Goodfella's Pizza & Subs

Great pizza and love that they are on GrubHub!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza was amazing. Im ready to try more off the great menu they have.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

OMG... from the time you walk in the door....the hospitality is amazing...very friendly....and the food is great!!....💯💯💯💯💯🤞🏽🤞🏽🤞🏽🍕🍕🍕💪🏽💪🏽💕💕💕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Goodfellas Pizza, Lasagna

Craig is the OG, know him from 20 years ago in my hometown. He’s awesome! Food is awesome!

Stopped in for mother's Day lunch with two of my daughters. We were greeted with a warm welcome and the counter display of pizza garlic knots and strombolis brought me back to New Jersey pizza shops. The pizza was delicious, garlic knots were great and stromboli was full of lots of flavor! Very friendly atmosphere, you can tell they care about their customers! We will definitely be returning!

this crew is top notch. 10 out of 10 must try again

Terrible, worst experience at a restaurant I’ve had in a long time. The dude running it at the time was rude as soon as I came in. Waited 50 minutes for my order, supposed to be ready in 16 minutes. Looked and smelled terrible.

Super nice owner and the pizza was good. We are new to the area and we're happy with the customer service we received!

My mom loved the eggplant and pasta dish 😋, I had the Chicken franchese, It was excellent 😋 👌 👍

Becky was very helpful and amazing the food was amazing and came out hot

Best pizza in town!

UPDATE 3/9/25 - pizza has improved since my last review. Ordered take out a few times as I just knew this place is a gem when pizza is done right and I was right. To be fair I increased the stars in my review. ————————————
This pizza is getting worse and worse every order. It’s not always bad but the pizza I got today was awful. Our pizza was flavorless, didn’t see any visible sauce, hoping the toppings weren’t old, it was just off. We asked for it to be cut in squares, didn’t happen (about the third time now) and we Asked please bring pepper flakes upon delivery, didn’t get that either. Given how filthy the place is on the inside I don’t even want to think as to why my pizza tasted off. I only order it when my brother visits because he likes it, but after this last order we may just leave them alone for good.

Excellent pizza

Excellent food, great people, great prices, really great people.

Great owner and menu. Small cozy location and dining room. The chef will make it your way on pasta dishes, pizza and salads. Pizza by the slice is great.