I won't be ordering from them again with these prices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Thought they opened at 11am
Employee, owner, or whoever comes up to the door to unlock it at 11am.
Doesn't say a word to me.
Yeah, good luck with business. Bye ✌️

Service: 1

I had the food delivered. It was amazing!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

Hard not to give it 5* they have fantastic massive slices. It was cold a few times is the only thing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Seriously? Won't be coming back. Nice job...

Food: 2

Need to move into a bigger facility so people can enjoy the pizza there. Great pie and salad.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie, Greek Salad

The best pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Pie

Good pizza. Great interaction with staff. Fast service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

It was 6:03pm and the person do want to sell me a slice

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Absolutely amazing pizza ? neck and neck with Yahgis !!

Parking: There's plenty of parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Slice, Fresh Out of the Oven, Medium Cheese Pizza with Pepperoni and Black Olives, Classic New York Pizza

This place just feels cool. The posters on the walls, the checkered floor, the music, all of it really brings a New York Aesthetic. I had dinner with my mom and my sister so we ordered a pie, which took a little time, but was worth it. I would recommend there be a table cleaner, because there were crumbs on the table we sat at. All in all, I Hope this little business gets big one day and more people can appreciate it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Pizza Slice, Classic New York Pizza, Pie

They couldn’t take big bills. Seating area was small

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5