Carisa’s cake company

90 N Main St, Payson
(801) 717-6967

Recent Reviews

Allie Hansen

Carisa’s treats are delicious and totally worth the cost!! She’s the best to work with and has so much talent!!

Chelsey Graff

Carissa makes amazing product. I LOVED her Cake and her homemade Oreo Sammies. I drove over an hour to visit her truck and it did not disappoint. She also makes the most beautiful painted cakes and sugar flowers. And she’s one of the most genuinely caring and hard working individuals I know. I would support her business any day. She’s one of my favorite ways to shop small.

Parker Wootton

My fiancé and I were trying to find someone to make our wedding cake and she stumbled upon Carisacakecompany. After setting up a taste test, we looked no further, this was our gal. However, I didn’t know the Pandora’s box we just opened haha. My fiancé is now obsessed with this cake and more so, the cake truck. This is the best cake I’ve ever had and Carisa is so easy to work with. We’ve had cake made for our wedding, a birthday and have gone 3 times to the cake truck. These goodies make for the best gifts because EVERYONE loves anything that is made. Discovering this cake has been the best part of 2020!

Heather Obray

After trying Carisa's Mrs. Jenkins' Dessert, I'm completely hooked. I have become a frequent customer (groupie) of her darling cake truck. I think her cookies and cakes are the best I've ever had. My favorites are the Coconut Caramel Sammie and her Red Velvet Oreo Cake. My daughter thinks the Mapledoodle Sammie is as close to heaven as you can get, while still on earth.

Jayci Harper

Carisa’s treats are so delicious, everything she makes is simply amazing! You can tell all of the hard work and love that she puts into everything that she makes. If you ever get the chance to go to her food truck, do it!! You won’t regret it! Soo yummy!

Janelle Sorensen

Carissa makes the cutest cakes!

Dean Na

wonderful tasty treats ❣️? great service ? for birthday ? cake and wonderfully flexible with the Best flavors to pick? thank you ???#buylocal #supportsmallbusiness #community #supportlocal

T B.

Fair Warning: Every other treat will be ruined after trying Carisa's Cake Company! Her cake is to die for and the cookie sammies are incredible! You will find yourself not caring to eat any other dessert unless it came from Carisa!

Susanne Peterson Haring

I just tried Mrs Jenkins dessert today. It was delicious. Carisa's treats are the best.

Fran Carrillo

CARISA’s desserts are outstanding. And her cake decorating skills are beyond beautiful

Christine H.

Well we visited her Grand Openlng Truck Location here in Provo on Saturday, May 4th. I had to see what the buzz was all about with this solo-mama business! So I got: chocolate caramel Sammy, chocolate chip Sammy, red velvet cake, chocolate trunch cake, and the raspberry cake. I didn't even wait till I got home to try all of these, as I sat down not too far away from her truck to try all these and give an honest review. First off, Carisa was super sweet, and even gave hugs to her customers waiting in line before she started setting up - which was such a personal grateful gesture. First off, chocolate caramel Sammy: appreciated the chocolate flavor with a not overpowering caramel in it, chewy-and-chocolatey-satisfying! Chocolate chip Sammy: great flavor, also chewy and with colored sprinkles in the dough - my 4 year old really liked it. Red velvet cake: was surprisingly really good, as it seemed like the middle icing (towards the middle) seemed to include some kind of cookies-and-cream icing, next to the regular icing. Chocolate Trunch cake: I love that Carisa used a not-so-sweet chocolate mousse in between the layers of cake, to balance the semi sweet ganache icing (which was also in between the layers of the cake) and the outside layer of icing (which was the sweetest layer). This outside layer of the icing was indeed the sweetest, but it was a thin layer which I really appreciated! Raspberry cake: I'm normally not a fan of yellow cake, but this ended up being my favorite! She had fresh berries mingled in with the icing in between the layers of the cake (reminds me of summer!) The icing she used with this (on the outside) was also thin, but she balanced it out again with the sweet outside icing and underneath this layer was a pink frosting with bits of berries mixed in. The texture of her cakes are a bit more dense, but still presenting to be airy.

Victoria V.

Wow! Talk about the most filling dessert that I have ever had! It was so big and yummy that I got to even save some for later. The cookies had great texture and the frosting was the perfect addition! It was fantastic!!

Saige B.

I tried Carisa's cookies for the first time a couple weeks ago and they are by far my favorite. They are delicious!!

Bree F.

I have been ordering sweets from Carisa for years and have never once been disappointed. Her attention to cake detail and presentation is incredible and they taste even better than they look which is even more impressive. The cinnamon rolls are my all time fav.

Load More