PB&J with Tay

5335 McCullough Ave, Olmos Park
(210) 518-8299

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich
The Double Decker Delight
The Egg-Cellent PB\u0026J
Honey Bear with Bacon
The Egg-Cellent PB&J
Pooh Bear Sandwich
Hawaiian Sandwich
The Kitchen Sink
Strawberry Jelly
Pineapple Jelly

Menu

Signature Sandwiches
Classic
peanut butter, and jelly.
KJB
Peanut butter, banana, and marshmallow.
Razz Me No More Questions.
peanut butter, Nutella, and raspberry jelly.
Rocky Road
Almond butter, marshmallow, and Nutella.
The Mega Crunch
Crunchy peanut butter, granola, walnuts, and jelly.
Classic Double Decker
Peanut butter, and jelly.
Texan
Peanut butter, jalapeno jelly, and bacon.
The Pooh Bear
Peanut butter, banana, walnuts & honey.
Elvis
Peanut butter, bacon, and banana.
Hawain
Peanut butter, bacon, coconut flakes, and pineapple jelly.
Make My Tay
Peanut butter, cream cheese, bacon, and choice of jelly.
The Egg Cellent
Peanut butter, over-hard egg, bacon, and strawberry jalapeno jelly.
Double Decker Delight
peanut butter, banana, walnuts, almond butter, bacon, cream cheese, and choice of jelly
The Kitchen Sink (Double Decker)
peanut butter, Nutella, cream cheese, walnuts, bacon, banana, coconut flakes, and choice of jelly.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+30 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+29 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We stopped in here after seeing someone on social media who shared their experience and this place did not disappoint. The pb&j was so freaking good and of course you have to pair it with milk too. The owner greeted us right away and broke down the menu and gave some amazing suggestions too. They take an original pb&j and make some minor tweaks that make it taste 100x better. Highly recommend this place and will be back to try some more.
August 2025
The food and service were very comforting. Taking something classic and adding a quirky twist made it so much fun. And the service—absolutely wonderful! I truly have no words. Thank you all! 10/10, I’ll definitely be coming back.
August 2025
Service was great, fast and very friendly. The atmosphere is very much a home vibe. Just a heads up to anyone: As mentioned in a past review which is important to mention as I observed this issue, but the restaurant does not provide ADA access as the only way to enter the restaurant is taking stairs to the second floor, so anyone in a wheelchair, aged, or with a disability would find it very difficult to access due to the stairs.

The food is very average. As...
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Yaya's Thai Restaurant - 5305 McCullough Ave
Thai, Vegan, Vegetarian
Pesto Ristorante - Olmos Park - 5221 McCullough Ave
Italian, Salad, Pizza, Vegan
Krazy Katsu - 5257 McCullough Ave
Chicken Shop, Chicken, Pet Friendly

PB&J with Tay

5335 McCullough Ave, Olmos Park, TX 78212
(210) 518-8299