Sicilia Mia Cottonwood

I do enjoy the small feel and locality. However, the food at the location further north is much better! But it is still good here so I give it 5 stars. The other location I would give 10.

Even through the voluntary quarantine you can still get delicious Sicilia Mia take away. It's a beautiful day to eat outside. Thanks crew for the delicious lunch!

Exquisite... spectacular... it's HOME.

This is my new favorite Italian food place! Just delicious and fresh.

Very nice little place this location is pretty small it doesn't seat many. The food is excellent, the carbonara and ravioli really stand out. Never had a bad meal here.

Fantastic food!! It was almost like we were in Italy! *except the prices were not like you would see in Italy-be prepared for a hefty bill. Dinner for 2 was $120 with tip. We had wine and an appetizer along with our main course. It was well worth it and we didnt want to miss out on anything* They were kind enough to squeeze us in for dinner LAST minute. The atmosphere was cozy yet formal. The walls covered in Italian pride of famous, I would assume, Italians. The service was great! We loved our bossy waitress, full of character! Will come again!

Offensive waiter and incompetent manager. Recommend staying away unless you want to have family dinner ruined by body shaming and manager dismissing it to racial stereotype. This restaurant left sour taste in my mouth. It’s unimaginable this would happen! Left me sick to my stomach all night. Might as well have gotten food poisoning.

The waiter Jerry was the very best thing at this restaurant.

Literally amazing food. Staff was above and beyond, great environment. Will recommend to everyone. Shout out to Misha our server, she was superb!

Pricey for the amount of food you get. Place is a bit cramped. One waitstaff has an attitude Not sure we will go again.

Ordered tagliatelle Sicilian Mia because the photos from other review was good, I took one too (attached)... but pasta was too hard and seafood was definitely from frozen package. Disappointed from such a high rating place

I would rate this place a 10 if possible!!! Best Italian restaurant I've ever been to, by far. The Spaghetti Carbonara is out of the world!! Staff is very attentive and helpful. My new favorite place to be.

I have been to the Highland Drive location three times. Every meal was amazing. That location is perfect. We decided to try the Cottonwoods Height location tonight. From the minute we arrived it was unimpressive. We had to share menus, after being told they did not have enough for our party of only five people. And we arrived at 5:00, right after they opened. The service was moderate. But the food was much different than the Highland Drive location. I had ordered lasagna at both locations. Tonight it arrived with no tomato sauce. Just cheese and noodles. And the lasagna was burnt on the sides. The flavor was very plane. The lasagna at the Highland Drive store is the best I have ever had. The others dealt with cold pasta. We will not be going back to Cottonwood Heights. It’s too bad the quality is not maintained at all locations.

Amazing food, and always such great service with a smile. We love Misha!

My boyfriend, and I had the opportunity to dine here tonight, and I gotta say.... Oh my word , it was simply PHENOMENAL! We loved how cozy the restaurant was! Soon as we walked in the door we were immediately made to feel so special. We had the best little table right next to the fireplace! We loved the intimate setting. The staff is fabulous! Everyone from Jerry, the AMAZING chef Generro, Roberto, Carlos, and Deirdra, the absolute sweetest thing ever! The food was amazing! I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for authentic Italian food! It was all made with heart, and it definitely showed here tonight! You guys have 2 new loyal customers for life! LOVED IT!!