Carol's Pastry Shop

1991 Lincoln St, Salt Lake City
(801) 484-3442

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katie Hansen

I don’t think 5 stars is enough for this place. Let me set the scene for you:

One of my bosses ordered 4 dozen tarts from this bakery to be picked up on Wednesday.
Today, what I thought was Thursday, I thought I had forgotten to pick up the order the day before and I would have to beg for my bosses forgiveness. I was deep within the phases of panic when I pulled up to the bakery (only after I passed it like 3 times —they’re a wee bit hidden and I was not paying attention) just praying that another coworker had picked up the order. Turns out it WAS Wednesday. I had showed up the correct day… but almost an hour early.
The lovely workers still got everything ready so fast, offered me a pastry while I waited, and even helped carry it all to my car. I’ve never met more genuinely kind people than those two.
I apologize to the bakery folks for having to deal with my completely strung-out self, and thank you for being so lovely hand helpful.
Also the pastries were fantastic and so freaking cute!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Gibbons

Gotta try their eclairs! They're AMAZING!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Eclairs, Bakery, Doughnut

Mary McKee

Worst experience ever at a bakery. They didn’t have my Boston cream pie ready when they said they would but the main thing is how bad it was made. Literally no cream in the center. And tasted awful. Nobody even ate it. What a waste of money. I called to let them know and the man literally hung up the phone on me. Stay far away from this horrible bakery.

Atmosphere: 1

Steph G

What’s an amazing Pastry shop, this is my new go-to! The glaze donut in the photo below tastes just like a honey bun and the lemon square was fantastic. Absolutely delish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gary Whipple

Love the food. Excellent eclairs. Just don’t break any unwritten rules. Need to order at least the day before you want something. They get really upset if you come before they tell you to come and they don’t hesitate to let you know about it. Yes I ordered four hours before I showed up to see if by chance it was ready. I was asked if I could wait while they finished the order. If it was going to be so difficult to do why didn’t they just tell me to come back in 2 hours instead of telling me how rude I was to come early, even after I apologize for imposing on them. They are the ones that gave me the option.
Again don’t break any unwritten rules!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Nicole Mujica

The pastries were some of the best we’ve tried, the custard is really good. The service was amazing the person on the front was really nice. I recommend coming here over other shops.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Eclairs, Custard Filled

Justin Marvel

Great food. Guy behind the counter was super friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lorella Smith

They do a good job

Effen M

Best eclairs in SLC.

David P

Wow! This place is a hidden gem. Smells amazing and everything tastes even better.

Marci Sayers

Great prices and the best eclairs! I preordered eclairs for a party. They actually called me to make sure they wouldn't be out for a delivery when I came to pick up. Other customers can be slow at the counter, so there was a wait. This is a no frills, hidden gem. Service, prices and food quality make it worth the drive through traffic. I drove 40 minutes each way to get eclairs for my son's birthday. Worth it!

Brooke McKinnon

Gem of a bakery in the heart of sugar house. Get there early as I arrived around 9:30 am and nearly sold out.

S C

I bought these rolls yesterday. Took a bite today and tasted salty. Turns out rolls have molds all over. It’s not a day old mold. How long do they keep these rolls on the shelf for sale? Disgusting. My daughter already ate two of them.

Mackenzie Wood

A sweet spot in the Sugarhouse neighborhood good enough to bike or walk to. The pleasant service, delicious donuts, and alleyway entrance solidify the charm.

Patricia Tueller

Best chocolate eclairs ever!!!

Loading...