19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hyrum

“Tonight 12/12/24 i ordered 4 pizzas and some ranch cups. They did show up with 3/4 pizzas so they were missing one, but the store is fairly close and knew they would bring my missing pizza right back. I made a joke saying hey since you forgot a pizza tell your manager to throw in some bread bites haha well i wont go into detail but i was surprised and my son was thrilled with what they re delivered with our missing pizza. Mistakes happen and i think you really can rate a business on how they handle and react to said mistakes. In my personal opinion and experience with this domines I think they have some of the best customer service in the food industry in the valley. Thank you guys for going above and beyond after forgetting one of our pizzas you guys are awesome and we will absolutely be ordering from you guys again!“

“I have either eaten here, ordered out, had it delivered or worked here in the last two decades. Food is amazing. It always is consistent. They are famous for their breadsticks. They are unlike any other breadstick I’ve had around the state or any other as far as the North West goes. Your salads are yummy and there’s cinnamon bread twists make a great dessert. Come check them out if you haven’t already.“

“After a long day of watching my kid’s soccer team get absolutely destroyed and not necessarily looking forward to the hour and a quarter drive home with a car full of complaining and whining kids about how hungry and thirsty they were I decided to take them to go check out the giant pumpkins at the center street festival.

After 20 minutes of perusing pumpkins and checking out all the street vendors my kids were losing their minds because the hunger pangs were becoming overwhelming. I would dare say they were even becoming hangry.

So we decided we needed to get something to eat pronto. Unfortunately for us none of us could agree on anything which is not unusual for us.

As we were walking back to the car arguing and mumbling and grumbling, we saw a narrow storefront with a picture of a pizza on it. It seemed like a sign from heaven. So we stepped in and were greeted by 6,7 pizza angels at our service.

We ordered our grub and waited a short 10 minutes only to be delighted and filled with the best sourdough pizza we’ve ever had in our lives.

Once the pizza was gone, everyone’s frown turned upside down and all was right with the world again.

Thank you center street pizza.“

“We got our food pretty quick. It was really good. Too“

“What a fantastic pizza experience! I just had the meat lover's pizza and it was outstanding. The ingredients tasted incredibly fresh, and the pizza was full of flavor.
​My wife, who is gluten and dairy-free, was also really impressed. They had a great selection, including a gluten-free crust and vegan cheese. She said both were delicious, which is a huge win. It's rare to find a place that does both so well.
​This is definitely a spot we'll be visiting again!“

“The service was amazing Bradley was the best waiter I’ve ever had! Our food came out so fast and fresh and there was live music making a very fun atmosphere!“

“We went in today to papa Murphy’s about 6:15 and ordered 3 pizzas we stood there for probably 15 minutes while waiting for someone to greet us as we hear two people (male and female) in the back just laughing and talking. Another girl came running in the store from taking her break and instantly apologized and went straight to taking our order and she made all of our pizzas and started an online order all while these two in the back were just bullshitting and laughing and goofing off! I told her how amazing she works and that I see her! That girl deserves a raise! She’s maybe 5’4 130lbs and has brown curly hair! I can’t remember her name but she deserves some praise!“

“Love the new Dill Pickle Pizza!! Don't let the name scare you. It's a perfect balance of all the toppings. Hope to see it on the menu.“

“Great atmosphere, service, food and drinks!“

“I've rated Fredrico's before. It's always good and priced fairly.
True story. My grandkids wanted to eat somewhere that my hubby and I ate at when we were dating in the 60's! Yep!!! Federico's was the cool and only pizza shop in northern Utah! 60+ years of pizza and still going strong!!!“

“We ordered on doordash, AWESOME gluten free pizza! Also yummy crispy Chicken wings!! THANKS for taking the time to explain safe celiac options... Great food, great service!!“

“Shaq appeared to me in my dreams and said if I didn’t leave five stars, he would eat me. He also mentioned that the staff here was incredibly friendly and that this location was his favorite chain pizza place in Cache Valley. He was very specific. And also tall.“

“Best gluten free Deluxe vegetarian pizza and no cheese needed, it's amazing. It only gets better if you can find a coupon code to use for a discount ?

Dietary restrictions: Gluten dairy free and just not adding cheese with so many toppings it was delicious ?“

“The pizza was good as always! However my boyfriend is allergic to certain mushrooms and the chicken Alfredo pizza which he had before without mushrooms had mushrooms this time and when he asked them what kind they were the cook staff didn't know which mushrooms were used.“

“I'm from Ogden and I drive up here to get this pizza. I love it! Especially since the new management took over..“

“We like this place and it’s great place for good cheap pizza. Today however, whoever made our pizza made it absolutely perfect. Our deep dish square is as Detroit style as it can get and it is amazing. Big shout out to the Hungry Howie’s crew. Support this locally owned pizza shop.“

“Ordered the stuff crust to try it out, upon pickup got offered a new pizza because they weren’t happy with how the first one came out. Went above and beyond to make a fresh one that was up to their standards. I’ve ordered many times from this location and they always come through“

“I have Celiac Disease and I'm happy to report that this location of Pizza Pie Cafe is taking precautions to avoid cross contamination! I tested my gluten free pizza with the LEO tester, and it came back less than 10 parts per million! We celebrated my daughter's birthday here, and had the BEST time. Great food, a free Monster Cookie, and balloon animals from Kerri! Thank you PPC!“

“Ordered my pizza online and when I got to the store the system didn’t process my order. They immediately made it and even gave me a free drink. Talk about customer service! Been ordering from this Dominos for a while on almost a weekly basis and they are always wonderful!“