We had an amazing meal and our waiter Alex was very helpful and customer oriented.The food was delicious and the portions are just the good size.The atmosphere is nice but it was very cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Retiredbeanctr
Great pizza - was recommended by the KOA campground we were staying at. Got a large 1/2 and 1/2 pizza for carry out, was surprised upon pick up that price included a nice Italian salad for 2. We opted for thin crust and it was great
Culture67682622152
First time attending Gabrella's Italian restaurant. Brick oven pizza was amazing. Would rate 5 stars if our waiter Juan F. would have attended us better. Asking other staffs members were found to be respectful.
Gene G
Longtime local. Left a clothing item, next day asked if found and an employee says yes it was but they couldn’t find where they put it… after she said she really liked it. Came back 5 times asking for it. Different story each time, last story was they threw it away. Obviously an employee stole it. Manager offered zero compensation and argued rudely. Bad idea to lie to and steal from locals.
Tony R
Gabriella's never fails. We had above and beyond service from our waiter Alex who made our experience memorable. He was fast, funny, and engaging! We all enjoyed our entrees and will be back again on our next trip.
Isaac M
We only live an hour away, and almost always go for seafood when out at the island. I decided to mix it up this time, and Gabriella's caught my eye. How have I not heard about this place? This was easily the best lasagna and pizza I have ever had. It would be worth the trip out here just to eat here. It is an immediate add to our favorite spots.
H5380ARdanr
If you been there or not. You must try the Pasta Italian nachos. you won't find better nachs in the island.
Marilyn B
Best pizza in town. We had a 16in pizza, picked our toppings, came with salad and garlic bread. Excellent pizza. Service was fast, pizza came out quickly. Friendly waitress, (Christina). Price was reasonable.
dkdoremifaAustin
What a great evening! The eggplant parmigiana and clams fettuccine were over the top, only to be exceeded by the wonderful server, Alex. He made the evening perfect ! Thank you Alex , we’ll be back !
Brittney F
Our “salad” was brown rotten lettuce with soggy tomatoes and a few slices of cheese. The “garlic bread” was soggy and hard (quite an accomplishment!), and the large pizza barely covered half the box! Order Pizza Hut.
Had high hopes for this place but it definitely let us down. We looovee pizza and this pizza was doughy like not cooked thru and tooooo cheesy for my taste. However I will say we tried several pizza places and had the same experience with the pizza so maybe the humidity or something. But still not good.
Vacation45333843449
Amazing experience. Walked in and asked for a table for 10. They had a table ready in minutes and we were relieved thinking we were going to be waiting. Beautiful setting and the food was memorable and delicious.
ALopez03
The food here was so amazing!! The waiter was so fun and had great recommendations when asked. The Cesar salad was one of a kind delicious. It was pricy but worth every penny!
Anita D
1st time at Gabriella's. Food was great. We had the Lasagna, tomato basil soup, Calzone, and Shrimp Fettuccine. Our Server, Juan, was great as well. Very good experience. Thanks.
MJNeuhaus
Super disappointed. We were told it was a 30 minute wait and after 1 1/2 hours and. $40 tip to the hostess we werww Eq finally sat outside in 2 separate tables. The Mayer came out and refuse that bribes were accepted and the employee was identified, nothing was done. So dissappointed.
We had an amazing meal and our waiter Alex was very helpful and customer oriented.The food was delicious and the portions are just the good size.The atmosphere is nice but it was very cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza - was recommended by the KOA campground we were staying at. Got a large 1/2 and 1/2 pizza for carry out, was surprised upon pick up that price included a nice Italian salad for 2. We opted for thin crust and it was great
First time attending Gabrella's Italian restaurant. Brick oven pizza was amazing. Would rate 5 stars if our waiter Juan F. would have attended us better. Asking other staffs members were found to be respectful.
Longtime local. Left a clothing item, next day asked if found and an employee says yes it was but they couldn’t find where they put it… after she said she really liked it. Came back 5 times asking for it. Different story each time, last story was they threw it away. Obviously an employee stole it. Manager offered zero compensation and argued rudely. Bad idea to lie to and steal from locals.
Gabriella's never fails. We had above and beyond service from our waiter Alex who made our experience memorable. He was fast, funny, and engaging! We all enjoyed our entrees and will be back again on our next trip.
We only live an hour away, and almost always go for seafood when out at the island. I decided to mix it up this time, and Gabriella's caught my eye. How have I not heard about this place? This was easily the best lasagna and pizza I have ever had. It would be worth the trip out here just to eat here. It is an immediate add to our favorite spots.
If you been there or not. You must try the Pasta Italian nachos. you won't find better nachs in the island.
Best pizza in town. We had a 16in pizza, picked our toppings, came with salad and garlic bread. Excellent pizza. Service was fast, pizza came out quickly. Friendly waitress, (Christina). Price was reasonable.
What a great evening! The eggplant parmigiana and clams fettuccine were over the top, only to be exceeded by the wonderful server, Alex. He made the evening perfect ! Thank you Alex , we’ll be back !
Our “salad” was brown rotten lettuce with soggy tomatoes and a few slices of cheese. The “garlic bread” was soggy and hard (quite an accomplishment!), and the large pizza barely covered half the box! Order Pizza Hut.
Restaurantji Recommends
Had high hopes for this place but it definitely let us down. We looovee pizza and this pizza was doughy like not cooked thru and tooooo cheesy for my taste. However I will say we tried several pizza places and had the same experience with the pizza so maybe the humidity or something. But still not good.
Amazing experience. Walked in and asked for a table for 10. They had a table ready in minutes and we were relieved thinking we were going to be waiting. Beautiful setting and the food was memorable and delicious.
The food here was so amazing!! The waiter was so fun and had great recommendations when asked. The Cesar salad was one of a kind delicious. It was pricy but worth every penny!
1st time at Gabriella's. Food was great. We had the Lasagna, tomato basil soup, Calzone, and Shrimp Fettuccine. Our Server, Juan, was great as well. Very good experience. Thanks.
Super disappointed. We were told it was a 30 minute wait and after 1 1/2 hours and. $40 tip to the hostess we werww Eq finally sat outside in 2 separate tables. The Mayer came out and refuse that bribes were accepted and the employee was identified, nothing was done. So dissappointed.
Loading...