The food quality during the winter isn’t as good as it is during the summer. Being only 1 of the few places open during the off season, I would probably go somewhere else next time but giving an extra rating since this place is usually pretty okay during the summer time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Richard Bradshaw
Meh. Find somewhere else. Over priced, under delivered.
Sam Wald
Really tasty pizza. Crust has the amazing balance of fire cooked without tasting like ask or feeling crunchy, but that necessitates it being a little thinner.
We also really liked the little cups of the Alfredo sauce on the side, that stuff is better than the papa johns garlic cups!
There's not much decoration on the wall besides Pepsi ads, but perhaps that's because the focus is on the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Hansen
No delivery service
Tara Sanchez
The pizza wasn’t fully cooked. The staff were very unfriendly. I’m a tourist here and so far everyone has been a bit unfriendly. I was looking forward to some good pizza. Sadly, I was disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Los
People out here during the off season has no respect for people just trying to get out. Pizza was the nastiest that I ever tasted. I don’t understand why people like it out here and 4th time out here and the locals are rude. Never coming out here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ashley Kuretich
We always go here when visiting Bear Lake. Food is amazing. Staff are always nice. They get very busy and sometimes you have to wait but the 🍕 pizza is fresh and worth the wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mirko Wisniowski
The food was quite Good. Except for minor missunderstanindings between us and the waiter it was a great experience. Very Kind waiters
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
amileeg2025
Horrible!! The price listed for their monster pizza on their website was totally inaccurate. I called them twice to verify the cost, and they never told it was so much more if you ordered different pizzas. My bill was 40 dollars more than it should have been. I even showed them the price on the website and they did nothing! The pizza was horrible, cold, and almost stale when we ate it, and the one pizza was even missing some toppings! If you are used to firehouse in Logan or just a good pizza in general, DO NOT eat here. Awful service awful food.
Shawn Godfrey
Their pizza prices online were different than what we were charged when we got to the store. The website and the person taking the order never mentioned the up charge for ordering anything other than pepperoni when ordering their monster pizza. Their pasta also said $13 online and they charged us $19 when we picked it up. The bread sticks were ok but the pasta and pizza were bland and cold when we picked it up. The day we ordered was a Tuesday and according to them they were slow, so being busy was not the issue. If you are used to the location in Logan and want everything made correctly or if you want to feel like you got what you paid for and didn’t waste money on a so so meal. Don’t eat at or order from this location.
Based on the reviews, I figured I would give this place a try. This was the worst pizza I have ever had. When I walked in, only one couple was ahead of me. The restaurant side was empty, and it was 5 p.m. I ordered the Firehouse Combo. They said it would take 15 to 20 minutes, and I thought, "Okay, cool."
I went outside for 10 minutes and came back in, expecting to wait another 10 minutes. I was the only customer in the place, besides the employees. I sat down on one of the red metal chairs. As soon as I sat down, they called my name.
In my experience, with fresh pizza, the box should be warm. But the box was cold, and the pizza wasn’t even cooked—it was just dough and cold. Not to mention, none of the employees handling the pizza were wearing hair nets or any kind of covering. I won’t be coming back here ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Firehouse Combo Pizza
Glynna Todd
The food didn't taste good. They would have forgotten my wings and breadsticks if I hadn't reminded them.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Caden Smith
Paid for dipping sauce and extra topping to the order. Both showed up on the receipt, but neither were in the boxes by the time the pizza was opened @ home. Don’t waste your time, summit is better anyway
Food: 4
Service: 1
Mitchell Kemppainen
Everything tasted good, decided to grab takeout since our view of the water was better at the house.
The food quality during the winter isn’t as good as it is during the summer. Being only 1 of the few places open during the off season, I would probably go somewhere else next time but giving an extra rating since this place is usually pretty okay during the summer time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Meh. Find somewhere else. Over priced, under delivered.
Really tasty pizza. Crust has the amazing balance of fire cooked without tasting like ask or feeling crunchy, but that necessitates it being a little thinner.
We also really liked the little cups of the Alfredo sauce on the side, that stuff is better than the papa johns garlic cups!
There's not much decoration on the wall besides Pepsi ads, but perhaps that's because the focus is on the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
No delivery service
The pizza wasn’t fully cooked. The staff were very unfriendly. I’m a tourist here and so far everyone has been a bit unfriendly. I was looking forward to some good pizza. Sadly, I was disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
People out here during the off season has no respect for people just trying to get out. Pizza was the nastiest that I ever tasted. I don’t understand why people like it out here and 4th time out here and the locals are rude. Never coming out here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We always go here when visiting Bear Lake.
Food is amazing. Staff are always nice. They get very busy and sometimes you have to wait but the 🍕 pizza is fresh and worth the wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was quite Good. Except for minor missunderstanindings between us and the waiter it was a great experience. Very Kind waiters
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Horrible!! The price listed for their monster pizza on their website was totally inaccurate. I called them twice to verify the cost, and they never told it was so much more if you ordered different pizzas. My bill was 40 dollars more than it should have been. I even showed them the price on the website and they did nothing! The pizza was horrible, cold, and almost stale when we ate it, and the one pizza was even missing some toppings! If you are used to firehouse in Logan or just a good pizza in general, DO NOT eat here. Awful service awful food.
Their pizza prices online were different than what we were charged when we got to the store. The website and the person taking the order never mentioned the up charge for ordering anything other than pepperoni when ordering their monster pizza. Their pasta also said $13 online and they charged us $19 when we picked it up. The bread sticks were ok but the pasta and pizza were bland and cold when we picked it up. The day we ordered was a Tuesday and according to them they were slow, so being busy was not the issue. If you are used to the location in Logan and want everything made correctly or if you want to feel like you got what you paid for and didn’t waste money on a so so meal. Don’t eat at or order from this location.
Restaurantji Recommends
best pizza in the valley
Based on the reviews, I figured I would give this place a try. This was the worst pizza I have ever had. When I walked in, only one couple was ahead of me. The restaurant side was empty, and it was 5 p.m. I ordered the Firehouse Combo. They said it would take 15 to 20 minutes, and I thought, "Okay, cool."
I went outside for 10 minutes and came back in, expecting to wait another 10 minutes. I was the only customer in the place, besides the employees. I sat down on one of the red metal chairs. As soon as I sat down, they called my name.
In my experience, with fresh pizza, the box should be warm. But the box was cold, and the pizza wasn’t even cooked—it was just dough and cold. Not to mention, none of the employees handling the pizza were wearing hair nets or any kind of covering. I won’t be coming back here ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Firehouse Combo Pizza
The food didn't taste good. They would have forgotten my wings and breadsticks if I hadn't reminded them.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Paid for dipping sauce and extra topping to the order. Both showed up on the receipt, but neither were in the boxes by the time the pizza was opened @ home. Don’t waste your time, summit is better anyway
Food: 4
Service: 1
Everything tasted good, decided to grab takeout since our view of the water was better at the house.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Montana Pizza
Loading...