MeLisa The Pie Lady

3805 Main St #107, The Colony
(469) 294-0881

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mini Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Wlayer of Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter Fudge Mini Pie
Chocolate Cream Mini Pie
Full-Size Key Lime Pie
Large Banana Cream Pie
Mini Coconut Cream Pie
Mini Banana Cream Pie
Banana Cream Mini Pie
Mini Millionaire Pie

Menu

Mini Pies
Chocolate Cream Mini Pie
A thin layer of lightly sweetened cream cheese on top of a homemade honey graham cracker crust, topped with a thick layer of the perfect chocolate pudding then finished off with a homemade whipped cream and Hershey's chocolate shavings. This pie is our number one seller!
Keylime Mini Pie
You don't get more authentic Key West pie than this! We squeeze and zest our own key limes and make our honey graham cracker crust and whipped topping homemade to perfection!
Oreo Cream Mini Pie
We start with an Oreo cookie crust, then the cream filling is a mix of cream cheese and homemade whipped topping with lots of crushed Oreos inside. Then again we add another layer of whipped topping with 1/2 an Oreo on top. If you're looking for a pie for kids, this is the one! Adults love it too!
Peanut Butter Fudge Mini Pie
The crust is made with Nutter Butter cookies mixed with graham crackers, a thin layer of homemade chocolate fudge on bottom and top and the delicious peanut butter filling makes it all so delicious!!
Banana Cream Mini Pie
A homemade Nilla Wafer crust, two layers of bananas and a homemade vanilla pudding makes this pie taste almost like the banana pudding your grandmother used to make!
Apple Mini Pie
You won't find canned apple filling in this pie! We make it with real Granny Smith apples, full of cinnamon goodness!!
Cherry Mini Pie
We've had so many customers say this is the best cherry pie they've ever had! We tend to agree. Our ingredients that make it so yummy is our secret. The crust just makes this pie! It's crunchy because it's topped with sugar in the raw. You won't be able to get enough!
Pecan Pie Mini
The recipe for this pie came from my twin-sister's great-grandmother in law from the 1930's. It has the right amount of sweetness and loaded with pecans! If you're a pecan pie lover, you're going to love this pie!!
Buttermilk Mini Pie
This is one of our custard pies. Made with buttermilk of course, vanilla, sugar, eggs, the usual ingredients for a custard but it has the perfect amount of flavor and we're just sure you'll order it again after you taste it! Btw, the Chess pie is similar but is a lot sweeter than this one.
Chess Mini Pie
The chess pie recipe is a 200 year old tradition and we just love it! It's a custard pie with a bit more sugar than the buttermilk pie and where the buttermilk has flour in the custard to make the crust on top, this one has flour and cornmeal. Absolutely delicious!!
Coconut Cream Mini Pie
This coconut cream pie is made with the finest ingredients and actually won two prizes in a contest it was entered in. It won Best Pie and Best Dessert Overall. It is loaded with the finest sweetened coconut. You're going to love it!
Pumpkin Mini Pie
Pumpkin with Cream Cheese Mini Pie
Millionaire Pie
This is a summery treat! It's made with coconut, pineapple, cherries, and pecans in a fluffy whipped base, sat in our classic graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream, cherries, and chopped pecans!

Full-size Pies
Full-size Chocolate Cream
A thin layer of lightly sweetened cream cheese on top of a homemade honey graham cracker crust, topped with a thick layer of the perfect chocolate pudding then finished off with a homemade whipped cream and Hershey's chocolate shavings. This pie is our number one seller!
Full-size Key Lime Pie
You don't get more authentic Key West pie than this! We squeeze and zest our own key limes and make our honey graham cracker crust and whipped topping homemade to perfection!
Full-size Oreo Pie
We start with an Oreo cookie crust, then the cream filling is a mix of cream cheese and homemade whipped topping with lots of crushed Oreos inside. Then again we add another layer of whipped topping with five 1/2 Oreos on top. If you're looking for a pie for kids, this is the one! Adults love it too!
Full-size Pecan Pie
Melisa's Alabama roots help her create the best pecan pie you've ever tasted. Crisp pecans are blended into a sweet and nutty custard that's best served warm with a dollop of whipped cream or ice cream. Ingredients: Pecans, Karo syrup, butter, sugar, flour, vanilla, and eggs.
Full-size Apple
You won't find canned apples in this pie, we make it with fresh Granny Smith apples and the perfect amount of cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger to make it the best apple pie you'll find in Dallas!!
Full-size Cherry
We've had so many customers say this is the best cherry pie they've ever had! We tend to agree. Our ingredients that make it so yummy is our secret. The crust just makes this pie! It's crunchy because it's topped with sugar in the raw. You won't be able to get enough!
Full-size Coconut Cream
Award winning coconut cream is loaded with sweet, toasted coconut nestled in a flakey crust.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+64 photos
Photo credit: google
+63 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

It's so awesome that MeLisa has gluten-free pies and mini pies! I called and requested the turtle crunch. She didn't have any already made, but was able to put it together in just the time it took me to drive there. It tasted delicious. 100% will be going back.
July 2025
Pies are delicious and made with great care. Melisa and her staff are very kind and sincere. Over the years she has worked very hard to provide the best to all customers and has been a great part of the community.

My favorites are the cherry, chocolate cream, chess, key lime, and pecan. Buy 5 minis and you get a discount.

You can also look at the website or call the store if you are unsure if a specific pie is available.
July 2025
Some of the best pie we have ever enjoyed. They have a great selection of mini pies and some full sized pies. We went with the turtle pie and Dutch apple. The turtle pie was incredible.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

iHeart Kolache - 3805 Main St #110
Cafe, Bakery, Coffee & Tea
Cicis Pizza - 3805 Main St
Pizza, Kids Activities
Sonny Donuts - 3751 Main St #800
Donuts

MeLisa The Pie Lady

3805 Main St #107, The Colony, TX 75056
(469) 294-0881