Cute little store front. Lots of items to chose from cupcakes or cookies. The red velvet is one of my favorite.
Vanessa W.
Thank you to this wonderful bakery! I wanted to surprise my brother and sister in law to let them know I was having a baby boy, but I don't live near them, and the staff went above and beyond and helped make this special delivery one to remember!
Sophie R.
Seriously the best cookies, especially the sugar cookies and chocolate chip whoopie pies! They do run out of the good stuff if you go too late, but they also have discounts on Saturday night!
Cheryl D.
Whoever came up with the pumpkin cheesecake bar recipe needs a raise. HOLLLLYYYYYYYY.
Lauren A.
Delicious and beautiful cupcakes! Just happened to stumble across this gem on my way home from work. Their cupcakes are on beautiful display and are creative, very moist, and full of flavor. They have some usuals like red velvet and funfetti but constantly are hanging the menu like key lime pie. Their cake bites are one of my favorites as well (and my husbands too!). This place will always have my sweet tooth business . Gluten free options too!!
Katy J.
After binging Cupcake Wars my hubs decided to surprise me with these. I had varying opinions of each cupcake. The cookie dough and cheesecake one were both really good. Would buy again. The salted caramel and Samoa one were pretty good but I would choose a different one if it appealed to me. The peanut butter one was too rich. I like a more tame accent of peanut butter and this one made me feel like I was eating it straight out of the jar. The Nutella one I couldn't taste Nutella at all. But if it was a fun experience. They weren't anything to rave about but we enjoyed them for a fun mid week treat.
Julia P.
I discovered this place when Utah had that wild wind storm and my roommate and I really wanted something sweet. Everything was closed except for this place. We are so happy with this place! Every Tuesday they have $2 tuesdays where cupcakes are $2 (including the gluten free ones!). I especially love that they have gluten free options and they don't taste dense like all other gluten free pastries. The place seemed clean and the workers are friendly. They are wearing gloves and masks for COVID precautions. :)
mpualani676
Was in the area and wanted to try this place for a quick dessert. I ordered the brownie ala mode. The brownie was so hard I could barely cut it with the edge of my plastic spoon. It was crunchy, and basic tasting. Maybe it was supposed to be like that but it made me feel that it might have been in the case too long. My mother ordered a cake bite. It was hard too. Not sure what is happening here, but with so many other bakery choices in the area, I would skip on this one for now.
Heather H.
This location wasn't as clean as the other locations I've been to, but I'm just happy that it even exists, considering most of the other Sweet Tooth Fairy shops have shut down. There also wasn't much variety. However, I did enjoy the cupcakes that I purchased.In fact, the Reese's Peanut Butter and Chocolate cupcake at this particular location was the best version I've ever tasted. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll definitely be back... and hopefully they'll have their Apple Pie cupcake the next time I'm there!
Julia L.
These are absolutely adorable. The design is well thought out, creative, and beautifully executed. The cake itself was moist and well flavored. I do agree with others' comments that the frosting was way too sweet.
Omg the service here is beyond amazing. I live in Ga an was looking for a bakery to deliver cupcakes to my best friend for her birthday. I found them on Grub hub called them up an told them what I needed.. I was beyond amazed at the customer service. They put extra special touches on the cupcakes an made her day extra special. My bestie said the cupcakes were not only pretty but they were also very delicious. If you haven't tried them pleas do, I promise you won't be disappointed.... Talisha
Julie Nichols Thompson
Picked up cake bites to give the grandkids as they did a drive-by birthday parade for their great-grandma! Put them in individual bags and gave them to the cars as they passed by. Perfect to pop in their mouths without making a mess in the car. They felt like they got a piece of birthday cake! Highly recommend the fairyfetti! Great service and selection. Delicious!
Bri Anderson
The Sweet Tooth Fairy in Salt Lake really delivered on our quarantine birthday cake! SO delicious and beautiful! Couldn’t have asked for more.
Alison Keddington
SERIOUSLY the best cupcakes ever. I will never bake cupcakes again. Mine are so disappointing in comparison.
spencer jacobs
Great service! The salted caramel cookie was delicious.
Cute little store front. Lots of items to chose from cupcakes or cookies. The red velvet is one of my favorite.
Thank you to this wonderful bakery! I wanted to surprise my brother and sister in law to let them know I was having a baby boy, but I don't live near them, and the staff went above and beyond and helped make this special delivery one to remember!
Seriously the best cookies, especially the sugar cookies and chocolate chip whoopie pies! They do run out of the good stuff if you go too late, but they also have discounts on Saturday night!
Whoever came up with the pumpkin cheesecake bar recipe needs a raise. HOLLLLYYYYYYYY.
Delicious and beautiful cupcakes! Just happened to stumble across this gem on my way home from work. Their cupcakes are on beautiful display and are creative, very moist, and full of flavor. They have some usuals like red velvet and funfetti but constantly are hanging the menu like key lime pie. Their cake bites are one of my favorites as well (and my husbands too!). This place will always have my sweet tooth business . Gluten free options too!!
After binging Cupcake Wars my hubs decided to surprise me with these. I had varying opinions of each cupcake. The cookie dough and cheesecake one were both really good. Would buy again. The salted caramel and Samoa one were pretty good but I would choose a different one if it appealed to me. The peanut butter one was too rich. I like a more tame accent of peanut butter and this one made me feel like I was eating it straight out of the jar. The Nutella one I couldn't taste Nutella at all. But if it was a fun experience. They weren't anything to rave about but we enjoyed them for a fun mid week treat.
I discovered this place when Utah had that wild wind storm and my roommate and I really wanted something sweet. Everything was closed except for this place. We are so happy with this place! Every Tuesday they have $2 tuesdays where cupcakes are $2 (including the gluten free ones!). I especially love that they have gluten free options and they don't taste dense like all other gluten free pastries. The place seemed clean and the workers are friendly. They are wearing gloves and masks for COVID precautions. :)
Was in the area and wanted to try this place for a quick dessert. I ordered the brownie ala mode. The brownie was so hard I could barely cut it with the edge of my plastic spoon. It was crunchy, and basic tasting. Maybe it was supposed to be like that but it made me feel that it might have been in the case too long. My mother ordered a cake bite. It was hard too. Not sure what is happening here, but with so many other bakery choices in the area, I would skip on this one for now.
This location wasn't as clean as the other locations I've been to, but I'm just happy that it even exists, considering most of the other Sweet Tooth Fairy shops have shut down. There also wasn't much variety. However, I did enjoy the cupcakes that I purchased.In fact, the Reese's Peanut Butter and Chocolate cupcake at this particular location was the best version I've ever tasted. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll definitely be back... and hopefully they'll have their Apple Pie cupcake the next time I'm there!
These are absolutely adorable. The design is well thought out, creative, and beautifully executed. The cake itself was moist and well flavored. I do agree with others' comments that the frosting was way too sweet.
Restaurantji Recommends
Omg the service here is beyond amazing. I live in Ga an was looking for a bakery to deliver cupcakes to my best friend for her birthday. I found them on Grub hub called them up an told them what I needed.. I was beyond amazed at the customer service. They put extra special touches on the cupcakes an made her day extra special. My bestie said the cupcakes were not only pretty but they were also very delicious. If you haven't tried them pleas do, I promise you won't be disappointed.... Talisha
Picked up cake bites to give the grandkids as they did a drive-by birthday parade for their great-grandma! Put them in individual bags and gave them to the cars as they passed by. Perfect to pop in their mouths without making a mess in the car. They felt like they got a piece of birthday cake! Highly recommend the fairyfetti! Great service and selection. Delicious!
The Sweet Tooth Fairy in Salt Lake really delivered on our quarantine birthday cake! SO delicious and beautiful! Couldn’t have asked for more.
SERIOUSLY the best cupcakes ever. I will never bake cupcakes again. Mine are so disappointing in comparison.
Great service! The salted caramel cookie was delicious.